(See Instructor of Jan. 21, 1885.)
Punishment of the Wicked—Continued.
Critical Notes.
2 Thessalonians 1:7–9: In this chapter Paul commends the Thessalonian church for their patient endurance of persecutions and afflictions, and says he was accustomed to glory in their patience and faith among the churches of God. Verse 4. He then proceeds to offer them consolation in the thought that the tribulations and persecutions which they suffer are a token or proof of the righteous judgment of God, from the fact that they who suffer for the kingdom of God will hereafter be counted worthy of that kingdom. Verse 5. And you may be assured, he continues, that God by these persecutions is preparing you for the kingdom of heaven; because it is, upon the face of it, a righteous thing for God to recompense tribulation to them that trouble you, while it is equally righteous for him to recompense rest to you who are troubled. Verses 6, 7. When shall the troublers be recompensed with tribulation, and the troubled with rest?—When the Lord Jesus shall come the second time, in flaming fire taking vengeance on them that know not God (those who willfully shut their eyes to all knowledge of the true God and of his character and attributes), and that obey not the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ (those who having a knowledge of God and of the gospel of Christ, deliberately reject that gospel, and refuse to obey it). Verses 7, 8. How shall vengeance be visited upon the disobedient at this time? They shall be consumed by the spirit of Christ’s mouth, and temporarily destroyed by the brightness of his coming. Chap. 2:8; Jude 14, 15. Is this temporary destruction the only punishment they will suffer? These same persons, upon whom the vengeance of the Lord will be poured out at his second coming, will finally suffer everlasting destruction both away from and because of the presence of the Lord and the glory of his power. Verse 9. When will this final and eternal destruction take place?—At the end of the thousand years, when the holy city, the New Jerusalem, the bride, the Lamb’s wife, comes down from God out of heaven, inhabited by the saints of the Most High under the leadership of their king, Jesus. Then as the resurrected wicked come up and surround the beloved city with a view to its capture, fire comes down from God out of heaven, and devours them. Verse 10; Rev. 21:2, 9, 10; 20:9.
2 Thessalonians 2:8: That Wicked.—Literally, that lawless one; generally considered by Protestant commentators to be the papacy.
The mystery of iniquity was already at work in Paul’s time; it soon developed into the papacy, which will continue its work until destroyed by the glory of Christ’s coming.
Revelation 14:11 and 20:10: The expressions in these passages which are thought by some to prove eternal torment for the wicked, are these: “The smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever,” “and shall be tormented day and night for ever and ever.” The original of the expression “for ever and ever” is eis aiōnas aiōnōn, unto or for the ages of ages; in Rev. 20:10, the article is used: eis tous aiōnas tōn aiōnōn, unto or for the ages of the ages. This expression was not new in John’s day, but was borrowed from the Old Testament. See Isa. 34:9, 10, where it is said of Idumea that its smoke should go up forever, and none should pass through it for ever and ever. If the literal land of Idumea is meant, certainly the statement that its smoke should ascend forever does not imply eternity of duration; for its judgments have long since ceased. If it refers to the fires of the last day, it still does not imply eternity of duration; for a new earth is to come forth from the ashes of the old, cleansed and purified for the everlasting abode of the righteous. Here is an instance in which the word “forever” must denote a limited period; and from this passage in Isaiah the language in Revelation is probably borrowed.
That the words aiōn and aiōnios sometimes denote a limited period is stated by leading lexicographers: as, for example, “Duration, finite or infinite, . . . a period of duration past or future, time, age, lifetime.”—Greenfield; “An age, a generation.”—Liddell and Scott; “In the N. T., of long continued time, indefinite duration.”—Robinson. Cruden in his “Unabridged Concordance,” under the word “eternal” says: “The words ‘eternal, everlasting, and forever’ are sometimes taken for a long time, and not always to be understood strictly.” Dr. Clarke, commenting upon 2 Kings 5, where is recorded the prophet’s curse upon Gehazi, “The leprosy of Naaman shall cleave unto thee and to thy seed forever,” says: “The forever implies as long as any of his posterity should remain. This is the import of the word, leolam. It takes in the whole extent of duration of the thing to which it is applied. The forever of Gehazi was till his posterity became extinct.” This is the true key to the interpretation of the words “forever” and “for ever and ever.” Thus in the cases under consideration, the wicked will be tormented until they cease to exist; the smoke of their torment will go up until the fires which shall consume them go out. It is only by assuming that the wicked are immortal, and cannot cease to exist, that it can be made to appear that the torment of the wicked will be eternal. That assumption has been positively disproved in previous lessons. For a complete discussion of this matter, the reader is referred to the chapter in “Man’s Nature and Destiny” entitled “Tormented Forever and Ever,” from which most of the above facts are condensed. He would do well to read also in this connection the last chapter of Vol. IV. of the “Great Controversy.”
