Why Prayers Sometimes Fail.
By Charles S. Robinson
ONE sentence there is in the Lord’s prayer, in which our interest is heightened because of the fact that Jesus singled it out distinctively for further enforcement. Matt. 6:12. He told his disciples that if they did not forgive others, God certainly would not forgive them. Verses 14, 15. The same careful statement is repeated in Mark 11:25, 26. So, just as the apostle Paul calls attention to that precept in the decalogue which requires a child to honor his father and mother because it is the “first commandment with promise,” it is surely befitting that we call attention to this one request in the prayer, because it is the first and the only petition with comment of illustration. I. Let us, in the first place, enter upon an intelligent exposition of the verses just as they stand. It will be quite as necessary for us to be sure what they do not mean as what they do mean; for the declaration has been somewhat abused. 1. It is easy to show what our Lord does not teach in his repeated counsels on this point. The new revision gives a very interesting turn to the form of expression by throwing the verb into the past tense: “Forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors.” This intensifies the admonition, and enforces the condition that insures success in our praying; for it demands that our pardon of injuries shall have taken place previous even to our coming to the mercy-seat for ourselves. It cannot be that the passage we are studying means that our forgiveness of others is in any sense the ground for our remission of sins from God. We must not consider ourselves here encouraged to say, “Forgive us all our transgressions, because we have shown ourselves magnanimous enough to forgive people against whom we might have brought charge of injury.” This was the prayer of the Pharisee, who went down from the temple unjustified. Our sins are forgiven because of Christ’s righteousness. 2. What, then, does our Lord mean when he gives us this warning? How is a forgiving spirit connected with our prayers? If our having pardoned those who have injured us be not a ground for our own pardon, nor a measure of divine grace, what is it? For one thing, it may be used as a token. It can be looked upon as a hopeful sign that our transgressions have been removed, and that we are now heirs of the kingdom. Christ has made it a test; he has left it without qualification, as if he had no fear that Christians would pervert or abuse it: “For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your Heavenly Father will also forgive you.” Such a token can be employed very easily. If used faithfully, it would set at rest many a doubt concerning religion in one’s heart. For a true man cannot possibly be mistaken about this one thing; the poorest metaphysician in the world can tell whether he wishes to feed his enemy when hungry, or give him drink when thirsty, and so accept the principle Solomon gave to Paul. Rom. 12:20. Any man can know whether he is growing in mildness of temper or gentleness of charity as the years move on. He can understand whether he is becoming more and more moderate and placable in even his first honest outbursts of indignation. It is possible to settle himself, if he truly desires so to do, as to whether he forgives those who misuse him: “But if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.” For another thing, this passage may serve as an admonition. And it is likely that it will have in this its widest use. The petition of the great universal prayer cannot be pressed without its comment. In this demand for a forgiving spirit, there is nothing less than a permanent reminder that when we come asking for pardon, we must be prepared to exercise it likewise; if not, we are to turn on our track and seek preparation. For it never does any good to start for communion service, when in our heart there is an old grudge against the man who is to distribute the bread or hand us the wine. It will avail nothing to enter our closet of supplication with our minds morose and embittered. We are to drop the gift we have brought to the altar of prayer, and go and seek a better frame of devotional feeling; then we can come back again. Matt. 5:23, 24. II. This being the exposition of the verses, and the conclusion having been inevitably reached that we cannot even pray without the spirit of forgiveness, it is evident that we must move forward to a higher plane of Christian experience in this one particular. So we inquire, in the second place, concerning the reach and the limit of the doctrine of forgiveness. 1. The reach of it is indicated in an incident of Simon Peter’s life. Matt. 18:21, 22. This disciple wanted to know whether he was bound to forgive a man who kept injuring him, and about how long such a magnanimous form of procedure was to be continued; and he suggested, as a good, fair margin, “seven times.” Our Lord replied four hundred and ninety times. The Jews were accustomed in those days to say, “Bear with thine enemy three times, and then duty is done toward him.” Simon went beyond his national traditions. Three was considered a sacred number, but seven was more sacred still. This decent disciple supposed that seven times would be satisfactory even to Christ. Just think how one of this old fisherman’s temperament would have rejoiced to find it settled that when a seventh offense had been reached, then it would be actually religious to say to the injurious fellow, “Now you have to take your turn; your days of grace are exhausted; do that thing an eighth time, if you dare!” But his Lord answered him with a somewhat startling extension of the bounds: “Seventy times seven!” There is no need of imagining that exactness of figures was designed to be stated in these words. The four hundred and ninety times of forbearance with one man, however, would cover the ground of most people’s troubles, if the language must be forced. Probably Jesus meant that there should be no limit whatsoever to the principle that men must be forgiven as often as they erred. 2. But now, with a sober sense of inquiry, and a sincere wish to be reasonable, some of us are ready to ask after the limit as well as the reach of this counsel. Are we to take the admonition literally? Is there actually no bound whatsoever to our charity? At all events, does not even God demand repentance as a condition of pardon? And is not this the teaching of the Scriptures for ourselves, too? See Luke 17:3, 4. Before this question can be plainly answered, we must be careful to see that forgiveness does not imply that we approve, condone, or underrate the injurious acts committed; we forgive the sinner, not the sin—the sin we are to forget. Nor does forgiveness imply that we are to stifle all honest indignation against the wickedness of the injury. Nor is it settled that we are to take the injurious man into instant companionship if we forgive him; Jacob and Esau will do better apart. What, then, are we to do? We are, in our very heart of hearts, to cease forever from the sore sense of a hurt; we are to shut our souls against all suggestions of requital or future revenge; we are to use all means for furthering the interests of those who have done us harm; we are to illustrate the greatness of God’s pardoning love by the quickness of our own. All this before our wrongs have been atoned for; before our honest acts and decent deeds have been shown! It does seem a little difficult; but think over Augustine’s searching question, “Do you who are a Christian desire to be revenged and vindicated, and the death of Jesus Christ has not yet been revenged, nor his innocence vindicated?”—Charles S. Robinson, D. D., in S. S. Times.