LAW AND PENALTY

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 13, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 24.

Read the full edition

LAW AND PENALTY.

ABOUT the weakest of all weak things supposed to be an argument, is that which claims that the Sabbath is abolished, because the penalty of death for its violation is no longer in force, as it was with the Jewish nation. Eld. J. Litch, in his tract on “The Law of the Sabbath,” takes up this idea as follows: “A law without a penalty is void, it cannot be enforced. As they stand in Ex. 20, the ten commandments are powerless, for they have no annexed penalty.” Further he says, “But in Ex. 31:14 we have a statute and judgment to enforce the fourth commandment.” This text says that the one who should defile the Sabbath should be put to death. Eld. Litch continues: “While this statute and judgment was in force, the commandment was in force.” So he claims that this law is void, because it is without a penalty.
But what about the other nine? A number of them had the same penalty attached. Are the commandments forbidding idolatry, profanity, murder, and adultery “powerless,” “entirely inoperative,” because there is now no earthly judiciary and executive to enforce the death penalty? If the Sabbath is not now binding for this reason, neither are the others. It may be said that obedience to the others is taught in the New Testament. But the New Testament was not written, especially the epistles of the apostles, for many years after the crucifixion, when that which was to pass away was nailed to the cross. If one of the commandments written in tables of stone was nailed to the cross, it is evident that all of them were; and thus again “the world was then without divine law, and did as they pleased,” till the apostles gathered up, one by one, the scattered fragments of the old, abolished law, all that were worth saving, to be the rules by which men were to live thereafter. And yet, failing to appoint a judiciary and executive to enforce them by pains and penalties, they have left them all powerless and inoperative! This is not my language, dear reader. Who would not “blush and hang his head” to think he belonged to a race that could speak thus lightly of the law of God? Holy and reverend is his law, as well as his name; and his distinctive characteristic, as the Maker of all things, is found only in the fourth commandment of the ten.
And it is of this moral code that the Lord Jesus said, “Verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law.” So it is recognized as a whole in the gospel, and is laid as a foundation upon which the gospel is built; for by the law is the knowledge of sin, for which the gospel offers pardon through repentance and faith.
Is the world without law, because the church is not authorized to inflict the penalty upon transgressors? Did men ever inflict the penalty of the law of God? The Lord says, “When a righteous man turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, and dieth in them; for his iniquity that he hath done shall he die.” Eze. 18:26. Did man ever inflict this second death? —Death is the wages of sin; and from the second death there is no resurrection. There is a penalty for the violation of the law of God. May the reader and the writer escape it.
R. F. COTTRELL.