BAPTIST AUTHORITY FOR SUNDAY.
By M. E. Kellogg
INTERESTING TIMES IN VERMONT.
The distribution of Sabbath publications, and the meetings being held under the tent in Brattleboro have so far aroused the public interest in regard to the Sabbath that the ministry have already commenced a discussion of the subject. A notice appeared in the local paper to the effect that the “Rev. Mr. ——’s sermon at the Baptist church next Sunday morning will be in answer to the question, ‘Why should Christians keep Sunday and not Saturday?’” The church was large and well filled, and the minister able and confident; so he succeeded, no doubt, in establishing Sunday as the Sabbath in the minds of those who have never heard and have no desire to hear the Bible evidences for the Sabbath instituted before the fall of man, and kept by the disciples of Jesus after his crucifixion. Luke 23:56. It is not my purpose to notice his general arguments for first-day observance. No new ideas were advanced. The speaker rung the usual changes on John 20:19, 26; Acts 20:7; and 1 Cor. 16:1. He assumed that the Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10 was Sunday, claimed the same for “Pliny’s stated day,” and then quoted from the Church Fathers, by whom the Catholic Church prove so many of their dogmas. But what I wish to notice especially are his closing words, or, more strictly speaking, his last quoted authority: “I will conclude,” said he, “in the words of Leo the Great.” Probably very few in his congregation knew who “Leo the Great” was, or in what his greatness consisted. The simple fact that he was great was sufficient to make his testimony conclusive to the majority of the congregation. But who was this “great” man whose words are so conclusive upon the transfer of the Sabbath to Sunday that he is quoted by a Baptist minister in this nineteenth century? The “New American Cyclopedia” says thus: “Leo, the name of twelve of the popes. One of the most important of these was Leo I., called ‘the Great.’” Who, then, was Leo?—One of the most important of the popes! Strange authority for a Baptist minister to use upon this or any other subject! Was not the word of God given to “thoroughly furnish us unto all good works?” And if keeping the first day of the week as the Sabbath is a good work, should we not expect to find sufficient evidence of it in the word of God, and not have to call to our aid the Fathers or the corrupt and proud pontiffs of Rome? Suppose that on the next Sunday, the Congregational minister across the way should take it upon himself to defend the ancient and honorable (?) practice of baptizing infants; and since his brother had argued that as Paul preached once on a certain first day, that day must have been the Sabbath, and the day of the Christian worship, so he would claim that as the apostles baptized “households,” there must have been infants baptized; and conclude by quoting the Fathers and a pope of Rome,—suppose he should do this, what a hue and cry our good Baptist friends would raise! And they would be loud and foremost in saying that the argument for infant baptism was not sustained by the word,—that it was only inferential at the most; that the Fathers supported all kinds of extravagant doctrines, and should never be quoted by a consistent Protestant, whose rule of faith and practice should be, “the Bible and the Bible alone;” and that to quote a pope of Rome was very suggestive of the origin of the practice of infant baptism. But to show that we are not alone in noticing the similarity of the arguments for infant baptism and for the observance of Sunday, I wish to make a few extracts from a little tract entitled, “Infant Baptism,” and published by the Congregational Board of Publication, Boston, Mass., in 1866. The tract is before me, and the quotations are genuine. The writer starts out with the broad statement that, “Infant baptism was sanctioned by Christ, and practiced by his apostles, and universally adopted as a divine ordinance by the apostolic Church.” The book abounds with inferential evidence, and many quotations from the Church Fathers, prominent among whom are Justin Martyr and Clement, whose testimony advocates for Sunday always recognize and use as proof. The writer of this tract was well aware of this fact, and did what many persons before and since have done,—took one error to prove another! For on page 53 he says: “In the meantime, we tell the objector that he must have confidence in the historical argument [i. e., the arguments drawn from the Fathers], or give up things of more importance than infant baptism. Our observance of the first day of the week rests upon this argument. We find this day set apart as a day of rest and public worship by almost every denomination of Christians throughout the world; and the observance of it considered by all as obligatory. By whose authority has this day been thus set apart? Is this institution from Heaven, or is it of men? If you answer, From Heaven, we ask, How do you know that? It is vain to quote the fourth commandment; for that relates to the seventh day. It is in vain to send us to the New Testament; for the Saviour has left no precept requiring us to keep this day holy, nor is there any account of the manner in which the apostles observed it to be found in their writings. How, then, do we know, how can we know, the will of Christ in this matter? We search the history of the Church, and we believe its testimony.” Again, on page 55, we read: “It is important to observe in this connection, that in defending the Christian Sabbath against its assailants, whether Jewish or infidel, we are obliged to call to our aid those very witnesses who have testified to the divine origin of infant baptism.” We give one more extract upon this point, from page 60: “If we give up infant baptism on the ground that the uniform testimony of the Fathers of the Church for many hundred years after the apostles, is not sufficient to produce conviction, . . . how shall we answer the Seventh-day Baptist, who rejects the Christian and keeps the Jewish Sabbath; and how shall we convince those who maintain that we have no