Dr. Abbott and Conditional Immortality

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 29, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 35.

Read the full edition

Dr. Abbott and Conditional Immortality.

One of the most important events that have recently transpired in the theological world is an editorial in a late number of the Christian Union, in which Dr. Lyman Abbott, the well-known editor of that paper, announces his belief in the probability of the doctrines of conditional immortality and the destruction of the wicked. Although the article is long, our readers will doubtless be glad to read it entire, together with the letter which called it out.
“In your various articles concerning the teachings of the Scriptures with regard to future punishment, I notice that you always declare that they do not teach that there shall be an end of punishment, and, therefore, that all men shall become, finally, holy and happy. Your reiterated assertion, therefore, is that the Scriptures do not teach Universalism. The more I read these wonderful writings, the more I am amazed at your earnest and oft-repeated declarations. May I therefore ask you to explain two passages: ‘And I, if I be lifted up, will draw all men unto me.’ ‘And when all things shall be subdued unto him, then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all.’
“For my part, I do not need these and similar passages to convince me that God punishes his children in order to improve them, and therefore the end—improvement, holiness—will finally be attained. The Master taught that God is our Father. If he is our Father, he will not make punishment endless. The Master gave us the parable of the Prodigal Son. Its teaching is that punishment, at last, will cause the sinner to ‘come to himself,’ and that then he will go to the Father, and the Father will receive him. I stand with Stopford Brooke. He says: ‘If there is endless punishment, then there is no Heavenly Father.’ I stand with James Freeman Clarke. He says the parable of the Prodigal Son sufficiently explains the question of punishment. And when I read ‘Salvator Mundi,’ written by the Rev. Samuel Cox, an English Trinitarian Congregationalist, then I wonder how you, or any one else, can say that the Scriptures do not teach the final holiness and happiness of all men. A ‘master in Israel,’ you have pondered this question deeply. Many times before I have been prompted to address you in order to express my amazement at your conclusion. Your recent editorial on Andover has added power to my impulse. Under its influence I send you these fraternal words. Cordially yours,
“HENRY BLANCHARD, “Pastor of Shawmut Universalist Church. “Boston, Mass.”
“This fraternal letter I welcome with the same cordiality with which it was sent. We are both students of the same mystery, disciples in the same school, and may well help one another toward a larger light. I have no desire to conceal my convictions on this subject, nor even my doubts and questionings.”
“The problem of the future is approached by men of every school who are sure what God will do, who even assert with assurance what he must do. To me it is shrouded with mystery; I approach it with awe; I cannot assert what God will do, still less what he ought to do; I understand too little this awful mystery of sin. What it is, what its nature, whence its origin, what is the ever-shifting line which separates between crime and disease, what almighty love can do for the deliberately, persistently wicked; what all-wise justice must do for the protection of the innocent; what possibilities of redemption there are in any human soul; what reserves of mercy in God’s omnipotent love; what awful power there is in the human soul to reject all love, even the love of the Almighty; what limits there are to the power of love, even the omnipotent love of God—all this I know not, and not knowing, I cannot dogmatize; I cannot be sure; I look out into the great unknown future with beating heart in silence, and I fear and hope and wonder.”
“1. Many Christians regard the Bible as a clear and comprehensive revelation concerning God and divine government, which contains the whole truth concerning him and his purposes, so that, humbly studied and heartily believed, it will furnish a complete science of God and divine things. I do not so understand the Bible. It appears to me to be simply a book of practical directions for godly living in this present life. It tells enough about God to draw out the heart in love toward him; enough about his will to enable us to show our love by our obedience; enough about the future to furnish motives of hope and fear to re-enforce the larger motive of love. We sail upon an ocean whose further bounds are far beyond our sight. The Bible gives every soul a course to sail by; follow this course, it says, and you will reach harbor; follow any other, and you will come to shipwreck. But what that harbor is, and what possibilities of rescue at the last from shipwreck there may be, it tells not. The wise father neither promises nor threatens; he leaves his children to understand that obedience brings happiness, disobedience suffering. God governs his children as a wise father; and to all our questionings, ‘What pay for doing right?’ ‘What penalty for doing wrong?’ keeps a silence that is more eloquent than speech. The Bible contains no clear revelation respecting the nature of either eternal life or eternal death. It discloses nothing to curiosity. We can gather from its intimations some probable conclusions; but every kind of dogmatism respecting the eternal future is unscriptural. Not until the church furnishes a prophet who can foretell the rewards of virtue or the penalties of sin which God will award to a single individual next year, shall I accept the foretellings of its would-be prophets concerning the rewards and penalties which he will award at the further end of eternity.”
