WILL THE JEWS RENOUNCE THE ANCIENT SABBATH?
By E. W. Whitney
THEY certainly will if they take the advice of modern conformists; for the influences and pressure in that direction are becoming so strong that such a result seems only to be a matter of time with all who do not hold the observance of the ancient Sabbath of the Lord from a higher motive than simply maintaining forms of Judaism. The following article, which appeared editorially in the Syracuse (N. Y.) Herald of Sept. 13, under the heading, “A Revival of Judaism,” indicates what influences are to be brought to bear upon this question of Sabbath observance, not only among the Jews, but with all, whether Jews or Christians, who hold to the observance of the Sabbath of the fourth commandment:— “About a year ago, at the annual meeting of the executive board of the Union of American-Hebrew Congregations, it was decided to issue a circular letter to all the Jewish ministers of the country, containing the following inquiry:— “What measures seem to you practicable to assure the rising generation of Jews such Jewish teaching as will more surely tend to create in them an active interest in Jewish affairs and an earnest participation in the intellectual and moral life of the Jewish community? “Answers have been received from about two hundred rabbis, and the replies show a marked unanimity of belief that Judaism in America is not in the condition it should be, and that there is urgent need of measures which will correct the wrong tendencies and growing evils.” After giving several of the answers returned, the editor gives his answer, which he considers sets forth the only “effectual remedy.” He says:— “All these reforms are well enough as far as they go, but do they reach the real seat of the trouble with the Hebrew Church in America? If they could be carried out, the wished-for revival would doubtless be an actuality; but several of the suggestions are more of the nature of effects than causes. If the awakening were realized, it would bring about the beneficent improvements which are named as the means of producing it. The Hebrews are possessed of keen intellects and quick perceptions, and it is not astonishing that the young men of the race who have received superior education should have been influenced by the atheistic and materialistic spirit of the age. Religious forms, where still retained as a principal feature of worship, are not esteemed with the reverence once paid them. They are not infrequently regarded as mainly ministers to the higher tastes, not as enjoined with the authority of divine command. The ‘reform’ branch of the Hebrew Church has been particularly advanced, and the more conservative Jews view with the deepest sorrow the rapid demolition of revered customs by the iconoclasts. “In the general shaking and modification of religious faith, therefore, the Hebrew Church has not escaped, and it is met with the practical question, What shall be done in the present emergency? It is, of course, not to be expected that the Church will readily adopt any course which will involve the surrender of cherished dogmas; but is it not reasonable that a radical remedy can be the only effectual one? It is indisputable that the lack of interest on the part of the young in the Jewish religious assemblies is in no small measure due to the fact that they are held during the secular days of the week. The Jewish Sabbath is not a holiday or half holiday in the law, and hence Jews are compelled to follow on that day, very largely, their ordinary vocations. To change their Sabbath day to the Christian Sunday would be a violent wrench for the orthodox Hebrews, but, once made, would it not be of great benefit? [Italics mine.] What would become of the congregations if any one denomination of Christians should select Wednesday for its Sabbath? It is plain that the Hebrew Church would undergo a decided revival if its Sabbath could be made to conform with the Sabbath of Christians and the legal weekly holiday of the government [Italics mine]; but it is too much to expect that the innovation will be made, at least very soon. Such a concession, in the opinion of the Jews, would doubtless be too great, even with the most alluring promises of prosperity.” When such suggestions and advice as the above shall deepen into a universal demand that all observers of the seventh day shall renounce such observance, the question will be quickly settled by all who hold seventh-day observance merely as a form. But God will have those at such a time, as he has had in the past, who will honor him by keeping all his commandments, and take the consequences, even though they be—persecution, imprisonment, and death,—“Israelites indeed, in whom is no guile.” E. W. WHITNEY.