THE CHRISTIAN UNION AND THE SABBATH

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 22, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 38.

Read the full edition

THE CHRISTIAN UNION AND THE SABBATH.

In the Christian Union of Sept. 10, 1885, will be found a communication from one of its correspondents on the Sabbath question, and the reply of the editors thereto, which we deem will be of sufficient interest to our readers, to be given entire as we present them below. The Christian Union, under recent enlargements and improvements, with a large extension of its field of contributors, has come to take equal rank with any representative of the religious press in this country, surpassed by none in intellectual, and, from its stand-point, religious, vigor; and we are glad to see a consideration of the Sabbath question occasionally coming to the front in such organs as these. The correspondent wrote:—
“Since you are so friendly to troubled and weary ones through the columns of your paper, I cannot hesitate in complying with the request of my friend Mrs. M. R. W., a subscriber to the Christian Union, who asks me to question you in regard to the seventh-day doctrine of Second Adventism. I hardly know how to put the case to give the right impression as to what may be needed in answer, and my desire was for her to write the letter instead of myself, feeling sure that her yearning for light on the subject would make itself manifest and secure a speedy answer. We both have constantly read your paper the last year, and been greatly interested in your helpful answers to troubled hearts. For myself, I have to thank you for much good cheer and comfort in the Christian Union, particularly through a long convalescence from sickness last year. So often has a bit of spiritual good come to me in your columns that I can with less embarrassment urge a friend’s earnest longing for light upon a vexed question, in the confidence that you can so counsel as to help her.”
“The points especially mentioned by her are:— “1. When was the change made from seventh to first day of the week? “2. Why was it made? “3. How can we infer God’s sanction of the change when nowhere in his word does he own and bless the first day as Sabbath, and in so many places distinctly hallows and sanctifies the seventh? “What tracts or other literature are there in candid refutation of this doctrine?”
“About six weeks ago some Advent ‘Elders’ put up their tents and began a series of meetings, expounding the Scriptures, and finally working strongly to their peculiar doctrines. They seem to be earnest, devout Christians. People went to hear them partly from curiosity. Several have been greatly interested in their preaching, and claim to have been spiritually profited—good, orthodox sisters mainly, who think the Elders are godly, simple, fervent preachers. Three or four are considerably tinctured now with Adventism, who belong to our one church (Congregational) here; and some of those who lean the most that way are those whom people generally would not suspect of changing. A few more flighty, less intelligent ones naturally veered over at once. One minister came out in a sermon not calculated to help the candid, investigating mind, because he was self-assertive, and made sweeping statements that he did not prove from the Bible. The Elders reasoned more calmly, and, it must be confessed, as many thought, more ably; and they make a great impression on some because of going so closely by Scripture. They claim that our Sunday is the papal Sabbath, not universally settled upon till the Romish Church, by device of Satan, brought it about, and that God’s certain punishment must fall upon those who, after being enlightened, fail to hallow the seventh day as God commanded. That text in the New Testament they so strongly emphasize, the women not going with spices till after the Sabbath, but keeping that ‘according to the commandment.’”
“For myself, I can’t see why nor how the change was made, and it does not seem clear that the change was established wholly by Christian motive; but I can see no good to be made by changing, and what study I have made into the subject has seemed to confirm the significance of the term ‘Lord’s day,’ as referring to Sunday, the resurrection day. I never thought much about it before, but now I shall always better love the sound of ‘Lord’s day’ than Sabbath day or Sunday.”
To this the editors of the Union, under the heading, “Which is the Sabbath?” respond as follows:—
“In another column we publish portions of a letter from an inquiring friend, who puts in a candid and clear manner the difficulty which an honest and conscientious mind feels in solving this question when urged to a literal observance of the fourth commandment and a maintenance of the seventh day of the week in place of the first. We can in a short space here only give a very brief and general answer to her inquiry.”
