THE CLOSING OF OUR COLLEGE.
It is always pleasant to speak of the prosperity of the cause, the rapid extension of our work, and of the growth and good standing of our institutions, and very unpleasant to every one who truly loves the cause to speak of the opposite. As a general rule, it is better to think as little as possible about the discouraging things we have to meet. When we know we have the truth of God, and are engaged in his special work, we want to look forward, and not backward. We want to forget as soon as possible the unpleasant things that are behind, and reach forth to the duties that are before us, and press forward to the mark of the high calling of God in Christ Jesus. But there are occasional exceptions to this general rule, to which the attention of our people must be called, because we have duties connected with them which have to be considered, and obstacles to be overcome, in order that the cause may prosper in the future. Such a case is the closing of the College the present season.
There are a great many among us who have not been ignorant for months past of the fact that there was trouble in connection with our College. The Board of Directors, of whom the writer is one, have until recently hoped that matters might be arranged, and the school go on this year as usual, though we had many difficulties to confront. If this could be done, we greatly desired to leave all in blissful ignorance of our troubles who did not already know them. We have been forced to meet these difficulties for six months or more, and yet have said nothing of them in print. But now, since the decision has been made that the College should be closed for the present, it seems necessary that something be said. Inquiries have been pouring in upon us concerning the present status. These we cannot answer singly without a great amount of labor. Many others are anxiously waiting to learn what is to be done, so that they may understand what course to pursue. Distorted statements have gone here and there from pupils who were not prepared to present the matter in a true light. Under these circumstances, we deem it best to make a brief statement.
Our College was brought into existence for a special purpose. Excellent schools are plentiful in all directions, controlled by other denominations or established by the State. Though furnishing needful instruction in the sciences, they failed in some respects to furnish what we needed. We wanted a school where the truths of the Bible relating to this time should be taught, and our young people fitted to act a part in this work, either as teachers, missionaries, or ministers. We felt that the influence in the schools of our land was worldly, and tending toward skepticism and infidelity, and that we needed to have a college where science could be learned without endangering the soul’s salvation; one, in short, where a strong religious influence should prevail, calculated to lead toward God, and away from the corruptions of modern society. We hoped to have a school where discipline, order, and thoroughness of instruction, should prevail; and where frivolity, pride, vanity, and premature courting, could be mainly shut out.
For several years, we flatter ourselves, our College did comparatively a good work, though having a constant battle with opposing influences. A goodly number of our young men who attended the College went from it to preach the truth, and some of these are among our most efficient ministers. But for a few years past a cloud has been gathering, which has threatened wholly to destroy its usefulness in those special directions for which it was created. During the last year these influences have seemed to culminate, and a state of things has been reached which calls for decided action.
There never has been that cordial co-operation with the authorities of the College on the part of a portion of the church that there should have been in order to secure the best results. It required a constant effort to maintain the right influences in the College. Those who have maintained right discipline, and the proper religious influence in the College, have not been sustained by many in the church, but their work has been made hard and only partially successful. With favoring circumstances and surroundings, it is a difficult task to manage successfully hundreds of students full of animal life, naturally careless about religious matters, and not realizing what they most need. The spirit of the present age is opposed to thoroughness of discipline and instruction. Present ease and pleasure are principally desired. But the task becomes almost impossible, when the College is surrounded by a community which does not sustain heartily those placed in authority. The students very soon find out where the sympathies of the people are with whom they board and associate. The spirit which prevails without comes within, and right influences are weakened, and wrong ones strengthened. Latterly, there have been an alarming number of cases of young persons attending our College, who went there with the purpose of giving themselves to the work of God in some of its departments; but have lost all such desires while attending our school, going away full of pride and vanity, tinctured with skepticism, and lost to the cause. Startled by these things, the patrons of our College, when looking about for the causes of such results, find that there are influences centering at Battle Creek which for the present make it unsafe to send our young people there. Many of the young people living there—the children of Sabbath-keepers—are irreligious and skeptical, and opposed in heart to all proper discipline. They have had their own way, and are determined to have it, and hate restraint. Their influence upon scholars brought in contact with them is most pernicious. We fear that many souls have been ruined by this state of things.
The policy of the school has been gradually changing, becoming more and more like that of the worldly schools around it. This, of course, is the natural tendency unless a strong religious influence is maintained. Teachers and pupils, unless consecrated to God and blessed with spiritual discernment, want such a result. Pride and vanity naturally come in. The past year this tendency has been more marked. New policies have prevailed. The discipline has been lowered. Insubordination became manifest among students, and to some degree among teachers also. And matters came to a crisis. The Board of Directors whom the stockholders placed in control found themselves powerless to hold in check these influences, unless they virtually closed the College in the middle of the school year. A majority of the Faculty, sustained by a large portion of the church, threatened to resign in a body, if certain measures taken by the Board were not retracted. Mass meetings of the students were held to sustain their favorites in the Faculty. When some of these teachers were asked to resign by the Board, they refused to do so. The Board would no doubt have been justified in discharging these at once; but considering the prevailing excitement, and the fact that these students had come long distances at great expense to attend the College, they thought it best to let the school go on till the close of the year. The Board virtually had nothing to do with the management of the College for months during the past year.
