A CRITICISM FROM OVER THE SEA

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 9, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 19.

Read the full edition

A CRITICISM FROM OVER THE SEA.

Eld. J. N. Loughborough sends us the following strictures which an English reader offers upon our view of the third angel’s message, as involving the subject of the two-horned beast of Rev. 13:—
“We have looked through the ‘third message,’ which tries to make out America to be the power symbolized by the two-horned beast of Rev. 13. The argument is a false one. It does not follow because ‘waters’ represent people in one symbolic use, that therefore the ‘earth’ represents country without people. There are various symbolic usages, one of which may be called the typographical, by which the geography of symbolic events is literally indicated, as in the case of the Euphrates. As a rule, the context is a sufficient guide. This rule identifies the two-horned beast rising up out of the earth with a power having origin in the European interior, viz., the Germano-Roman empire, consisting of the joint dynasties of pope and emperor. The fact that it ‘exercised all the power of the first beast’ excludes the notion of its being America, which has no jurisdiction in the Roman habitable, while the fact is that the Germano-Roman empire was the actual successor of the Roman imperialism. As for the westward path of empire, the four empires successively ruled the same territory, with which America has nothing to do.”
The application of the symbol of the two-horned beast to America does not rest wholly, nor chiefly, upon the contrast between the sea and the earth in the prophecy. This is only one of the incidental evidences; but it certainly possesses some significance. The sea might be used symbolically in one prophecy and the earth in another, without suggesting any contrast. But here both symbols appear in the same prophecy; one beast arises out of the sea, and the one immediately following rises out of the earth. We know what the sea was designed to symbolize. It was peoples, multitudes, nations, and tongues; and the Roman-papal beast was developed in lands teeming with just such multitudes. But the two-horned beast arose where such multitudes did not exist, as otherwise that too would be said to have come up out of the sea. It came up out of the earth, language which is certainly designed to suggest a contrast; but the only conceivable contrast is that to be drawn between the densely populated territory of Europe, and a virgin territory previously unknown to, and unoccupied by, civilization, as was America when Europeans first obtained a foothold here.
The argument of our friend that the Germano-Roman empire is intended, we pronounce in his own language, a false one, for these reasons:— 1. The two-horned beast is “another” beast; that is, it is not any nation symbolized by the Roman beast or any of its parts. But this symbol with its ten horns (ten kingdoms) took in all central and western Europe and northern Africa; and all eastern Europe and western Asia had been appropriated by preceding symbols. Any power arising in that territory would have been one of the horns, or some part of that first beast, and not “another” beast, as the two-horned beast was. 2. The two-horned beast was not to appear in the part assigned to it in the prophecy, till the close of the forty-two months of the first beast. But we may apply the forty-two months, or twelve hundred and sixty years, of the supremacy of the first beast, as we please, it was the combination of emperors and popes, or the union of Church and State, that caused that supremacy; hence that combination could not be symbolized by a beast which did not arise till after that period of supremacy was ended.
The argument in reference to the power which the two-horned beast was to exercise, is equally faulty. He was to exercise all the power of the first beast before him, that is, in his presence. But it is his own power and not the power of the first beast which he exercises; the expression, “all the power of the first beast,” meaning simply power to the same extent, and perhaps of the same kind. And he can do this without any connection, political or even ecclesiastical, with the first beast.
“Westward the star of empire takes its way.” This is a too-universally acknowledged fact to be questioned or argued. While it is true that of the four great empires of Daniel 2 and 7, each one occupied the territory of all the preceding, each had territory peculiarly its own while in power. Thus with Grecia, the seat of empire was west of any territory occupied by Babylon and Persia. Rome was west of Grecia. The ten horns represent powerful kingdoms west of the ancient Roman seat of power. In the eastern hemisphere, the ruling nations were once on the banks of the Euphrates; now they are in the extreme west of Europe; while still onward, beyond the ocean, in the western hemisphere, where less than three hundred years ago was only an unexplored wilderness, a nation has arisen to commanding influence in a space of time so marvellously short as to be utterly incredible did we not see the demonstration before our eyes. It is hardly supposable that this nation would receive no mention in prophecy.