apostolic authority for public worship on that day?” The above writer sees plainly what should be apparent to every one, that Sunday consecration and infant baptism rest alike upon the authority of the Fathers and practice of the Church. And the Baptist cannot say, This invidious parallel is made only by the insignificant sect of Sabbatarians. He will be compelled to say, It is thou, my equal, O my Congregational brother; how could you turn upon me in that way! We can almost imagine him, like Cæsar, drawing up his robes as he received the fatal stab, and saying, “Thou, too, Brutus!” But thus it has always been; those who try to defend practices not taught in God’s word will tear down each other. That Sunday-keeping and infant baptism can both be traced to an early period of the Church does not secure to them the apostolic sanction. We should ever remember that God’s word was given us to correct the Church, and not the Church to correct the word; and that the apostle said, “For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.” Acts 20:29. And to Timothy he writes, “And they shall turn away their ears from the truth and be turned to fables.” 2 Tim. 4:3. Infant baptism and the Sunday are two of these “fables” early introduced into the Church by the great apostasy. Upon this early introduction of error into the Church, listen to Mr. Dowling in his history of Romanism:— “There is scarcely anything which strikes the mind of the careful student of ancient ecclesiastical history with greater surprise than the comparatively early period at which many of the corruptions of Christianity took their rise; yet it is not to be supposed that when the first originators of many of these unscriptural notions and practices planted those germs of corruption, they anticipated or even imagined they would ever grow into such a vast and hideous system of superstition and error, as that of popery. . . . The worship of images, the invocation of saints, were but expansions of the natural feelings of veneration and affection cherished towards the memory of those who had suffered and died for the truth.” Robinson, author of the “History of Baptism,” bears the following testimony:— “Toward the latter end of the second century, most of the churches assumed a new form; the first simplicity disappeared; and insensibly as the old disciples retired to their graves, their children along with new converts, both Jews and Gentiles, came forward and new modeled the cause.” Thus we see Paul’s prediction of an early apostasy verified, and Rome can claim a “high antiquity” for all her departures from God’s word. And if we should accept doctrines not taught in the Bible, because taught and practiced by the early church, Protestantism would at once begin to retrace its steps toward Rome. And it is also apparent that those bodies who still hold to doctrines and practices received from the early Church, upon which the Scriptures are silent or squarely opposed, have still a little of the leaven of Rome, which they should purge out, lest the whole lump be leavened. “To the law and to the testimony; if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isa. 8:20. It is worthy of note here that the early Fathers, who favored the observance of the Sunday festival, never claim any authority from Christ or his apostles, but rest their arguments (when they try to present any) upon entirely different grounds. Thus Clement, who wrote about A. D. 194, and who is the first one of the Fathers who distinctly applies the term “Lord’s day” to Sunday, does not quote the apostle John nor any other scripture as authority, but refers to the heathen philosopher Plato, who he thinks spoke of it prophetically! “And the Lord’s day, Plato prophetically speaks of it in the tenth book of the Republic in these words: ‘And when seven days have passed to each of them in the meadow on the eighth day they set out to arrive in four days.’” Tertullian, so often referred to as authority for Sunday-keeping, says, in reference to the observance of Sunday, making birthday offerings for the dead, and the sign of the cross: “If for these and other such rules, you insist upon having positive Scripture injunction, you will find none. Tradition will be held forth to you as the originator of them, custom as their strengthener, and faith as their observer.” We are here forcibly reminded of the words of Christ, “But in vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men;” and of the apostolic counsel, “Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, . . . and not after Christ.” Col. 2:8. From the foregoing it can readily be seen that452 for one to be a consistent Protestant he should accept only those doctrines plainly taught in the Scriptures, and that we are bound and even commanded to reject those which have but tradition for their support. And if the Baptist would be consistent with himself, he should not reject infant baptism and sprinkling because only supported by tradition, and at the same time cling to the observance of the “venerable day of the sun,” which rests solely upon the same foundation. Our Baptist friends are, to say the least, in a very delicate situation. They cannot, and ought not to go back; and to advance with the advancing light will subject them to new crosses, another and wider divergence from the world and the “mother Church;” and, alas! this is a reform that cannot be accomplished at once and forever like the single act of baptism, but it is a constantly recurring duty and test which he has to take up every seven days. Let us be thankful that some are seeing these things. The mists of tradition are being swept away by the clear light of God’s word, and the Sabbath, sanctified in Eden, spoken by the voice of God from the flaming mount, written with his own finger upon the tables of stone, and honored by Christ, who styles himself its Lord, is taking the place of the day of the sun brought into the church in the days of the apostasy. “But ah! too many, when before their eyes
The narrow way and cross begin to rise,
Though ample views of truth they once have got,
Will shut their eyes and say they see it not.”
