The Rev. Stephen H. Tyng, Jun., lately the rector of the Church of the Holy Trinity in this city, and at present an agent in Europe of an American life-insurance company, is the defendant in a curious suit at law. The suit is brought for a balance due the plaintiff on account of certain speculations in stocks, made while the defendant was still exercising his clerical functions, and in which he had ventured some eight thousand dollars. Of course, we do not propose to discuss the merits of this suit. In fact, what may be called the social interest of the case depends not upon the disputed, but upon the undisputed facts of the case, for the fact of the speculations is not denied.
The moral question involved in speculation in stocks seems to us too simple to be sophisticated, except by a man who has an interest in deceiving himself. Investment is one process; speculation is another. Any man, and a clergyman as well as any other, has the right and the duty to buy with his savings whatever he thinks will yield him the largest and most secure returns. If he foresees that certain property will be worth more than its present price, as the result either of his own labors or of the labors of others, he is fully entitled to the profit which accrues from his foresight. But the “operator” “on a margin” buys nothing but a right to secure the profits of such a fictitious advance as he believes will be brought about by his own manipulation or by that of somebody else. About the intrinsic or ultimate value of what he is buying he knows or cares nothing whatever. He “buys what he doesn’t want, and sells what he hasn’t got.” Securities are to him simply things to bet upon. He arrives at a belief that a certain stock is going up or down, as he might arrive at a belief that a certain card is to turn up at faro, or the ball to fall into a certain compartment of the wheel at roulette. What but simple gambling is the “backing” of an opinion like this? If he believes that he knows how the cards have been arranged or the wheel “fixed,” does that fact heighten the dignity of his moral attitude? In gambling-houses persons believed to be privy to the arrangement of the cards or of the wheel are excluded with every circumstance of ignominy. In spite of this moral advantage which gambling-houses seem to enjoy over the Stock Exchange, clergymen and respectable laymen would object to be found taking “flyers” in gambling-houses, which, indeed, only remain open on sufferance, and because the police prefer to ignore them; while no moralist has hitherto proposed to “pull” the Stock Exchange.
That the business of the Stock Exchange has little more relation to productive industry or to legitimate investment than the prohibited business of unlegalized gambling-houses may be easily made evident. An experienced and successful broker was not long ago asked what proportion of the business of the Stock Exchange was its legitimate business of furnishing a market for investment in securities. His answer was that an estimate of ten thousand shares a day would without doubt be extravagant. The business of the Stock Exchange reached at that time a volume of six hundred thousand shares a day. Of this vast business, of which the brokerage alone amounted to $150,000, the legitimate nucleus and pretext, according to this expert, was a trifle more than one and a half per cent. Investment was to speculation as sixteen to a thousand. The daily business of the Exchange during recent months has averaged about half this extraordinary figure, say three hundred thousand shares a day. At this rate, the whole capital represented by all the securities dealt in upon the Exchange is “turned over” between three and four times a year, for the yearly business would reach the inconceivable total of nine thousand millions. Supposing the investment demand to remain constant at the “extravagant” estimate just given of ten thousand shares a day, the “speculative” demand is responsible for the nominal transfer of $8,700,000,000, of which one-tenth part is actually at risk “on a margin,” to be multiplied or “wiped out,” as the case may be, and in any case to be reduced by the constant attrition of brokers’ commissions, at the trifling rate of a quarter of one per cent to the two brokers engaged in each transaction, to the extent of $22,500,000 annually. In other words, the “lambs” of this country are risking money in mere and sheer gambling, through the New York Stock Exchange alone, at the rate of eight hundred and seventy millions a year.
These are appalling figures. Of course it is necessary to make some rather violent assumptions in order to arrive at them, such as that all sales reported are genuine, and that all stocks are at par, and it is impossible to give the figures accurately. But after all possible abatements are made, they remain appalling. The country is rich, as all of us keep on all the while telling each other, but is it rich enough to stand the like of this? For all this money risked and wasted, lost and won, has somewhere and by somebody been actually earned, dug out of the ground, or drawn from the forests or the sea. It is part of the surplus of the productive industry of the country. But it is not the pecuniary but the moral aspect of all this that is most depressing. Think what a proportion of this money comprises the whole hoards and long accumulations of those who have put it at risk! Think of the unwholesome excitement the risk involves, of the contempt of regular industry it induces, and then say wherein it is intrinsically more respectable, or ought to be socially more reputable, or legally more permissible, than the undisguised gambling of the faro-bank.
Whoever is tempted to risk his savings in stock speculations may profitably turn these considerations over in his mind before yielding to the temptation. There is a stirring discourse waiting to be preached to our generation from the ancient text of Solomon, “He that maketh haste to be rich shall not be innocent.” Those whom Solomon’s admonition would not suffice to deter from gambling in stocks, may yet be deterred by the moral which so many stories of stock speculation also bear, that he that maketh haste to be rich shall not necessarily be rich either.—Harper’s Weekly.