JUDGE WAITE'S OPINION OF SUNDAY-CLOSING

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 16, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 20.

Read the full edition

JUDGE WAITE'S OPINION OF SUNDAY-CLOSING.

While the question of opening or closing the World's Fair on Sunday is now an all-absorbing topic of conversation, we are glad to be able to present to our readers the opinion of so eminent a jurist as Judge C. B. Waite, formerly territorial judge of Utah. It will be apparent to those who read what the judge has to say, that all the legal talent in our land is not yet blinded by religious bigotry. We clip the report from the Chicago Evening Journal, of May 3, as given by a reporter of that paper:—
“In order to discuss this matter intelligently, we must begin at the beginning, and see who have rights, and who have none in the land upon which the glorious White City, that most marvelous of man's creations, is builded. That entire domain originally belonged to the people, and they have never parted with their ownership in it. The South Park commissioners only hold it by virtue of the Legislature of the State of Illinois, in trust for the whole people of Illinois, for purposes of amusement and recreation, and to be free to them for such uses forever. It is, therefore, extremely doubtful whether the legislature, in the face of that public dedication, had any right to grant the exclusive use of the land so devoted forever to the free use of the people for purposes of amusement and recreation, to a corporation which is but the creature of the people, after all—the World's Columbian Exhibition Company. But I do not wish to raise any fight on that question, nor do the people. We are well satisfied that the Exposition should fence off the ground and charge an admission fee, because the Fair is for the good of the people, and temporary use of the ground is in the highest interest of public policy so long as no unjust discrimination is made. But just the moment discrimination begins, such as making rules and regulations at the dictation of the classes against the protest of the masses of the people; or in other words, when in deference to the religious opinions of comparatively a few, the gates are to be closed on the one day in the week when the countless many of the people have an opportunity to exercise their right to use the park for purposes of amusement and recreation, the aspect of the matter changes materially.”
“In presenting this view of the case to a very eminent constitutional lawyer of this city not long ago, he said: ‘Should that issue ever be raised, it will prove a very serious question of law, a very serious question indeed.’”
“‘But has not the national government—Congress—a right to say whether a national fair shall be closed or open on Sunday?’”
“‘There is no title in the United States government, and therefore it has no jurisdiction in either the park or grounds. How could Federal authorities close the gates, if they do not own the grounds? In a legal sense, the World's Fair is not a national institution, because it is an enterprise undertaken by an Illinois corporation, principally paid for by the city of Chicago, the State of Illinois, and private citizens. It has received aid, comfort,—sometimes very cold comfort,—and financial assistance from Congress and from the National Executive. But all that does not alter the fact that it is the Illinois corporation to which the people's title in the ground was delegated, temporarily, and if that delegation was not legal, the title still remains in the people of Illinois, nor can the national government set up even the shadow of an excuse for assuming jurisdiction over it.’”
“‘Do you hold, then, that Congress in granting money for the Fair had no right to make its own conditions? The condition was that the Fair should be closed on Sundays. Since the Exposition accepted the money, with the condition attached, is not the directory legally and morally bound to observe the condition? It is contended, you know, that Congress settled the Sunday question once and for all, and that it must not be reopened.’”
“‘The directory, in my opinion, is neither legally nor morally bound by that act of Congress. In the first place, the grant was in the nature of a contract, and Congress itself violated its conditions. Two million five hundred thousand dollars were appropriated for a specific purpose—the preparation of the Fair—conditioned upon the Fair being closed on Sundays. In good faith the Exposition accepted that appropriation, but later on, throwing faith to the winds and violating the terms of its contract, Congress sequestered $570,880 of the grant from its declared purpose, the preparation of the Fair, thus seriously crippling and embarrassing the directory who had depended, in good faith, upon the use of this money. Congress by its act of bad faith, withdrew over one fifth of its gift, and directed that unless the directory gave bonds for the restoration of that money to the national treasury, 1,141,760 of the souvenir coins were to be withheld. The directory finds itself unable legally to execute the bonds demanded, because its credit is already pledged to the limit—hence it is denied the use of $570,880 at a critical time in the preparation of the Fair.’”
“‘In case the directory should decide to open the gates on Sunday, would they be morally and legally bound to refund that part of the grant that has been paid over?’”
“‘Certainly not, and for this reason: I am not in active practice now, though I was for many years, but my recollection of the law is this: In case of a gift, bequest, or devise, the person making it could attach any condition he chose, and were that condition ever so whimsical or frivolous, the courts would sustain that condition. They would not give the gift effect unless the condition was performed, with one exception,—if the condition were illegal or contrary to public policy, then the condition would be void, and the gift or bequest would stand being in that case considered in law as unconditional. If my recollection of the law is correct, they would not be obliged to refund the money, even if there had been no violation of its own contract by Congress, because I look upon the condition as entirely illegal and unconstitutional, and, therefore, void. There might, of course, have been a question of propriety under those circumstances, which has been eliminated from the subject in view of Congress's breach of good faith. Had an individual done what Congress has been guilty of, it would be very properly called a dishonorable act.’”
“‘On what grounds do you maintain that the condition was illegal, and therefore void?’”
“‘The first amendment to the Constitution provides that “Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Judge Storey has said, in his “Commentaries on the Constitution,” that the intention in this provision was not merely that Congress should not establish a national religion, but that Congress should not legislate at all on the subject of religion. That view is sustained by the practice of the government for over one hundred years. In all that time we have had no religious legislation whatever, until the last Congress overstepped its powers by enacting the Sunday observance proviso contained in that bill, which appropriated $2,500,000 for the World's Columbian Exposition.’”
