WHAT CONGRESS CAN DO

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 6, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 23.

Read the full edition

WHAT CONGRESS CAN DO.

The Chicago Inter Ocean, of May 11, editorially says: “Congress could at any time, without any connection whatever with an appropriation, have decreed that the Fair should be closed on Sunday, or on any other day of the week, if its members chose.” This is certainly a strange position for an American citizen and an editor of a great daily newspaper to take. He leaves right entirely out of the question, and clothes Congress with all the powers and prerogatives of an absolute king, with the old, and now happily exploded theory that the king can do no wrong, still in vogue. Certainly if Congress can arbitrarily close the Fair upon any day of the week, without any reason for so doing other than a desire to show how big it is, what is there it cannot do? It might close a merchant’s store, prevent a farmer from gathering his crops, stop a blacksmith from shoeing a horse, or do any other outrage pleasing to the congressional mind! In short, Congress could become a perfect tyrant, interfering, not only in State matters, but also with the private and inherent rights of the people, whose sovereign will created Congress to serve the interests of the whole people, and not any part, faction, or particular religion. Congressmen knew this, and as they knew they had no constitutional right to close the Fair on Sunday by direct enactment, they attempted to do it another way,—by an appropriation conditioned upon Sunday-closing, which is held by many eminent lawyers and profound thinkers to be unconstitutional, at the same time being a most despicable and underhanded way of interfering with the affairs of the State of Illinois, and the rights of all who desire to visit the Fair on Sunday.
Congress is not a body with such unlimited powers that it could close the Fair upon Sunday or any other day, if it chose to do so. It certainly could not do it without violating the Constitution. The Constitution never gave to Congress any such dangerous authority. An authority so arbitrary, unnecessary, and unreasonable as this, which the Inter Ocean declares Congress could exercise, is only seen where all liberty is suppressed, and a king holding his power by divine (?) right rules according to his own will, without respect to the rights of the people, and without allowing that the people have any rights but such as he is pleased to grant them. It is just as dangerous to give to a Congress unlimited powers, as it is to give the same to one man. This fact was recognized by the founders of the American Republic, and for this reason the Constitution was adopted, defining and limiting the powers of Congress. Beyond the powers thus specified, Congress has no right to act; indeed, it cannot act; for when it exceeds its legitimate authority, no one is under any obligations to obey it. On the contrary, every citizen is under the highest obligations to his own dignity as a citizen, to other citizens, whose rights like his are also threatened, and to posterity, to resist such encroachment. The immortal Declaration of Independence, which so grandly asserted the rights of human liberty to all men, also declared that “whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or to abolish it.” To protest against and to refuse to obey, an unjust and tyrannical law, is the highest duty. The American revolution gave birth to the saying that resistance to tyrants was obedience to God, and this is equally true, whether applied to a Congress of tyrants or to a single tyrant.
The French Directory in the time of the French Revolution developed a tyranny that was never excelled by the worst autocrat that ever lived upon the earth. In the name of “liberty, equality, and fraternity,” liberty was unknown, equality but a promise that was never fulfilled, and fraternity a mingling of people who constantly feared that under the guise of friendship others were plotting to take their lives.
The people of the United States have not given to Congress all their rights. They have only surrendered a portion which are distinctly named. Every person has rights that he cannot give to any one, to any power or government. Congress represents the United States, acting for the States in their united capacity, and in relation to things especially enumerated in the Constitution. Beyond this Congress cannot go. Article X. of the Constitution declared that “the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively or to the people.” When the people of the United States allow Congress to take from them their rights which the Constitution absolutely prohibits that body from touching, they become the servants of Congress, instead of the masters. This would be an entire subversion of the principles upon which our government rests. And it is evident that the subversion of a principle so vital to the integrity and maintenance of the liberties of the people would pave the way for other steps of a like nature, until the people would be reduced to a condition of serfdom, and Congress, or whatever power Congress might set up, would rule with absolute sway. This being the case, we decidedly protest against such a surrender of rights as is indicated by the statement in the Inter Ocean. It is a position fraught with danger to the rights of the people. Congress has already threatened both religious and civil liberty.
To go further, and close the Fair by arbitrary act, would be a crime against the people, which, if submitted to, would be an important landmark in the decline and fall of the American Republic. That what Congress has already done has not stirred the people more than it has, shows that the people are largely in supine indifference as to their rights, no doubt fondly imagining them to be perfectly secure, and are willing to trust Congress to handle rights they never gave it; and by and by, when they look for their rights, they may be surprised to find that they have surrendered them, and they will have to get along without them the best they can, the same as the people of the Old World have been doing for ages. There is far more in this Sunday-closing movement than the majority of the American people are aware.
The interference of Congress, even in the condition accompanying the appropriation, is an inexcusable folly, and has already caused much trouble, and promises to become a serious damage to the Exposition, as well as to keep lawyers and courts busy for some years in the future. The powers of Congress should be exercised in preserving the rights of the people, not in trampling upon them; and when the people tamely submit to lose their rights without protest, and do not care enough about them to know when they are taken away, it is a sure sign of the decadence of the spirit of liberty, which gave our nation birth, and has thus far preserved it to be a beacon light and a harbor of refuge to the people of other lands, where freedom, as we understand it, is a thing unknown.
M. E. K.