IS IT A SOUND ARGUMENT?
By Roswell F. Cottrell
“A MAN may be a very bad man inwardly, and yet not transgress outwardly any of the ten commandments, so as to be convicted by man of transgression. “In this respect the law was faulty, and must pass away when the substance is reached. The law is a shadow, not only in its sacrifices, but also in its commandments.”—J. A. Simonds, in Restitution. Are the ten commandments a faulty law, because a man may appear to keep them, and so deceive his fellow-men that they cannot convict him? Is the fault really in the law? Is it not possible that the fault is elsewhere? Mr. Simonds teaches that the law of ten commandments is a shadow. He says, “The shadow was given to regulate the outward conduct. The substance will regulate the intentions of the heart.” He refers to the teaching of Christ as the substance, which shows that he who hates his brother is a murderer, and that he who cherishes impure desire is an adulterer. The law of Christ is faultless, without doubt. But could not a man “be a very bad man inwardly,” could he not be a murderer and an adulterer in his heart, and yet men not be able to convict him of transgression? Can we not then say with equal propriety of the law of Christ, as S. says of the ten commandments, “In this respect the law was faulty, and must pass away”? —Who does not know that the desire and the intention always precede the act of transgression? The commandments of God always required heart obedience. God, who knows the heart, is our judge. David said by the Spirit, “Thy commandment is exceeding broad.” Ps. 119:96. Christ could testify to its breadth, but could make it no broader. The Spirit had testified by David, “The law of the Lord is perfect.” Ps. 19:7. It cannot be made more perfect. Now every sane man who is acquainted with the Bible, knows of himself that God’s moral requirements are the same in every age of the world; that acts which are morally wrong in one age, are morally wrong in every age. They also know that to violate any one of the ten commandments except the fourth, always was, and always must be, sin. They also know that the Sabbath commandment was placed by the finger of God in the midst of this law which can never be violated without sin; and that this commandment, together with the fact that it is generally transgressed, is the only cause why any one makes an attempt to prove that the ten are abolished. The entire war against this law is solely on account of the Sabbath. Now God did distinguish the ten commandments by his own voice and his own finger. And he knew to which class of laws the Sabbath belonged. He made no mistake in the classification. He gave the Sabbath a place in his primary, fundamental law, the constitution of his government. Will they attempt to correct the Almighty? Besides this, they admit that man needs a day of rest and worship, just such an institution as that which they claim that God has abolished, leaving man to supply the need by choosing a substitute. Would to God that their eyes might be opened to see the utter nothingness of their supposed arguments. Is it not worse than folly, is it not blasphemous, to say, “A man may be a very bad man, he may hate his brother, and thus be a murderer according to the teaching of Christ, and yet his neighbors not be able to convict him of sin; therefore the law of God is faulty, and must pass away”? This is the substance of the extract at the head of this article. Is it an argument?