“‘That point is disputed, Judge. Many of the leading advocates of Sunday-closing claim that it is not a religious question at all, but merely a provision for a day of rest in the interest of health and comfort.’”
“‘That is all nonsense. It is merely a subterfuge to which our friends the enemy resort, when they find that the laws and institutions of this country are in opposition with their religious views of what ought to be. This is a religious question, and must be battled for or against as such. If it is not, how did it happen that when the question was under discussion in the Senate, Senator Matthew Quay, Pennsylvania's pious representative and moral exemplar, sent to the clerk's desk to be read as his argument, the Bible opened and marked at the decalogue? There are some people who deny that Mr. Quay did this on religious grounds, but the senator's career of sanctity and the quotation he had read, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy,” etc., disposes of that argument. Furthermore, how did it come that the ministers and church people took such an active part before the Congressional Committee, if this is not a religious question, to say nothing of the hysterical shrieks of the religious press and a part of the secular press, led by the New York Mail and Express, for “the sanctity of the American Sabbath”? One minister, writing to the New York Independent, said that any one who attended the sessions of that Congressional Committee might have supposed himself in a general church assembly, a synod or an ecclesiastical council. That statement was true; for it was a religious question that was under discussion, and the zealous advocates of what is popularly known as a “Christian Sabbath”—a strange contradiction of terms even on their own grounds—were those who pressed the fight for Sunday-closing. To deny this self-evident fact, is both idle and dishonest.’”
“‘For all that, Judge, a great many earnest and honorable men declare that they only desire a civil rest day for the protection of the laboring classes against the encroachments of greedy employers.’”
“‘Then why, if the legislation is of that character, is Sunday specified? For my part, I deny the right of any legislative power to establish Sunday or any other day as a rest day. Nature designates that we should rest, but only when we are tired. She has made no arbitrary law regarding one day in seven, and it has been conceded by some of the most eminent ministers who petitioned Congress for the closing of the Exposition, that there are many prosperous nations who do not observe a Sabbath. This shows that the seventh-day-for-rest idea has no foundation in nature. They further admitted that their advocacy was almost exclusively on religious grounds.’”
“‘It is further contended that to open the Exposition on Sunday, would be in violation of the laws of Illinois.’”
“‘By no means. The State provides only for the prevention of the acts enumerated, when they disturb the worship or peace of other people. Who would be disturbed if the gates were open? Certainly not those holding religious services miles away. Who were disturbed during all the months that thousands of Sunday visitors flocked to Jackson Park, and paid their fifty cents to enter in and gaze on the glories of the great White City? If any such there were, they have carefully concealed the fact, for not one solitary complaint has been made, either to a magistrate or in the columns of the newspapers, including those of the religious press. No! The true reason of “Sunday disturbance” was frankly stated by Judge Ruffin, of North Carolina, in deciding a case brought before him. He decided against the disturbers, and said: “The disturbance consists not so much in that these people were prevented from carrying out their own opinions, but in the fact that they were doing what the complainants thought were wrong.” Just so here. They demand the closing of the Fair, because they believe in what is called “the sanctity of the American Sabbath.”’”
“‘Another thing, I have grave doubts of the constitutionality of the Sunday observance law of Illinois. So have many eminent lawyers and jurists. I have not given the matter the deep study it demands, but, as I view it, this is my reason: The Constitution provides that no preference shall be given by law to any religious denomination or mode of worship. The Christian religion is only one denomination, or mode of worship. Though it is split up into many sects and isms, they all have one broad basis, and all class themselves as Christians, and a peculiar observance of Sunday is a part of the mode of worship of some, indeed, a majority of these Christian sects, but not of all. Hence the setting apart of Sunday by law appears to me plainly “giving a preference” to one particular “religious denomination.” The Seventh-day Adventists and Baptists, for instance, construe literally the commandment to rest on the seventh day, Saturday, and to labor on the other six days. They hold that the command to labor is just as vital as the command to rest. Now, it might be that in pursuing their religious opinions, of which the Bill of Rights guarantees them free exercise, the noise of their labor might disturb some other religious denomination. In the case supposed, it is very doubtful whether the Legislature has any right to prohibit the disturbance. I think it is plain that the Sunday law is inconsistent with the Constitution, because it is giving a distinct preference by law for a mode of worship, and discriminating against all others—the Jewish, Mohammedan, Hindu, pagan, and other forms of worship which may be found within the borders of the State. The contention that the Christians only can be bound by this law, while all others must enjoy liberty of conscience, is of course absurd and ridiculous.’”
“‘John F. Geeting, the well-known lawyer, also holds positive opinions on the power of Congress to enforce the closing of the Fair. He said:—
“‘I do not believe that Congress has any power legally to close the gates of the World's Fair on Sunday. It has no jurisdiction over the park, which is the property of the State of Illinois. The Exposition Company is an Illinois corporation. Certainly the military arm of the government could not interfere to close the gates, if they should be thrown open; for the military arm is subordinate to the civil in time of peace. I can't see any grounds for an injunction; for such writs are granted only in cases of irreparable damage, such as the destruction of property, injury to business, etc., and certainly no irreparable damage can result to the United States government by the opening of the Fair on Sundays.’”
“‘Even should the United States government seek to recover the money paid over to the Fair by civil suit, such right, if it exists, does not extend to interfering with the Fair itself. If the park belonged to the United States government, the case might be different. The whole matter rests entirely with the Exposition Company. It has been given the control, and cannot be interfered with unless in violating some existing law. The condition on which the appropriation is made is of the nature of a contract, and not an enacted law. Furthermore, Congress is a body of special and limited powers, and has no authority to pass any law on such a subject. Any act recognizing Sunday, passed by Congress as a law, would be unconstitutional and absolutely void.’”