“We have no doubt that the advocates of a seventh-day observance are thoroughly honest, sincere, and conscientious; and can count some personal friends among them. If we believed, as they appear to do, that the Bible is a book of specific statutes and rigid rules, and that religion consists in an exact compliance with them, we might find some difficulty in avoiding their conclusions. We do not so read the Bible, nor so understand the nature of religion. The object of the Bible is the development of a Christian character; that is, of a character conforming to and modeled upon that of Jesus Christ. This is also the object of all religious institutions, ordinances, and instruction. None of them are an end in themselves; they are all a means to an end. Paul expressly declares this in more than one passage, one of which will, however, suffice for our quotation here: ‘And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ; till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ.’ That use, therefore, of the church and its ordinances, of the Bible and its teachings, of the Sabbath and of sacred institutions, is best which best conduces to this definite end. Now, it is the almost universal usage of Christendom to take for its day of rest and of worship the first day of the week. This is just as serviceable spiritually as the seventh day of the week. He who attempts to take the seventh instead of the first runs counter to Christian usage, without any well-defined spiritual advantage to himself or others. Not only that; he experiences great disadvantage both for himself and others. The majority of the community is ready to be reached on the first day of the week; it is not easily reached on the seventh; worshiping assemblies can be found in every village in the land on the first day of the week; only in rare and exceptional communities can such worshiping assemblies be found upon the seventh. He has every advantage for work and worship on the one day, every disadvantage on the other. He who insists upon it that the Christian must observe one day rather than the other must either show a great corresponding spiritual advantage, or he must show a very clear and explicit command.”
“Now, there is no such clear and explicit command. There is in the twentieth chapter of Exodus a general law requiring men to work for six days and rest upon the seventh, but it does not even specify, still less does it put any stress upon, the particular day to be observed. A, who works from Monday morning until Saturday night, and rests on Sunday, works six days and rests upon the seventh as truly, and even as literally, as B, who works from Sunday morning till Friday night and rests on Saturday. Throughout the Old Testament, while great stress is laid upon the observance of the Sabbath, nowhere is stress laid upon one day rather than another; while in the New Testament Paul explicitly and in terms condemns as a violation of Christian liberty the action of those who insist upon one day rather than another. ‘One man,’ he says, ‘esteemeth one day above another; another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind. He that regardeth the day regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the Lord he doth not regard it.’ In Colossians 2:16, he is even more explicit: ‘Let no man, therefore, judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of a holy day, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days.’”
“We hold, then, in answer to our correspondent, that the Christian is bound to observe the Sabbath day, not because God has a statute fixing a particular point of time in the calendar to be set apart for a particular observance, but because humanity needs stated times for such worship and special religious activities; that the fourth commandment is an interpretation of this natural law, written in man’s physical and spiritual nature, as each of the other ten commandments is an interpretation of a natural law written in man’s nature before it was written on the tables of stone; that the early Christians, beginning in apostolic times, substituted the day of Christ’s resurrection in place of Christ’s entombment as their festal holy day, needing therefore no special, definite command or authorization; and that in our own time it is not only our right but our duty, in the exercise of our Christian liberty, to take that day for observance which experience proves best fitted to build us up and the community up in all those qualities which constitute a Christian and divine manhood.”
We thank the Union for its recognition of the honesty, sincerity, and conscientiousness of the observers of the seventh day, which estimate we believe from an extensive acquaintance will very generally hold good as applied to them. It is also right in supposing them to hold that “the Bible is a book of specific statutes and rigid rules,” not however in any servile sense, and that “religion consists in [we would rather say ‘includes’] an exact compliance with them.” That is to say, we believe that God has laid upon men specific duties, governed by specific rules, and that he has made known these in that Book which he has given as a revelation of his will; and further that when God’s will can be ascertained, and his directions in any matter be understood, they should be complied with to the very letter, in the spirit of loving obedience. “Religion” is defined to be, “The recognition of God as an object of worship, love, and obedience.” Great stress is laid upon this matter of obedience in the Scriptures, as an essential of religion; and God has everywhere shown himself, as he could not otherwise consistently do, to be very particular in regard to the manner in which his directions are complied with.
As an instance we may refer to the case of Nadab and Abihu. Lev. 10:1, 2. God had provided a certain kind of fire which they were to use with their offerings. We are not told that its constituent elements were any different from those of any fire; but God had directed that they must use that and no other. These sons of Aaron, however, perhaps following a line of argument which the Union, if we understand the tenor of its article, would in large measure, at least, justify, may have reasoned like this: “Fire is fire; one kind of fire will burn as well as another; the only essential thing is to have fire, and what difference can it make which we take?” And so they offered common fire. But their reasoning did not satisfy the Lord; and they paid with their lives the penalty of not acting exactly as he had instructed them.