But to return to the concluding testimony for Sunday-keeping used by the minister, and referred to at the beginning of this article. Some one has said that “there is an eternal fitness in things.” And if any one is determined to support the festival of the sun instead of the Sabbath of Jehovah, what better or more fitting authority can be desired than the popes of Rome? What earthly power can be greater? Does not Paul foretell this power, that he “opposeth and exalteth himself above all that is called God or that is worshipped; so that he as God sitteth in the temple [or church] of God, showing himself that he is God”? As the Bible furnishes no ground for the Sunday institution, which is greatly in need of support of some kind, how proper to refer to that “great” power that was to exalt itself above God! And that any and all of the popes are well qualified to testify upon this point is evident, when we consider that this whole line of priest-kings was to “speak great words against the Most High, . . . and think to change times and laws.” And in their catechisms, confessions of faith, and numerous theological treatises, they always claim the Sunday festival as an institution peculiarly their own, and charge Protestants with virtually acknowledging their supremacy by rejecting their own standard, “the Bible and the Bible alone,” and accepting an institution which rests only on the “authority of the Catholic Church and apostolic tradition.” There was also a peculiar fitness in quoting from Leo the Great. Perhaps he was no greater in wickedness, apostasy, and opposition to God’s word than his predecessors or successors; but that he took an active part in the elevation of the day of the sun to the place formerly occupied by the Sabbath is quite evident. The “New American Cyclopædia” says of him, that he “became pope in A. D. 440, and marked his succession to the pontificate by many important reforms.” We are also told the nature of these reforms: “He extended to sub-deacons the obligation of celibacy, enacted penal laws against married monks, and procured from the emperor Valentinian III. an edict confirming all the previous ordinances passed against the Manichæans.” We also learn that the Council of Chalcedon, A. D. 451, at which several kinds of heretics were condemned, was presided over by the legates of this pope. Thus we see that when Leo the Great took the pontifical chair, celibacy was established in all the higher orders of the clergy, and that he imposed the same upon the inferior orders. He was also active in his persecution of heretics, and enlisted emperors and controlled councils to carry out his purposes. At this distance, and with such meager material from which to draw our information, it is difficult to say just how much this pope had to do with helping forward the change of the Sabbath, then well under way; but that he did assist in that unholy work, and do his part in fulfilling the prophecy of Dan. 7:25, is very evident. According to Dr. Justin Edwards, this pope made a decree in behalf of Sunday, in which he said: “We decree, according to the true meaning of the Holy Ghost, and of the apostles as thereby directed, that on the sacred day wherein our own integrity was restored, all do rest and cease from labor.”—Sabbath Manual, p. 123. When we remember that in A. D. 321, one hundred and nineteen years before Leo became pope, Constantine issued his famous edict in behalf of the “venerable day of the sun,” thus giving it a legal basis in the laws of the empire; and that Sylvester, Bishop of Rome, soon gave it a religious character by conferring upon it the imposing title of “Lord’s Day;” and that in A. D. 364 the Council of Laodicea prohibited the observance of the Sabbath, placing an anathema upon all who persisted in keeping it, how naturally the work of Leo the Great falls into line with the rest, ordaining that “all do cease from labor, and rest on the sacred day,” and claiming, like all the great successors of St. Peter, that what he ordains is “according to the true meaning of the Holy Ghost.” He thus puts the cap-stone upon this infamous arch of triumph over God’s law. No wonder, then, that he should be quoted as conclusive testimony. It is worthy of remark here that Valentinian III., who acted in concert with Leo the Great in the inauguration of his so-called reforms, was one of the most monstrous of the monsters who in that age disgraced the Roman purple. He murdered with his own hand the general who had saved his empire, and was guilty of other crimes too indecent to relate (See “Gibbon’s Rome,” vol. 3, pp. 205, 206). These two men were well calculated to work together for the extension of their own authority, balancing between them the civil and ecclesiastical power, holding with one hand the dogmas of the Church, and with the other the sword of State, and demanding from all instant and exact obedience. It was in this way that “reforms” were brought about in those times. But in the sixteenth century the era of reform based on God’s word commenced. This reform began with the then latest assumption of Rome—the sale of indulgences; and it has been steadily working its way back to the only foundation, the “Scriptures of truth.” And now we are examining one of the earliest works of the great apostasy, the change of the Sabbath to Sunday, and questioning the right of men to change one of the ten precepts of God’s law. Thus the last great reformation that was to take place just before the coming of the Son of man to reap the harvest of the earth (Rev. 14:12–14) is based upon the “commandments of God and the faith of Jesus,” and must develop a people keeping them all, the fourth precept with the rest. And let me conclude in the words of a great but much ignored authority: “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work; thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates; for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.”