College Government

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 1, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 31.

Read the full edition

College Government.

An article on this subject by P. H. Mell, D. D., LL. D., published in Barnard’s American Journal of Education, contains some thoughts which are well worthy of consideration by all interested in school enterprises. Discipline is one of the most delicate as well as one of the most important matters to be dealt with in the management of an educational institution. Different methods are adopted by different ones to accomplish the desired end. Which is the best method is the important question to be decided. To this question the writer gives an answer drawn from thirty years experience. Of the repressive method he says:—
It virtually announces to the students that the authorities have, and can have, no confidence in them; and that it is their intention to govern them by vigilance and espionage and the arts of the detective chiefly, if not alone. The issue tendered is, of course, accepted by the students, and the normal state between teachers and students is that of antagonism. The students, on their part, cordially reciprocate the implied expression of confidence withheld. No social relations exist between them and the faculty. Indeed, for one of their number to cultivate terms of intimacy with any member of the faculty is to lose caste with his fellows, and to be treated by them as one who has treasonably gone over to the enemy. With war virtually declared, and lines of battle virtually drawn—with a score of men on one side pledged to enforce order, and hundreds on the other tempted to thwart such an irritating and unnecessary use of force, the natural result ought not to be doubtful. Vigilance will be met by vigilance; and hundreds of young men can, to say the least, be just as vigilant, adroit, and untiring as a score of old men. Blows inflicted by one side will be certain to provoke and secure the return of characteristic blows by the other. A successful raid now by the governing power will be resented by the comrades of the victims; and there will be perpetrated, at unexpected times and in unexpected places, annoyances, public and private, that college-boy genius, stimulated by the quasi state of war, is competent to invent and execute. “College smiles,” tin-pan serenades, and pistol fusillades make night hideous; while gates and fences and vehicles and merchants’ signs mark the ravages of war. On the other hand, an unsuccessful raid to make a reconnaissance, to abate a nuisance, or to capture a prisoner, provokes merriment; and fun, reinforcing resentment, intensifies the difficulty and multiplies the disorder. Temptations will be piled to induce the officer to make the abortive effort over again; and numberless baits will be thrown out and ingenious expedients offered to entice to impracticable enterprises. If the officer makes no effort at all, he will be an object of contempt; if he makes what must inevitably be abortive attempts, he becomes the butt of ridicule.
But, I may be asked, shall all college government be disbanded, and the young men be permitted to do as they please? Shall college officers be released from all responsibility for the morals and deportment of the boys—not men, always, in this country—committed to their care? Better abolish all the institutions rather than that the youth in them, for want of restraint, should go to ruin. The question is not whether such institutions can dispense with college government, but rather which is the best and most effective form of it. In the opinion of the writer of this paper,

