PRAYERS AND PURGATORY

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 2, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 18.

Read the full edition

PRAYERS AND PURGATORY.

It is well known that the immediate cause of the Reformation under Luther was the coming of one Tetzel into Germany, selling indulgences, and saying masses for the release of souls in purgatory,—granting these great spiritual favors for a fixed sum, gauged according to the amount of money a person had, and the credulity with which he received the doctrines of the church. It is related that on one occasion, after having gathered in all the money he could, and having certified to his master the pope, the amount he had received, he had some friends call upon him, and found himself temporarily without funds for a feast. His ingenuity, however, was equal to the task. He had the church bell rung with great vigor, and summoned the people of the town together. Then he told them a pitiful story of how a poor soul in purgatory appeared to him, and begged for masses for his release. The sympathetic and credulous people at once responded to this crafty appeal, a generous collection was gathered in, and Tetzel and his friends feasted joyously on the rich viands procured with the money. It was against such doctrines and practices as this that Luther protested, and from that attempt to replenish the pope’s depleted treasury, arose the mighty religious upheaval which separated Germany from the papacy.
But has Rome changed in her doctrine or practice in respect to those points against which Luther and Melanchthon protested?—Not at all. She did, however, learn wisdom by what she suffered. She no longer sends a man with a strong box and a stentorian voice into the market places to advocate this doctrine, and rake in the money; that will no longer do, especially in countries where a fair degree of intelligence prevails. It is done quietly in the churches, where it will not attract the attention of the world. They have also a society, whose headquarters are in France, to raise money to pay for masses for the abandoned souls in purgatory. That is to say, they are not satisfied with what money they can gather in for prayers which they offer for those who have friends who are willing to pay to have them prayed out of purgatory; but they are playing the old Tetzel game over again, praying for abandoned souls, and from some items that occasionally appear in the Catholic papers, it would appear that they are still doing quite a profitable business at the old stand. The following, clipped from an article entitled “Praying for the Dead,” which appeared in the Catholic Mirror, of April 8, was taken from a French paper, and shows the amount of business reported to the head of the society in France for the month of February:—
“The resources of the work at ‘La Chapelle-Montligeon,’ France, have enabled the directors to have offered up during February, a total of 7,394 masses for forsaken souls. (This work has a center at Mt. Carmel, in this city, and already numbers 2,479 associates, scattered over the city, under many promoters.)”
Here we see that the directors of the society have received a sufficient sum to pay for 7,394 masses, or prayers, for “forsaken souls.” We are not sufficiently advanced in purgatorial lore to know what a mass costs (we know what it is worth), and so we cannot tell what these 7,394 prayers cost; but one dollar a prayer we presume would not be considered extravagant by a good Catholic. This, then, would represent the sum of $7,394 received by that one society during the month of February for the abandoned souls! This looks like a very fair volume of business, considering that the interests of souls in this present world generally absorbs the most of people’s attention and money.
The article quoted above also contains the following statement:—
“The United States, where everything is done on a grand scale, has received with honor the work for the abandoned souls in purgatory. To speak only of Baltimore, Rev. E. Didier has sent us, since August last, the names of 1,576 associates, and the handsome sum of 946 francs. There are in Baltimore ten head-promoters of the work.”
We gather from the above that those who solicit money for this purpose are called “head-promoters,” and that all who contribute are known as “associates.” This society probably extends wherever there are Catholics.
We give also from the same article the following letters received at the headquarters of the society from those sending money:—
“I come to fulfill a promise which I made to the poor souls in purgatory, if an affair succeeded according to my wishes. The fact has proved once more that prayers are not addressed in vain to those dear captives; and now I am happy to give them a strong mark of my gratitude.”
“May God be blessed! The dear souls in purgatory have lately obtained for me a spiritual grace which I ardently desired. I send you herewith twenty francs for a novena of masses in thanksgiving. Moreover I had promised to the abandoned souls a novena of masses if they came to my assistance in an affair which I thought desperate. I have been heard. I wish, therefore, to discharge my debt of gratitude, and thus I send you twenty francs, begging you to have thanksgiving masses said as soon as possible.”
“I send you herewith postal orders for fifty-six francs for the poor souls in purgatory in remembrance of favors obtained; also wishing to obtain their interest in a temporal affair very dear to my heart at this time.”
The most remarkable thing about these letters is that they all express the idea that the donors believed that they had received help from the forsaken souls in purgatory. One expresses himself that his prayers had not been “addressed in vain to those dear captives;” another speaks of them as coming to his assistance, and another speaks of “favors obtained,” and a desire still further to obtain their interest in a “temporal affair.” So abandoned souls in purgatory have, according to Catholic doctrine, power to help, even in temporal matters, those who still live on earth. This appears to be one reason why so much money is paid in, and shows that selfish desires have something to do with the contributions. The Scriptural doctrine that the “dead know not anything, . . . also their love, and their hatred, and their envy is now perished” (Eccl. 9: 5, 6), is a sure cure for all such follies. Prayers for and to the dead is one of the evil fruits that grow on the immortal-soul tree. When the tree is cut down, the fruit cannot appear. The “sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God,” cuts it down. Let the evil tree fall, and let Christ be exalted as the “resurrection and the life.” M. E. K.