AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 19., May 9, 1893

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

307.—MORTAL OR IMMORTAL?

The question has arisen in our Sabbath-school, whether or not Adam and Eve were created immortal. There is here some difference of opinion. Can you aid us through the Question Chair? J. B.

Answer.—This is a question over which a great many minds have allowed themselves to be puzzled; for it is reasoned, if Adam and Eve were created mortal, they must die, in any event; and if they were created immortal, they could not die; and yet eternal life was suspended upon their obedience, and death came into the world only by sin. It is assumed that they must have been created in one condition or the other, and hence the query. The trouble arises from this assumption. Immortality means, strictly and primarily, “exemption from corruption, decay, and death, not liable to disease.” If this condition can be maintained, of course eternal life is the result. Hence the word has come to be used as a synonym for “eternal and everlasting.” But strictly speaking, it means only a condition free from corruption and decay. Adam was created upright, pure, and innocent. Facilities were placed within his reach, by access to the tree of life, through which he could have maintained a state of exemption from disease, corruption, and death, and so have lived eternally. But this depended on his own actions. Adam’s immortality, therefore, depended in no wise on his creation, but only on his maintaining the conditions in which he was placed at his creation. And the question, therefore, whether he was created mortal or immortal, cannot properly be asked; for he could not be created in a condition which was to be developed only by his own actions after his creation. We could just as well ask the question, whether or not Adam was created a hundred years old.

308.—WAS MOSES RAISED?

If Moses was raised from the dead, and thus appeared on the mount of transfiguration as a representative of those who will be raised from the dead to enter Christ’s future kingdom, as taught by Seventh-day Adventists, how can Christ be said to be the first fruits of them that slept? 1 Cor. 15:20; Acts 26:23; Col. 1:18; Rev. 1:5. C. H. O.

Ans.—See this whole question explained at length in the chapter on the transfiguration, in the book entitled, “Here and Hereafter, or Man’s Nature and Destiny,” for sale at this Office, price one dollar, post-paid.

309.—THE AGE OF AHAZIAH.

Please harmonize 2 Kings 8:26, and 2 Chron. 22:2. One text states that Ahaziah was twenty-two years old when he began to reign, and the other says forty-two. Which is correct? J. D.

Ans.—These texts need no harmonizing. The passage in Kings corrects that in Chronicles. The statement in Chronicles is evidently the error of some transcriber; for the verses immediately precedingp. 297 give the age of the father of Ahaziah as forty years. “Thirty and two years old was he when he began to reign, and he reigned eight years.” Chapter 21:20. This would make him forty years old at the time of his death, when his son Ahaziah took the throne. And now, to state that this son was forty-two years old at that time, would make him two years older than his own father. Such a discrepancy within the space of three short verses, shows on the very face of it, that it is the blunder of some careless copyist. The statement in 2 Kings 8, is the correct reading.

310.—BLESS GOD, AND DIE. JOB 2:9.

In Job 2:9, I find the English Version reading, “Curse God, and die,” while in the German and Dutch Versions it reads, “Bless God, and die.” Which is correct? P. S.

Ans.—The word from which the English word “curse” in that passage is translated, is supposed to contain the idea of both blessing and cursing. If so, then either meaning could be given to it, according to whichever would seem to be most in accordance with the context. Dr. Clarke on this passage says, “We translate barech elohim va-muth, Curse God, and die. The verb barach, is supposed to include in it the idea of cursing and blessing; but it is not clear that it has the former meaning in any part of the sacred writings, though we sometimes translate it so.” He then goes on to state how, with this idea, it could be regarded as strong irony. Job was apparently dying of a loathsome disease, yet his heart was filled with gratitude to God. And his wife, filled with impatience and bitterness at the trial, says, “O yes, bless God for his goodness, if you will, while he is destroying you and all that you have. Bless on, and die.” There would certainly be force in this view of the subject.