“2. The Scriptures, especially the New Testament, do, however, contain intimations addressed to both fear and hope; the one seems to me to awaken well-grounded fear of a hopeless doom; the other, well-grounded hope of a perfected redemption.”
“It is impossible within the compass of a newspaper article to group the words of Christ and his apostles which foreshadow the awful fact that sin is sometimes incorrigible; that it is within the power of the human will to set at defiance the divine love; that a human will, set to do evil, can resist all the gracious influences of a divine will seeking to save the soul from its own undoing. If I were a John Calvin Calvinist I should be a Universalist. If I believed that it is in the power of God to coerce a virtuous choice from a free moral agent, I should be sure that he would. A study of life and a study of Scripture both forbid. God influences, but does not compel; he entreats, but does not coerce; he knocks at the heart, but will not break in; he will have children, not slaves; love, not obedience; and love is not compelled and cannot be. If he is a Father he will receive every child that love can draw and sorrow can drive to him; but he will not go after the fugitive with blood-hounds, and bring him back in chains. This seems to me to be the teaching of the New Testament, especially the teaching of Christ himself. He is not a Master come to capture by force men who have no choice; he is a friend come to capture by persuasions men who have a fatal power to resist, and whose resistance is soul-suicide, eternal death. This terrible fact—man’s power of resistance to all gracious influences—seems to me to underlie all Christ’s life and teachings, his arguments, entreaties, persuasions; his incarnation, his tears, his nights of prayer, his Gethsemane agony, his breaking heart, his tragic death, his descent into Hades in merciful quest of the lost, his resurrection, his perpetual intercession, his ever-living presence with his church. All this would be meaningless unless man is in a true sense the arbiter of his own destiny, and God is pleading before him to enter into life eternal. The terrible possibility of a hopeless fate gives pathos to the sorrowful tones of the Pleader’s voice. It appears in his explicit declaration that the wicked go away into eternal punishment; that they are left at last in the outer darkness; that they are cast into the fire of Gehenna; that they lose their own soul; that they may sin a sin which shall not be forgiven, neither in this world nor in the world to come. It re-appears in reiterated type and metaphor. They are guests arriving too late for the marriage feast and are shut out, and the feast goes on without them; they are chaff to be burned with fire, useless fish to be cast away, fruitless trees to be hewn down and burned to ashes, bankrupts consigned to perpetual imprisonment, rebels slain before the throne of their king. So terrible is this death-doom that any maiming, though it were as the cutting off of the right hand and the plucking out of the right eye, is to be preferred. If I turn to the epistles, their language seems to me scarcely less explicit; the wicked are without God, and therefore without hope; their sentence is death, their end destruction, their punishment everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord. I am not unaware of the interpretations which Universalist scholars give to these and kindred words of awful warning. I could perhaps accept explanations of isolated verses. But I am sure my correspondent will not understand me as impugning the honesty of other Biblical students when I say that I could not with honesty accept the authority of Christ’s teachings for myself and still preach ‘an eternal hope.’ The possibility of incorrigible sin, the hopeless doom of the incorrigible sinner, appear to me to be as clearly taught by Christ as words can teach them.”
