THE JUDGMENT, BAPTISM, RESTORATIONISM AND SPIRITISM, AND THEIR RELATION TO THE FALL OF THE CHURCHES.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—I shall follow up for a time to-night the consideration of the subject of the false doctrines held by the churches, and its bearing upon the question of their moral fall. Last evening I showed that the theory which they hold respecting a temporal millennium, taken in connection with the fact that the coming of the Lord is at hand, proved that they are very far from God, and are certain to be cast off absolutely unless they shall surrender that view,—a thing which is highly improbable.
I might base a similar argument on their erroneous conceptions of the Judgment, the commencement of which they place after the advent. We have seen that a message announcing that the hour of God’s Judgment is at hand, is to go to the world just before the coming of Christ, to prepare the church for that event. It has also been shown that such a message has already been proclaimed, and that it has been rejected by the masses of modern professors. Such a rejection of truth, when coming in the order of God’s providence, is no light matter. It proves the moral obliquity of those who share in it, and must result fatally to them if persisted in; as men who refuse “to see light in God’s light” must ultimately be given over to blindness of mind and hardness of heart. We can only be saved in God’s own appointed way, and it is as true to-day that the sheep will hear and recognize the voice of the Good Shepherd as it was at the time of the first advent.
I think that I must allude to the subject of baptism as related to the question of the fall of the churches. I do not know but I shall offend your sensibilities, Mr. Thoughtful, in doing so; for I take it for granted that you, being a Methodist, have adopted sprinkling for baptism.
Mr. Thoughtful.—Do not spare my feelings, I beg of you, sir, if they are in the way of my reception of the truth. I would rather be cut all to pieces than to reject light. So far as baptism is concerned, I admit that in my case it was administered by sprinkling. I adopted that mode because I supposed that it was the one that our Saviour prescribed. It is true that I never have examined into the matter very thoroughly, but yet I have been conscientious in the course I have pursued.
Mr. B.—I have no doubt, sir, that what you say is true. There are many in the churches who really believe that sprinkling is baptism, and who have acted accordingly. Such have done as well as they knew how to do, and the Lord will accept them. Unhappily, this cannot be said of a very large number of leading minds in the Pedo-Baptist part of orthodox Christendom. It is quite generally conceded now by scholars that baptism in the days of Christ consisted in the immersion of the whole body in water. The battle has been fought out upon that subject, and the best-informed in the churches have changed their base of operations on the baptism question. Instead of insisting any longer that John the Baptist, Christ, or the apostles, employed sprinkling or effusion, they admit that immersion was the method which they commanded to be used, and which they enforced by their own example.
Mr. T.—Your statement astonishes me, sir.
Mr. B.—It is, nevertheless, correct, as I will proceed to show if Maud will hand me a volume from the book-case there entitled, “The Act of Baptism.” Here, on page 36, is a quotation from Mosheim’s “Ecclesiastical History,” cent. I, chap. IV., sect. 8: “The sacrament of baptism was administered in this century, without the public assemblies, in places appointed for that purpose, and was performed by immersion of the whole body.” Mosheim’s “History,” as you know, is a standard authority with Protestants generally. But let me look along a little farther in the book; I think I shall be able to find here somewhere a general statement which will justify the remark that I made. Yes, here is something in point on page 37. It is from Rev. L. L. Paine, D. D. (Congregationalist), professor of church history in the theological seminary at Bangor, Me. Dr. Paine, referring to the fact that immersion was the primitive act of baptism, is quoted here as saying: “The testimony is ample and decisive. No matter of church history is clearer. The evidence is all one way, and all church historians of any repute agree in accepting it. We cannot claim even originality in teaching it in a Congregational seminary. And we really feel guilty of a kind of anachronism in writing an article to insist upon it. It is a point on which ancient, mediæval, and modern historians alike, Catholic and Protestant, Lutheran and Calvinist, have no controversy. And the simple reason for this unanimity is that the statements of the early Fathers are so clear, and the light shed upon these statements from the early customs of the church is so conclusive, that no historian who cares for his reputation would dare to deny it, and no historian who is worthy of the name would wish to.”
I can conceive, Mr. Thoughtful, that while the contest respecting the mode of baptism was going on, men might have differed very widely, and yet have been perfectly honest before God; but it is difficult for me to exercise the same charity toward individuals who, while conceding that baptism by immersion was instituted by the Lord, should venture to substitute something else in its place. Such a course, it seems to me, betrays a contempt for the Divine will and wisdom which can only be accounted for when it is conceded that those who exercise it have fallen far below the proper standard of Christian conscientiousness. It reminds one of the language of Isa. 24: 5: “The earth also is defiled under the inhabitants thereof; because they have transgressed the laws, changed the ordinance, broken the everlasting covenant.” While these words may not have been designed to apply especially to the men of our age, they certainly embody principles of obedience which have been utterly disregarded by them; since, according to their own confessions, they have transgressed the laws and changed the ordinance of baptism, in doing which they have really broken the covenant which at conversion they made with the Lord by agreeing to do all that he should require at their hands.
