“SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?”
Such is the title of a little pamphlet which has recently been written by Prof. Rauschenbusch, of the Rochester Theological Seminary, designed especially to teach our German fellow-citizens that Sunday, or the first day of the week, and not the seventh day, ought now to be kept as the Sabbath. There is a great amount of unnecessary discussion over the Sabbath question. The question is a very simple one. It rests upon less than half a dozen plain historical facts; and it can be answered in a direct and simple manner, if it can be answered at all. There is no obligation (morally speaking) resting upon any one to keep any day as a Sabbath unless God has commanded it; and if he has commanded it, the command can be found in his word. And we have no means of knowing what day should be observed, unless he has told us in his word; and if he has so told us, certainly it can be found. Why will not men, therefore, come right to the word of God with humble and honest hearts, and abide by its teaching? If they would do this, the controversy would all be ended in a day. God alone can make a Sabbath which will be binding upon men. And he can do this only by taking that day which he wishes to be regarded as a Sabbath, and giving it a different character, and elevating it to a different position from that of other days of the week. This the Scriptures say God has done in reference to the Sabbath day. He has “blessed it,” or made it holy time, and “sanctified it,” or set it apart to a holy use. The Sabbath must therefore be a particular, definite day; for these acts on the part of God must pertain to some one day, not to all days. If you say that there is nothing particular about the day, that not so much importance should be attached to that, that any day after any six days of labor may be kept as a Sabbath, this is saying that God has blessed and sanctified all days; and then any one can see in a moment that God has given us no Sabbath at all; for on this view he has not distinguished one above any of the others. To say that any day or every day is the Sabbath, is to say that no day is the Sabbath. No sensible person will dispute this. But most people acknowledge that God has given us a Sabbath; therefore he has set apart some particular day for this purpose. What day is it? There is a passage in the Bible which plainly tells us. It is the commandment which enjoins the institution. It was spoken by the voice of Jehovah himself, amid circumstances of loftiest grandeur on the summit of Sinai, when from his awful pavilion of clouds and flame, in words which, like the reverberations of many thunders, shook this solid globe (Heb. 12:26), he issued a law binding on all men through all time. Every person of unperverted mind will acknowledge that all the other commandments of the decalogue are of universal and perpetual obligation. If God has any moral government in the world today, men are bound to obey them. Then why is not the fourth commandment, which is placed in the very bosom of that decalogue, of the same nature as the other commandments? Does God, whom the Scriptures set forth as a God of order and not confusion, thus mix together the temporary and the eternal?313 The commandment says that the seventh day, not the first, is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God, and that it must be remembered and kept holy. There is not another commandment in all the Scriptures enjoining any weekly Sabbath whatever, and consequently no day can be the Sabbath according to the Scriptures except the one there mentioned. That day is some definite day; if it is not, then, as already shown, there can be no Sabbath, and the commandment is a fraud. And it is insulting Jehovah to his face to say that he has given a commandment enjoining a particular day, and then left the matter in such a condition that we cannot tell which day that is. No; the fourth commandment is not thus left. The commandment (Ex. 20:8–11) refers back for its origin to the creation of the world. As we turn to the record found in the first chapter of Genesis, and the first three verses of chapter two, we learn that God worked six days in the creation of the world, having finished it and all things therein, as the commandment asserts, when the sixth day ended. Then he spent the seventh day in rest. The seventh day was the chief and crowning day of that grand procedure. And when it closed, he blessed the seventh day, because that first seventh day had been to him a day of joyous contemplation of his glorious work; then turning to man, he sanctified the day, that is, set it apart to a sacred and holy use, which would be nothing more nor less than giving to Adam and Eve, our common parents, a commandment for its observance. All this the record plainly states, and it cannot be disputed. “The Sabbath,” says the Saviour (Mark 2:27), “was made for man”; and here we have the time when and the acts by which it was made. But this act of sanctifying the Sabbath, immediately threw all coming days into groups of sevens; for the command to devote to a sacred use each seventh day could not be kept unless time was so divided. This all must