We do not mean the Sundays of the ancient Babylonians, although they had them away back there, dedicated to the chief heathen divinity, the sun; for, as the North British Review has it, Sunday has been “the wild solar holiday of all pagan times.” But we refer to the very Babel that exists on the Sunday question throughout Christendom to-day. The confusion that reigns among those who are trying to bolster up the Sunday-Sabbath, and the contradictory positions they take, should be sufficient to convince any one that they are trying to sustain an unscriptural institution; for if it was a child of the Scriptures, they could appeal to the testimony of the Scriptures in its behalf; and then they would all speak the same thing; for the Scriptures are not yea and nay. This feature is very apparent in the testimony of the defendants of the Bible Sabbath—it is the same everywhere, from Nova Scotia to Oregon, from Michigan to Florida, in Europe and the isles of the sea.
The Bible gives to that which is confused and contradictory the designation of “Babylon;” and this being pre-eminently the case with the evidence offered by different ones in behalf of Sunday sacredness, it strikes us that in this sense it may well be called the Babylonian Sunday. We are not alone in this position. Even the friends of Sunday see the confusion, and are thrown into great perplexity thereby. Eld. Haskell gave us last week a very amusing account of efforts to settle “that perplexing question,” in a conference of First-day Adventist ministers. A friend has sent us a clipping from the Boston Herald of Nov. 10, 1884, containing a synopsis of a discourse by Minot J. Savage of the church of the Unity, delivered in the Mt. Pleasant Congregational church, Boston, Mass., on Sunday evening, Nov. 9. The discourse was one of a series, and was on the subject of “The People’s Sunday.” The report says:—
“The congregation was a very large one, and the utterances of the lecturer were attentively listened to. The reverend gentleman said: ‘The attitude of Christendom on the Sunday question is perplexing and contradictory in the extreme. Let us note some phases of the common confusion. At the very outset we find that there is no agreement even as to the name by which the day shall be called. Shall we say Sabbath or Sunday, or Lord’s day, or first day of the week? Neither is the day itself fixed upon with any degree of unanimity, for the Adventists, the Seventh-day Baptists, and many others are very strenuous in their opinion that only those who keep Saturday are obedient to the divine command. And on Biblical grounds their position is certainly impregnable. Then, when the day is fixed upon, there is no sort of agreement as to what shall be done with it. Shall we have the Jewish Sabbath, the continental Sunday, the Puritan’s Lord’s day, a secular holiday, or shall we blot out all distinction between that and the other days of the week? And even within the circle of our liberal churches, there are many unsolved practical problems, troubles of conscience, and questions of casuistry. Would it be wrong for the ladies to sew or crochet on Sunday? Shall the reading be the same as on other days, or shall a difference be made? Shall the children be allowed the same kinds of games and plays as during the week? What of recreations for grown people? There are those who will ride on Sunday, but who think it wrong to take a sail. Would it be wrong to play whist on Sunday evening? What about visiting and the social side of life on that day? Is there any obligation touching the matter of church attendance? The points of confusion I thus touch and the questions I raise, are all vital ones, such as I have come in contact with in my own experience.’”
This is a remarkable admission, especially the acknowledgment that on Bible grounds the position of those who are keeping the seventh day is certainly impregnable. Are we not then to go by the Bible on this question? Or what is the source of our obligation, and the rule by which we are to be governed in this matter? It is certainly a confession that Sunday-keeping does not rest on Bible ground.
Having made this admission, we are not surprised to hear him mark out a program of Sunday exercises which must have been a bitter pill to those who would clothe the day with divine sanctity. After saying that in the first place he would have the dramshops hermetically sealed, he continued:—
“We cannot pursue people into their homes and see what they drink, but for one day in seven we can shut up the devil’s shops and give God and nature a chance. I would have cheap Sunday afternoon trains into the country on every road leading out of the city. I would have cheap steamer excursions down the harbor. I would have all art galleries and reading-rooms wide open and free. I would have just as many active oppositions to evil as possible. I would do all I could to break up the weary monotony of drudgery. I would make trees and flowers and grasses and light and air so attractive and easy of access that people would leave the attics and cellars and slums and narrow streets to seek them with a simple and hearty relish. This is for the afternoon. On Sunday morning I would have everybody as far as possible go to church, and the evening, if I could have my way, should be given to the home, in the company of wife and children and friends. Let it be a time of all joy and freedom and simple festivity—a time in which all the week-day burdens of life should roll off and be forgotten. Make Sunday, then, a day of gladness and refreshment and peace.”
This is as near a counterpart as could be proposed, of what is called the Continental Sunday—like those for instance in Spain, where they hear mass in the morning, and attend bull-fights in the afternoon; or those in France, Germany, and Italy, where, after some small attention to religious matters in the morning, the afternoons and evenings are spent in beer gardens, carousings, and amusements of every nature. It would be impossible to keep such recreations on a high and respectable plane. The heart of man, unchecked by religious restraint, too naturally runs to that which is low and debasing.