This illustrates the degree to which we hold that God’s requirements are “rigid,” and the extent to which we believe our compliance with them should be “exact.” If God should place before a person a lamb and a goat, directing him to kill the goat, but save the lamb alive, we do not believe the person would in any manner comply with those directions by killing the lamb and saving the goat alive. To be sure he might reason like this: “Here are placed before me two animals; one of them I am to kill, but the other keep alive. I have no clear and explicit command which one is to be kept alive. True, the Lord said, ‘the lamb’; but we are not to understand that specifically as meaning that particular animal, but in a general sense, as only one of the two. Therefore I will kill the lamb and keep the goat alive.” Would that reasoning answer?
Just so we believe in regard to the Sabbath. God has given us the weekly cycle consisting of seven days. It came from his hand at the beginning of this world’s history. No other origin can be assigned to it. One of these days is set apart as the Sabbath, to be devoted to rest and worship. And all the circumstances of the institution of the Sabbath would seem to point to a definite and particular day. It was the day on which he rested at the creation, the day he blessed, the day he sanctified, or, to define the term, “set apart, to a holy or religious use.” And if God designs that a particular day should be kept as the Sabbath, we believe it is all important that just that day be kept and no other. Hence if there is any question to be raised, it should not be relegated to the low plane of discussing whether or not we may place our own estimate on the importance of obedience, and keep any day or no day as we may choose, but should rather be directed toward ascertaining what day that is which God required.
And this, it seems to us, is very easily ascertained. The Union says that there is no “clear and explicit command.” This raises in our mind the query what that paper would consider an explicit command. It did not overlook the fourth commandment; for it refers to that very law, and then, strange to say, declares that “it does not even specify, still less does it put any stress upon, the particular day to be observed.” If the commandment as it now reads does not specify the day, how should it read to specify it? The answer will doubtless be, “Oh, it does not say, ‘seventh day of the week’; and it needs that clause to make it definite.” This should not too readily be taken for granted. According to the position of our friends, the commandment should read, “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. The first six days of the week thou shalt labor and do all thy work; but the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work,” etc. Would it be any more definite if thus expressed, than it is now? For what is the week? where does it begin, and where end? and what determines its boundaries? We fancy our friends, even with this language, could easily adjust themselves to any Sabbath they might choose; and if some one should claim that the Scriptures demanded a different day from the one they were keeping, we imagine we hear them say, “What is a week? It is a period of seven days; and any seven days, begin or end them where we will, constitute a week; so that ‘A, who works from Monday morning until Saturday night, and rests on Sunday, works six days and rests upon the seventh day of the week’ as truly and even as literally, as B, who works from Sunday morning till Friday night and rests on Saturday.”
Would not this be the method of reasoning? and on this ground would not the commandment be just exactly as indefinite if it said “seventh day of the week,” as it is supposed to be as it now stands? Verily, it would. Thus we see it would be utterly impossible to make the commandment definite, even on their own showing, unless we abandon the idea of a sliding week beginning and ending anywhere, and make the week a definite, fixed period, with its days from one to seven unchangeably located, so that the first day of the week is always the same day, and so with the second, third, etc. Then, of course, the seventh day “of the week” would be a definite specified day. Do you then say that the week is a period of such a nature as this? Very well; then let us look again at the commandment. The commandment says, “the seventh day;” not a seventh day, or any seventh day, or every seventh day, or the seventh day after any six of labor; but, “the seventh day.” Now there can be no regularly recurring seventh day, except the seventh day of some definite period of time, as the week, month or year. Then we ask, What period is the day of the commandment the seventh day of? You say it is not the seventh day of the week. Then, pray, what is it the seventh day of? Is it of the month or of the year? Then why is it not so specified? and why do you in fancied obedience thereto observe a Sabbath every week? If it is not the seventh day of the week, how is it possible for any man to show that the commandment enjoins a weekly day of rest? No man could show it. And the fact that every one, without exception, who undertakes to obey that commandment makes his Sabbath a weekly observance, is the universal testimony of Christendom, expressing the innate conviction of every heart, that the fourth commandment has to do with the week. But if it has, then the seventh day of that commandment is the seventh day of the week, just as absolutely as if those words were expressed.