We have been aware that our moderation has made us to be despised by the elements we have referred to; but, on the whole, we have considered it best to coolly and calmly await the lapse of time, and appeal to the sober second thought of our people. The tide ran so high that those teachers who had done most in founding the College lost their influence, and were looked upon with dislike. Their lot was made very hard, and stories were circulated against some of them which were calculated to ruin their reputation as Christians, and even as moral men, and these have been circulated through the land. A large element in the church sustained this course. The Board had no power to overcome these influences, the fact that they withstood them cutting off almost entirely their influence with the church and the students, on account of the intense prejudice and bitterness which prevailed. The General Conference Committee had no greater influence, for the same reason.
When the matter of opening the College the present year came before the Board for consideration, we were thrown into great perplexity. We could see little ground of hope for such a school as the Lord had shown we ought to have, while the present state of things existed. Teachers of experience, who had labored in the school successfully in the past, and who were forced out of it by the unjust course pursued toward them, did not feel willing to go back while such a state of feeling existed, nor would it have been proper to urge them to do so. We saw none coming up to take their place who gave reasonable promise of successfully managing our College in such a condition of things. Matters looked discouragingly dark; yet the Board did their best to find teachers, and actually engaged several. But our way seemed hedged up before us, and we could see no reasonable ground to hope for such a school as would meet the mind of the Spirit of God. Though sharp testimonies of reproof were given to the church for the course they have pursued, no great change of public sentiment was discernible. The same evil influences which have made this an unsafe place to which to send our children, still existed.
After carefully viewing the matter from every standpoint, the Board finally decided to close the College. We cannot express the feelings of sadness and distress that we felt before we could bring ourselves to this decision. Months of anxious thought and prayer passed ere we could bring ourselves to the point of proclaiming to the world that our College was closed because of troubles among us. This is a most humiliating step for us to take. It will cause our enemies to rejoice, and cause sadness all through our ranks. But it is preferable to the state of things existing some months in the past.
We are receiving inquiries as to future prospects, and whether there is any probability of the College opening in the near future. Of course it would be improper for the present Board to speak of what will be done after their term of office expires. What our successors in office may do, it is not for us to say. The stockholders will doubtless consider this whole matter carefully, and place upon the Board those who sustain their views. Whether they will indorse the views of the present Board, time will determine.
As an individual, I feel free to say I do not believe the College will ever open again in Battle Creek till there is a radical change in the feelings of that church, and they decidedly condemn the course they have pursued in the recent past, and until the state of things there is such, and the moral atmosphere so cleared, that our youth from different parts of the field may come there with reasonable hope of moral benefit rather than moral injury. While we feel that we have been morally forced to close the College because of the existing state of things, and thus are made to suffer the mortification and anguish which such a step has cost in publishing these humiliating facts to the world, we cannot see how it would be justifiable to open it again without marked evidence of improvement.
We greatly mistake the sentiment of our people, if they do not take a decided stand against this spirit in the church and Faculty which has overridden the authority of those in whose hands they intrusted the welfare of their College; and if they do not take measures to sustain those principles in the management of the College which it was originally created to carry out, we are equally mistaken. If this cannot be done in Battle Creek, it must be done elsewhere. The purpose of God in calling this institution into existence will not be thwarted. If the church of Battle Creek permit such influences to live and thrive there as make it dangerous to the welfare of those who come to attend the College, they will simply deprive themselves of the benefits of its influence, as well as bring a disgrace and loss upon the cause. We do not believe our people will ever sustain any institution whose influence becomes more injurious than beneficial. The church at Battle Creek are specially interested in this question, and should solemnly consider the present condition of things and the influences which have prevailed to bring it about. We are deeply impressed that this is a matter of momentous importance.
In speaking as we have concerning the Battle Creekp. 587 church we do not wish to have it understood that we include all the members of the church. Far from it. There are some of the most devoted Christians living in this place of any we know in the cause. They are trying faithfully to exert a good influence; but they cannot control the influences centering here, which have produced the results we have mentioned. With great pain we make these statements. We might have said much more and kept within the bounds of truth; but we desire to be as brief as possible and give our people some idea of the state of affairs connected with the closing of our College, and of its future prosperity. We ask the stockholders carefully and prayerfully to consider them, and act in the coming annual meeting in such a manner as will best subserve the interests of this important institution and the cause we love.
Geo. I. Butler, Chairman Board of Directors.
We the undersigned, members of the Board of Trustees of the S. D. A. Educational Society, fully indorse the above statement.
C. W. Stone.
A. B. Owen.
H. W. Kellogg.
W. C. Sisley.
J. H. Kellogg.