acknowledge. The next division of time after the day, is the week; and here the week had its origin. It is not derived, like the month, year, and lunar and solar cycles, from the operations of nature, and can be traced to no other source but the institution of the Sabbath at creation. The Sabbath and the week began together. And the fact that the week is found among all nations, not only within the bounds of authentic history, but away back as far as tradition runs, is the strongest kind of evidence of the Edenic origin of the Sabbath, and a sublime testimony to the truthfulness of the Mosaic narrative. Now unless that commandment has been changed or repealed, and that arrangement disannulled, the same Sabbath that was given to Adam, proclaimed from Sinai, enthroned in the decalogue, kept by patriarchs and prophets, and observed by our Lord himself through all his earthly ministry, is still binding on mankind; and for the same reason as at first, namely, because God rested on the day, and then set it apart for men to keep as the great memorial of his creative work. But whoever says that the law has been changed or repealed, must bring his proof, plain, positive evidence, not mere guesses and inferences, that that is so. Let us be reasonable men; and let us have a little reverence for God, and treat his laws and actions with as much respect as we do those of our fellow-men. But now men begin to quibble, and “infer,” and draw far-fetched “conclusions,” and set up “probabilities,” and argue that this was “doubtless” so, and that “must have been” thus; and was not one thing for this reason and another for that?—and amid this tangled maze of confusion, they try to throw out the ancient and original Sabbath, and set up a new one, which is to be kept on another day and for another reason. Meanwhile the commandment stands in all its majesty, firmly planted as the pillars of Jehovah’s throne, standing serene amid all the discord and folly of men, ever pointing out the right way and appealing to men to do their duty, and ready to be a swift witness in the soon-coming Judgment, against all those who refuse to obey its requirements. Mr. R., like many others, starts out with the inquiry, “On what day of the week did Jesus rise?” This is dwelt upon, as if it was entirely sufficient to decide the question whether we shall keep Saturday or Sunday for the Sabbath. Perhaps in this he does not intend to raise a false issue and mislead the reader; but this is nevertheless the whole tendency of this part of his argument, whether he designed it to be so or not. For the day of Christ’s resurrection has nothing whatever to do in deciding the question which day we should keep as the Sabbath. Men never would have thought of this, if they had not found themselves out of harmony with the law, and then instead of changing their practice so as to comply with the law, sought to find some excuse for their position. For where in the Scriptures is it predicted that the Sabbath would be changed to the day in which Christ should rise from the dead? Where is it anywhere commanded to the disciples to keep the day on which Christ rose from the dead? Where do the apostles say that they kept the day on which Christ rose from the dead and because he thus rose? There is not one syllable of this kind anywhere in the Bible; and where there is no arrangement stated, no instruction given, and no law enacted, what has the matter to do in governing our conduct? Nothing whatever. A man should be ashamed of his logic in introducing such an argument. But why, then, it is asked, is it so particularly stated that Christ rose on the first day of the week? Why should it not be stated? What is there strange about that? But there are other days brought to view as well as Sunday—the Thursday on which he was betrayed, the Friday on which he was crucified, and the Thursday on which he ascended. These, though not mentioned by their numerical names, were all well ascertained and notable days. Why not make them as prominent as the first day? They were so made in the early church; and “Good-Friday” and “Holy-Thursday” stood on the same foundation as Sunday; all regarded, not as substitutes for the Sabbath, but simply as church festivals. Happy would it have been for the world if either they had never been introduced, or, having been introduced, had always been kept in their proper sphere! Do not say that redemption is greater than creation, that Christ finished it on the first day, and therefore we should make a Sabbath of that day. For (1) whether redemption was greater than creation or not, you, my friend, with all your wisdom cannot tell; and (2) Christ did not finish redemption on the first day of the week. It is not finished yet, and will not be till all the righteous are made immortal. But remember, further, that, even if it could be shown, on these or any other grounds, that we ought to keep Sunday, that would not release us from keeping the original Sabbath. If we are released from that law, a plain repeal of that law must be shown. But this can no more be shown than a new law for Sunday can be found. The argument therefore is a double deception. Other points will be noticed next week.