Practical Suggestions.
1. The true child of God must expect tribulations and persecutions, and must endure them all with patience and faith, remembering that it is through much tribulation that we must enter the kingdom of God. 2 Thess. 1:4, 5; Acts 14:22.
2. While passing through these trials the patient, faithful, troubled one may be greatly encouraged by the thought that if patiently endured they will make him worthy of the kingdom, and that when the Lord Jesus shall be revealed, he will be rewarded with “sweet rest in heaven.” 2 Thess. 1:7.
3. Nor let the troublers forget that a just recompense of tribulation awaits them unless they shall cease to persecute the children of God, and be themselves converted.
4. “Punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power”—who can think of such a fate, and realize that it surely awaits him if he turns away from the knowledge of God, and refuses to obey the gospel of Christ, without being restrained from sin by the thought? 2 Thess. 1:9.
5. What a deceiver is Satan! and what a deception is that by which the wicked nations are led to believe they can capture the camp of the saints, the beloved city, the New Jerusalem! See there the mighty hosts marshaled under their respective commanders! In number they are as the sand of the sea. See earth’s mighty warriors,—those who, to gratify their vain ambition, caused rivers of blood to flow,—the Alexanders, the Hannibals, the Cæsars, the Neros, the Napoleons! Those who perchance in this life warred against each other, now forget the past, and together plan the siege. Modern warriors seek out them of olden time, and explain the use of engines which the ancients knew not of. Amid the whole is Satan, going from place to place, encouraging, planning, directing, keeping up the deception, striving with all his might to combine the strength of the ages for this final effort. For a moment it would seem the Almighty regards the scene with scornful pity, and then—a breath, a flame of fire, goes forth from his presence, and licks them up as though they were but chaff. O sinner, be not deceived. God is not mocked. What you sow, that will you also reap. Rev. 20:9.
Teaching Hints.
I would begin by reviewing the two preceding lessons. Most teachers review too little; I never heard of one who reviewed too much. A few minutes should be used at every recitation in recalling the important points of past lessons. Do not let the class wander, or they will take up too much time. Hold them to one or two central thoughts. For example, the subject of the first lesson upon the punishment of the wicked was “Everlasting Punishment.” Review this at every recitation until your scholars can give a clear explanation of what everlasting punishment is, until they learn to see clearly the connection between Matt. 25:46, 2 Thess. 1:9, and Rom. 6:13, and by a comparison of these texts can show that everlasting punishment is everlasting destruction or eternal death.
The subject of the second lesson was “Everlasting Fire,” into which those upon the left hand were bidden depart. Matt. 25:46. Connect this passage with Jude 7 and 2 Pet. 2:6, and persevere until your scholars can show that as Sodom and Gomorrah suffered the vengeance of eternal fire, thereby becoming an example of the punishment of the wicked, without continuing to be on fire throughout eternity, so the wicked, cast into everlasting fire, will not continue to burn eternally, but the everlasting fire will produce their everlasting destruction. In this sense is the fire eternal,—it produces eternal results.
You may now begin the regular lesson, having occupied from five to eight minutes with the review. In the present lesson 2 Thess. 1:7–9 is again taken up, more thoroughly than in the first lesson upon this subject. As this is an important passage, let the class turn to it in their Bibles, and spend a few minutes studying and explaining it. Be sure they understand verse 7, “and to you who are troubled [it is a righteous thing with God to recompense] rest with us,” etc. Also see that they understand that verse 7 refers to Christ’s second coming, while the everlasting destruction of the wicked does not take place until the end of the thousand years, when the Lord shall come with the beloved city to be glorified in his saints. See Critical Notes. Do not overlook the important practical lessons that may be drawn from this passage. Remember that you have here an excellent opportunity to show definitely what the punishment of the wicked is.
Another leading feature of the lesson is the consideration of an objection to the doctrine of the destruction of the wicked; namely, that they shall be tormented forever and ever. Rev. 20:10; 14:9–11. By a careful study of the “Critical Notes,” comparing Ex. 21:2 and Isa. 34:10, together with a study of the notes in the Signs and in the Instructor, you may become prepared to give a clear explanation of this point, if you cannot already do so. Practice upon it with some friend during the week. Be not discouraged if at first you do not accomplish all you designed. You are engaged in a work worthy your best efforts, and in which your success depends largely upon your perseverance and your trust in God. C. C. L.