STATE CHAPLAINS

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 28, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 13.

Read the full edition

STATE CHAPLAINS.

The sectarian teaching of the Lutheran chaplain of the Illinois penitentiary at Joliet, which has caused such a hubbub in that State, is used as a text by General M. M. Trumbull, in the Open Court, to show the folly of State paid chaplains, in his usual interesting and characteristic manner, thus:—
“The attempt to make the Joliet penitentiary sectarian is meeting with much indignant opposition, and the governor of the State is called upon to interfere in behalf of all denominations. The complaint is that religion in the penitentiary is under the control of a trust composed exclusively of Lutherans and Roman Catholics; that the convicts must get spiritual food from those denominations or go hungry altogether, and that as the State at large must pay for the food, the discrimination is unfair. A settlement of the trouble is not easy, because we have no moral standard by which to measure a practice alien to the constitution of the State, the appointment of chaplains for public institutions. Where a State religion is unlawful, a State chaplain ought to be unlawful, too; but if we must have the luxury of a chaplain for the penitentiary, or the legislature, or the insane asylum, the constitution being broken in his appointment, what matters it in which religious direction the lines of the fracture go? What matters it whether the chaplain of the penitentiary be Catholic, Lutheran, Methodist, or Jew, except as the convicts themselves may have an interest in the question; and in that case, they ought to be allowed to decide what faith should or should not be preached in the penitentiary. It may be that the religious views of the convicts have been consulted in the selection of chaplains, and if so, that ought to be satisfactory all around. If the convicts are mostly Lutherans and Catholics, what right have the Methodists or the Baptists or the Presbyterians to complain that a Catholic or a Lutheran is chaplain? If those complaining sects can prove that they are more largely represented in the penitentiary than the Catholics or the Lutherans, that is another matter. The church that contributes the largest number of convicts ought to have the chaplain.”