PROPOSITION TO CURTAIL THE RIGHT OF RELIGIOUS DISCUSSION.
By L. A. S.
As we have reached a time in the prophetic history of our country when it is scarcely in order to be surprised at anything whatever in the line of departures from the principles of justice and freedom laid down by our forefathers in the foundation of our system of government, we are fully prepared to hear from one of our eminent and influential citizens, a proposition to limit the freedom of religious discussion. Such a proposition comes from the “Right Rev. Leighton Coleman,” Bishop of Delaware, and appears in the January North American Review. It is of course directly contrary to the letter and spirit of our Constitution, which declares against any restriction upon freedom of speech or of the press, but as before stated, it is nothing unusual now for some men, especially those whose names are prefixed with “Reverend,” to profess greater wisdom in governmental affairs than was possessed by those who framed and adopted the Constitution. The bishop outlines his view as follows (we quote from the Weekly Review):— “Any discussion which involves disrespect to the fundamental principles of Christianity transcends all proper bounds. Courts and public opinion have always recognized Christianity as the national religion of America, and assaults upon it ought to be as treasonable as attacks on the government. Is it not treasonable to bring into contempt the essentials of Christianity, especially since this is a time of war—Christianity waging a conflict in which there is no discharge, and which will last as long as the world?” “Nothing is more injurious to the State than a lack of confidence between man and man. This is the risk that is run in allowing religious discussion to go on indefinitely and wantonly, robbing men of their faith in God and Christ, and so, in time, of their faith in one another; for faith in man has its highest development among those who believe in God.” This is exactly the plea that was made by the Church of Rome against Protestants, and it was just as good in their day and for their purposes as it is now for Protestants, or any others. The Lutherans persisted in discussions which involved disrespect to the “fundamental principles of Christianity” (in other words, the principles of the papacy), and of course in the eyes of papists they transcended all proper bounds, and were guilty of treason against the government. (Modern phraseology would also have said “anarchists.”) They created “a lack of confidence between man and man,” that is, between those who held to opposite views in religion, and this was felt by the papists to be something very hurtful to the State. Accordingly, they did their best to suppress such freedom of speech; and fortunate is it for us who live to-day, that their efforts were not successful. In the execution of such a purpose, a necessary preliminary would of course be the settlement of the question, What are the “fundamental principles of Christianity?” This thought did not escape the attention of the reverend bishop, and he has undertaken to lay down some of them, to which no doubt some others would have to be added. He says:— “First is the belief in the personality of Jesus Christ; next is the belief in him as both God and man. A few question the fact of his existence; more refuse to acknowledge his divinity. We know that he is more than human, and therefore perfect and beyond criticism, and assaults upon his goodness can have no place in a Christian land. “Christianity is the religion of reason, and of reason in its strength and purity. It is founded on facts; Christ is a person. And it is as being a person of perfection, the incarnate Son of God himself, that we feel that in assaulting Christianity, he is assaulted; and in assaulting him, all virtue and grace is assaulted; and in assaulting them, the very foundations of life are liable to be overthrown. “Limits must be set not only to such assaults, but also as regards the discussion of Christ’s commands. Baptism and the supper of the Lord are ordained by Christ himself; yet the question of their obligation is flippantly discussed! The question is beyond the legitimate limits of discussion. The mode of baptism may be discussed, but the question of its necessity has been settled, and ought not to be a matter of debate.” It would be very strange if “the fundamental principles of Christianity,” as viewed from the standpoint of popular religious belief, would not include the doctrines of Sunday sacredness and the immortality of the soul. The former of these has already the sanction of law to assist toward its further elevation as a fundamental principle of the faith against which it would be treason to speak; and when the attempt is made, if it ever is, to define “the fundamental principles of Christianity,” we shall be prepared to see these two dogmas fall easily and naturally into line with the rest. They are the two to which Christendom has held most tenaciously during all the theological revolutions and earthquakes of recent times. The truth or falsity of any doctrine would of course make no difference with the principle involved in the Rev. Mr. Coleman’s proposition. That proposition is as un-American and un-Christian as anything that ever emanated from paganism or the papacy, and its appearance here in the face of all that has hitherto distinguished this land as the home of civil and religious freedom, is a straw that shows the wind to be blowing from a very dangerous quarter. L. A. S.