THE MANNA AND THE SABBATH

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 11, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 10.

Read the full edition

THE MANNA AND THE SABBATH.

As we occasionally find opportunity to glance over some of our exchanges, our eye chanced to fall upon the World’s Crisis of Feb. 19, 1890. In this paper we notice that Wm. Sheldon is still amusing himself, and trying to amuse his readers, by false assertions and foolish hypotheses in reference to the Sabbath question. This time he strikes the manna in the wilderness, and imagines that he has opened a large mine of discovery, showing that the seventh-day Sabbath was then and there instituted.
Briefly summarized, the points he endeavors to make are these: The children of Israel came into the wilderness between Elim and Sinai on the 15th day of the second month; and as soon as they reached that spot, they discovered all at once that they were right on the verge of starvation, and must have food or immediately perish. That very night, he claims, God sent them quails, and gave them manna in the morning. This makes the falling of the manna commence on the 16th; then the manna was to fall six days, and the seventh day from that point was (we suppose without any reference to the day of the week) to be the Sabbath. This would bring the Sabbath on the 22d day of the month. Having thus, as he fondly conjectures, found the day of the month on which the first seventh-day Sabbath fell, he then seems to find a vast amount of amusement in counting back to see what he will find on preceding seventh days. So he finds the whole congregation journeying from Elim to Sin on the seventh day, and all Israel crossing the Red Sea some weeks before on the seventh day, and on the 10th day of the first month, also the seventh day, all the people catching the passover lambs to be kept up to the 14th. “What a sight,” he says, “about 100,000 lambs being chased down on the Sabbath by divine appointment! Six hundred thousand people crossing the Red Sea on the Sabbath! And 600,000 marching from Elim to the wilderness of Sin on the Sabbath!” He needn’t be so modest here; for the whole host (and we always supposed they went together) numbered some 3,000,000.
But let us now touch his wonderful structure with a feather, and see how much it will stand. In the first place, there isn’t the least particle of proof that it was the very day they reached the wilderness of Sin, when they found themselves starving, and clamored so lustily for food. Mr. S. will have it that the food supply of every single man of them gave out the same instant, that every one became equally hungry the same moment, and that every one in that vast crowd knew exactly what to do, and that was to rail out against Moses. But any one can see, on a moment’s thought, that such a condition of things could not be produced at once in such a company; the exhaustion of the supply of food would be gradual, and it would take some days, at least, before the whole congregation would come thus to act in concert against Moses and Aaron. Verse 2 of Exodus 16 reads: “And the whole congregation of the children of Israel murmured against Moses and Aaron in the wilderness.” That is, while they were there in the wilderness, they fell into this trouble; not by any means the very moment they arrived there.
Secondly, he then has the manna fall six days, and then the seventh, counting from the first day of the manna, is taken and made into a Sabbath. But the record does not say that the manna was to fall, or that it did fall, six days before the Sabbath. It says nothing at all on that point. But they were to gather a certain amount every day (Ex. 16:4), and a double quantity on the sixth day; and this direction was not for that one occasion merely, but was the general direction to govern their action during the whole forty years the manna was to fall. (See verses 26-29.) On every sixth day they were to gather the double quantity, and on every seventh day it was to be withheld, and the people were to rest. These were the sixth and seventh days of the week, and had no reference whatever to the time when the manna began to fall. There is not the
least particle of proof that the manna began to fall six days before the Sabbath. It could just as well have been in any other part of the week. The two points, therefore, on which his whole argument depends, are bald and barefaced assumptions: the one against every probability in the case, and the other against the plain text of the record.
What follows?—It follows that the manna did not begin to fall the 16th of the month; the 22d was not the Sabbath; the people did not journey from Elim to the wilderness of Sin on the Sabbath; they did not cross the Red Sea on the Sabbath; they did not catch their passover lambs on the Sabbath; and the Sabbath was not the great “lamb-catching day” of that occasion, into the belief of which he would evidently fain try to laugh himself.
Then what becomes of Mr. S’s daintily built structure upon which he dotes with such glee?—Gone to the dogs, where it belongs. What a blessing it would be if all who set themselves up as teachers would try to weave into their theories a little intelligent thought, enough at any rate to entitle them to some consideration.