THE TRUE SYSTEM OF COLLEGE GOVERNMENT

Is that which relies upon and employs influence chiefly rather than authority; which seeks the confidence of the young men and gains their hearts; which inspires them with self-respect, and seeks to control them by making them control themselves. The system here advocated would avoid antagonisms, and secure kind, social relations between professors and students, by inspiring mutual confidence and respect among all the members of the college community. It would segregate the students as much as possible, by scattering them among the families of the town—subjecting them to the home-like influences of the household, and the conservative influences, daily exercised, of virtuous female society. Of course, this implies that there is nothing of just authority to be sacrificed, or anything of college law to be ignored or disregarded; for the college faculty or officer that permits students with impunity to trample under foot college law, or to fail to come up to college requirement, is contemned and despised, and cannot possibly be a party to administering the system of influence here advocated. I speak in favor of an influence which controls men—which, for that very reason, is a method of intentional government. Impotency, and indifference that takes its ease, are in no danger of being mistaken for the thing referred to. But pretension, and bluster, and ostentatious self-assertion enter in no respect into that influence which controls men. He is the best manager of men who, while doing it, does not seem to do so; but who, a genuine man himself, and unselfish, brings himself and his processes into harmony with human nature in general, and with the peculiarity of those with whom he has to deal, and then without ostentation,—if possible, without self-consciousness,—furnishes the occasion and applies the impulse to men, to make them manage themselves—rightly.
Let the college authorities gain the hearts of the young men, and command their confidence, and there will be no intentional disorder by day or by night, singly or in combination. This state of feeling existing, there will be no danger, excepting that which may result from personal vices, contracted at the university or college, or brought there from home. This is a specific danger and difficulty, to be met by a specific qualification in the college officer, and by a specific treatment in the administration of college discipline. The faculty must make themselves acquainted with the character and habits of every student, and must be able to discover at once the first departure from the path of rectitude. The student should find himself arraigned immediately after the commission of any vicious act, or the performance of anything tending in that direction; and thus be convinced that he cannot proceed in this way with impunity. No doubt it is difficult thus to make discoveries, but it is not impossible; and he who finds it so should not hesitate to conclude that his talents fit him better for any other position than that of administrator of college discipline. Certain it is that it is easier to make such discoveries under the system I advocate than under that against which I am arguing. When a young man pursues a course so vicious or insubordinate as to make it necessary ultimately to sever his connection with the university or college, I would, if possible, subject him to two reformatory processes before the final act.
1. When the young man is detected in his first aberration, then an opportunity is given to the college officer to wield a personal influence over him that may tend to reform him and to secure his permanent continuance in the right way. For college discipline should never be vindictive or retributive, but simply corrective. When a parent commits his son to a college officer, the latter should treat the boy exactly as he would wish another to treat his own son in like circumstances. If the young man goes astray, he should be plied with a discipline intended and calculated to correct and reform. With gentleness and kindness the boy should be shown his wrong and his danger. If he gives evidence that he realizes them, and promises in satisfactory tone and terms to abandon forever the wrong way, let the officer frankly accept the pledge and promise to keep his secret, divulging it not even to the faculty, provided that they have not themselves discovered it, and in that case pledging them also to secrecy. But let him frankly inform the culprit that the slightest aberration in the same or a kindred direction will make it necessary for his conduct, with all the incidents and the aggravations of it, to be reported to his parents. And this brings me to the second reformatory process I would use in college discipline.
2. Should the young man be detected in repeating the offense, or, indeed, in the perpetration of any disorder, let the officer gently but firmly decline to accept any more promises as a reason why he should proceed no further. Let him with manner at once kind and frank say to the offender that his parents must be informed of all the facts of the case. Indeed, it has been according to my experience that it is best to read to the young man the letter of information about to be sent to his parents; for the officer should say nothing about the student behind his back. Now, this course will have one of two effects—it will either humble or exasperate; and thus the officer can proceed to subsequent steps intelligently. If the parent co-operates, and the young man is saved, the officer will have administered college government successfully, by enforcing effective corrective discipline.
But in the event that all the processes fail, then the way is opened, and the minds of all parties prepared for the final act. And it is a great point gained if the college officer has furnished the occasion for the parent of the young man to justify and sustain him in the final and decisive act.
But in the event that all the reformatory methods fail, and that the boy be found to be hopelessly vicious or impracticable, even then there is no occasion for passion or resentment; nor any reason why he should be publicly humiliated and disgraced. Let his parent be requested to withdraw him, or the young man himself be advised quietly to retire. Let the officer promise him that he will throw no difficulty in the way of his joining another college, but rather encourage him to do so, assuring him that he will watch his career with interest, prepared to rejoice at the evidences of his reformation and success in life. If college discipline cannot benefit, it should not damage, certainly not ruin the subjects of it.
Thus far I have spoken only of irregularities and vices. In cases where students are guilty of notorious crimes, or where their vices or even irregularities have brought public scandal upon them or the institution, the treatment would of necessity be different.
I respectfully offer the above as my opinion as to the form, the method, and the spirit of the true college government. Nor is my conviction the result of mere theory, destitute of experience. I have been a college officer thirty-eight years. Twenty years of that time I assisted earnestly and honestly in the administration of the dormitory system; but it is my honest conviction that the system based upon influence is the only true method of college government, and the only one that can approximate to success.