“3. But if the New Testament warnings may well awaken fear in every sinner lest his sin become incorrigible, its prophecies give to every Christian good ground of hope in a final, perfect redemption. They foretell a kingdom of Christ to which all the kingdoms of this earth shall belong; an hour when every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess Jesus Christ to be Lord, to the glory of God the Father; a reconciliation of all things unto the Redeemer, whether upon the earth or in the heavens; a millennial glory in which his kingdom will come and his will be done on earth as in Heaven; a new song unto Him that sitteth upon the throne and unto the Lamb forever, sung by every creature which is in Heaven, and on the earth, and under the earth, and such as are in the sea, and all that are in them. In the New Testament picture of this hour of triumph I see no shadow of scowling faces, of angered and unrepentant rebels; in the New Testament echo of this song of the redeemed I hear no interrupting of wail or wrath from any far-off prison-house of despair. After the last enemy is destroyed, shall sin, worst of all enemies, still live, and work his ruin eternally? When God hath put all enemies under Christ’s feet, shall this worst of all enemies still rule in triumph over some remote, reserved corner of creation? I cannot, will not, dogmatize; but I can and do believe that God is always better than his promises, and that these promises of the perfect accord of all God’s creatures in him and with him mean not less but more than they seem to us to mean. I cannot, will not, dogmatize; but I can hope. The more I study my Bible the more unscriptural seems to me the conception of endless sin; the nearer I come into fellowship with God my Father, my Saviour, my Comforter, the more intolerable grows the thought of it to me. And I thank God for the good hope in his word, which permits me to look forward to and haste toward the day when this terrible tragedy of sin and pain will come to an end.”
“4. If I believe in the hopeless doom of incorrigible sin, and also in the undimmed glory of a perfected kingdom of love, I must believe in the annihilation of the incorrigibly wicked. Yes, that would be the logical conclusion. If I thought that logic were a glass which reveals the secrets of eternity, I should believe in this as the final doom of unrepented sin. As it is, I can only say that I think this a probable doctrine, more probable by far than the doctrine of endless sin and suffering. There are phrases in Christ’s teaching which give some color to that terrible dogma; but more often those quoted in support of it are misquoted or misinterpreted. Fire is generally in the Bible an emblem of destruction, not of torment. The chaff, the tares, the fruitless tree, are thrown into unquenchable fire, not to be tortured, but to be destroyed. The hell-fire of the New Testament is the fire of Gehenna, kept burning outside the walls of Jerusalem to destroy the offal of the city; here was the worm that dieth not and the fire that is not quenched; emblems of destruction, not of torment. Except two, or at most three, passages in the gospels and a few enigmatical symbols in that most enigmatical book, the Revelation of St. John, I find nothing in the New Testament to warrant the terrible opinion that God sustains the life of his creatures throughout eternity only that they may continue in sin and misery. That immortality is the gift of God through our Lord Jesus Christ, that man is mortal and must put on immortality, that only he can put it on who becomes through Christ a partaker of the divine nature, and so an inheritor of Him ‘who only hath immortality,’ that eternal life is life eternal, and eternal death is death eternal, and everlasting destruction is destruction without remedy or hope of restoration—this is the most natural, as it is the simplest reading of the New Testament.”
Dr. Abbott wrote to Addison P. Foster, “a conservative but broad-minded theologian” of Jersey City, N. J., asking his opinion of the above editorial. From Mr. Foster’s reply the following is taken, as illustrating the change taking place in popular sentiments toward those who believe in conditional immortality:—
“The arguments for conditional immortality are so many and so strong that, while they do not convince me, I must respect the man whom they do convince. And I can do this the more easily because I am more and more satisfied that the view is quite compatible with what we consider an evangelical faith. The test of an evangelical position seems to me to lie in its practical working. The point of church-fellowship is in the question whether we can work together. Two forces which are fighting for opposite results, or results which run counter to one another, are not in fellowship; nor are two forces which, though they may have the same aim, adopt methods which necessarily would neutralize one another. I cannot fellowship in church relationships, though most heartily as a brother Christian, with a Restorationist, because he must believe in his secret heart, as I do not, that it is no serious matter if a man fails to repent in this life—he will hereafter; nor with a Unitarian, because he denies the efficacy of the one remedy I have to propose for sin; viz., the blood of Christ. But I can fellowship, as I have already publicly said, with one who believes in conditional immortality. We both believe in a dreadful and irretrievable penalty for sin, and may work shoulder to shoulder in preaching Christ as its only escape.”