But the matter is not left to this process of reasoning, conclusive as this is, on the point. The commandment carries the mind back to the institution of the Sabbath in the beginning; and the record is found in Gen. 2:1, 2. God wrought six days in creating all things, and rested the seventh day. God, Adam, and Eve were the personages on the scene as the seventh day was drawing to its close. Let us in imagination go back to that time and join the company. The seventh day ends. The first week of time is now complete. It is a finished cycle; and God proceeds to make it a permanent one. He does this by the institution of the Sabbath. Looking back upon the past period he pronounces a blessing upon its last, or seventh, day. The reason given for this act was that upon that day he had rested. Then he sanctified the day; that is, as the word signifies, he set it apart to a holy or religious use. Who was to use it then?—Man; for our Saviour says, “The Sabbath was made for man.” And there in the presence of Adam God could set it apart to be used in a religious manner by him and his posterity only by telling him explicitly how to use it. Here then is a record that a Sabbath law—the original of the fourth commandment—was given to Adam in Eden. But the seventh day that was then past could not be used by Adam in any manner; hence the sanctification pertained to the future, setting apart every seventh day for time to come; and this at once necessitated the counting of days by sevens, in order to preserve and hallow every seventh day according to God’s commandment.
It seems unnecessary now to ask whether the Sabbath was a definite day or not. If God rested on any particular day, it was; if he blessed any particular day, it was; for we are to keep the very day he blessed and hallowed; and to that day and no other the fourth commandment refers us, and commands us to keep—the day God blessed and sanctified—the definite seventh day of the first weekly cycle, and of every succeeding weekly cycle, of time. Yet notwithstanding all this, we hear men saying, “There is no clear and explicit command,” and that the commandment “does not even specify the particular day to be observed.”
Should any one say that the day originally set apart has been lost, it would be sufficient to reply that God knew the day when he gave the law from Sinai, and pointed it out to the Israelites for forty years by the threefold miracle of the manna. It was then carefully guarded by that people till the time of Christ; and when he, the Son of God, appeared upon the earth, he knew the day and always recognized and honored it; and no one will deny that the week as established at the present day is identical with the week of the New Testament, as still preserved and reckoned by the Jews.
The Union appeals to the “almost universal usage of Christendom” in regarding the first day of the week as its day of rest and worship, as an argument against any change. But when Luther began his reform was not “the almost universal usage” and sentiment of Christendom against him? Was it not so with the reform introduced by the Wesleys and the Baptists? Has it not been so with all reformers? There is a question lying back of that condition of things appealed to by the Union; namely, How has this usage come to be established? The time was when Sunday was not thus universally established, and the usage of almost all Christendom was very different. Why the change? Was it introduced for good and Scriptural reasons? If it was, let us perpetuate it. If not, let us discard it. We could wish the Union had answered a little more definitely the query of its correspondent why the Sabbath was changed from the seventh to the first day of the week.
Finally we discover what seems to us, if not a contradiction, at least an inconsistency, in the position of our esteemed contemporary. It quotes the apostle’s words to the Romans, “Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind” (Rom. 14:5), and to the Colossians, “Let no man judge you in meat or drink, or in respect of . . . the sabbath days” (Col. 2:16), as applicable to this subject. But if these apply to the Sabbath at all they prove that there is no Sabbath; for that of which Paul wrote to the Romans, they might omit at pleasure if they chose, and that concerning which he wrote to the Colossians was “blotted out,” and “nailed to the cross” (verse 14), and was only “a shadow of things to come,” which could not endure beyond the body, which pertained to our Lord Jesus Christ. Verse 17. There was nothing shadowy in the ten commandments, no “hand-writing of ordinances,” no meats and drinks, as the apostle mentions to both the Romans and Colossians. Nevertheless the Union represents that this language applies to that moral system, instead of to the ceremonial, as we think. Yet it says further:—
“We hold, then, in answer to our correspondent, that the Christian is bound to observe the Sabbath day.”
What! bound to observe an institution which has been blotted out, nailed to the cross, and lost as a shadow in its substance? Rather every Christian is bound not to observe that which Christ has taken such pains to put out of the way.
But an unpleasant fact stares in the face this application of these scriptures—a fact which the Union is compelled to recognize; and that is, that “humanity needs stated times for such worship and special religious activities.” Yes, the need of the Sabbath is deeply stamped upon man’s moral, mental, and physical nature. Then why should God, having had such provision, answering all these needs, from the beginning to the advent of his Son, then take it out of the way, and leave men to shift for themselves as best they could, during what is designed to be the last and best dispensation of his grace?
Some spiritual advantage, it is said, must be shown in the change from the first to the seventh day. Very well, is there not great spiritual advantage in the thought that we have the truth as God has revealed it, and are obeying him just as he has directed, and that God the Maker of all worlds is our God. For without the Sabbath of the fourth commandment no people, not even our friends of the Christian Union, can show that they are worshipers of the true God.