There is another very dangerous doctrine which is gaining ground very rapidly in the churches at the present time, and to which I will call your attention next. It is the theory of probation after death. The rapidity with which this tenet is coming into favor is truly alarming. Under the lead of such men as Canon Farrar of England, and Henry Ward Beecher and Prof. Swing of our own country, it is marching steadily forward to the conquest of orthodoxy. Already it has so far won the day that scores of ministers are permitted to preach it in orthodox pulpits. Indeed, it has become quite fashionable to stigmatize all those who would silence the clergymen who publicly engage in its advocacy, as narrow and illiberal. The Scriptures, it is argued, are silent on this momentous question, and therefore every minister should be allowed to exercise his own judgment respecting its soundness. I need not stop to discuss the offensiveness of such a doctrine in the sight of Heaven. It is but a modified form of Universalism,—a system which is diametrically opposed to the plain teachings of the Bible, and one that has been denounced by the good of all ages. If you would take in the situation, and realize more fully the extent to which Protestantism has departed from its original ground in this matter, just imagine for a moment that Luther, Zwingli, Melancthon, Calvin, Knox, Wesley, Edwards, and Beecher the senior, were constituted a court for the decision of the question whether men could repent and be saved after death. Acquainted as you are with the character and teachings of these men, Mr. Thoughtful, you know very well that if anything would arouse in them an indignation bordering upon absolute wrath it would be the proposition to tolerate for a moment in the pulpits of Christendom men who would preach the modern doctrine of restorationism.
But I must pass to the consideration of another tendency of the church in our time which is very distressing. I speak of the rapidly increasing disposition among its members to adopt spiritualistic views. We have learned from the sanctuary question that the last days have been reached. Now let me read 1 Tim. 4: 1, a prophecy which applies at this time: “Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils.” Nothing could be plainer than the teachings of this passage. In it Paul declares that in the latter times some should depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits. In 1848, or just after the commencement of the Judgment, modern Spiritualism arose. At first it simply provoked contempt. To-day it belts the globe, and numbers its converts by millions. Unhappily, thousands of them are found in the very bosom of the churches. So long as they continue to be what are styled “Bible Spiritualists,” they, as a rule, are not expelled, even though they regularlyp. 67 sit in circles, and hold communication with the so-called “spirits of the dead.”
Maud.—Why don’t they turn them out, father?
Mr. B.—Why? my daughter. I answer, For various reasons. In the first place, they are frequently persons of so much influence that it would be difficult to dislodge them. In the second place, their opinions differ so slightly from those of the other members of the church that it would be troublesome to make an action hold.
Mr. T.—I do not understand you, sir.
Mr. B.—This is what I mean. Theoretically speaking, the difference between those church members who hold to the Bible and practice Spiritualism and those who do not practice Spiritualism is so small that it would be rather embarrassing to demonstrate the criminality of the former while maintaining the soundness of the latter. So long as ministers teach, and their congregations believe, that the spirits of the departed come back to this earth, and watch over, impress, guard, and direct their living friends, it is not unphilosophical to suppose that they could invent some method of communicating with them externally; and it is not unnatural that those so believing should attempt to bring about such a state of things. Hardly a funeral occurs, for example, but the minister tells the mourning circle that their friend is not dead, but is standing by their side, or flitting over them, and that he or she can now read their thoughts, and sympathize with them more fully than ever before. Such language intensifies the desire to communicate once more with the departed loved one, and no wonder need be entertained if under these circumstances the bereaved should cast about for some medium through which to interview the dead.
I repeat that if the orthodox conception on the subject of departed spirits is correct, necromancy, or intercourse with the deceased, would not seem from the logical standpoint to be either difficult or blameworthy, at least so far as the righteous dead are concerned. It is because such is the case, that in all past ages those nations who have held opinions respecting the nature of the soul similar to those entertained by modern orthodoxy, have had their temples and their oracles where, according to their ideas, the visible and the invisible worlds have been brought into actual communication. Saul lost his kingdom and his title to eternal life, because, believing as he did in the conscious state of the dead, he could not resist the temptation to communicate with the spirit of Samuel through the witch of Endor.
Mr. T.—But I thought that you said that it would not appear to be wicked for the living to communicate with the dead. If so, why was the Lord wroth with Saul for doing that very thing?
Mr. B.—I was reasoning from the standpoint of modern theology. Church members now-a-days hold that the departed are constantly communicating with us; and I argued that if such were the case, it would not be wrong for us to communicate with the good among them, either through tangible objects or otherwise.
Mr. T.—In what, then, did Saul’s offense consist?
Mr. B.—In disobeying God by consulting one who claimed to have a familiar spirit.
Mr. T.—Exactly so, sir. Now what I want to know is why God forbade it, if, as you say, it was not necessarily wrong to communicate with the dead.
Mr. B.—It was because the whole thing was a delusion of the most dangerous character. When Saul consulted that ancient spirit medium, he brought himself directly under the influence and control of devils. The spirit which on that occasion personated Samuel was a fallen angel. Just so it is in our day. Those at this time, whether in the churches or out of the churches, who consult the spirits of the dead, so-called, are the dupes of the Devil. Let me read you a couple of texts bearing upon this point. Here is one in Eccl. 9: 5: “For the living know that they shall die; but the dead know not anything, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.” Here is the other passage (Ps. 146: 3, 4): “Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man in whom there is no help. His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth, in that very day his thoughts perish.”
Language cannot be more explicit than that found in these verses. I might read you many more texts of like import; but these must suffice for the present. If the dead know nothing, if their very thoughts have perished, then assuredly they cannot communicate with men. Modern orthodoxy, holding as it does to the conscious state of the dead, does not realize the awful sinfulness of necromancy, and is rapidly fulfilling the prediction of 1 Tim. 4: 1, by “giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils.” Here again we see the danger of false doctrine. How the churches can ever extricate themselves from this snare of Satan, so long as they hold to their present views of the nature of the soul and its condition in death, it is impossible to discover. From the very necessity of the case it would appear to be certain that they will become more and more fully permeated with the doctrines of modern Spiritualism until at last they will be utterly cast off, and become as predicted in Rev. 18: 1–5: “The habitation of devils, and the hold of every foul spirit, and a cage of every unclean and hateful bird.” It is now time for us to adjourn.
Battle Creek, Mich.