THE “CHRISTIAN STATESMAN” VS. CARDINAL GIBBONS.
By H. F. Phelps
The Christian Statesman seems to be very much agitated over the recently published letter of Cardinal Gibbons. Why is it that the Christian Statesman and the cardinal do not agree in regard to the Sunday? They are both working for the same Sunday, only one would call it the “American Sabbath,” and would give it the ring and vigor of the Puritan, while the other would call it the “Christian Sunday,” and allow a portion of the day to be spent in recreation. The cardinal says:— “The Christian Sunday is not to be confounded with the Jewish or even the Puritan Sabbath. It prescribes a golden mean between rigid Sabbatarianism on the one hand and lax indulgence on the other. There is little doubt that the revulsions of public sentiment from a vigorous to a loose observance of the Lord’s day can be ascribed to the sincere, but misguided zeal of the Puritans, who confounded the Christian Sabbath, and imposed restraints on the people, which are repulsive to Christian freedom, and which were not warranted by the gospel dispensation. The Lord’s day to the Catholic heart is always a day of joy. The church desires us on that day to be cheerful, without dissipation; grave and serious, without sadness and melancholy. She forbids, indeed, all unnecessary servile work on that day; but she allows work whenever charity or a necessity shall demand it. And as it is a day dedicated not only to religion but to relaxation of mind and body, she permits us to spend a portion of it in innocent recreation.”
But to all this the Christian Statesman takes exceptions, and charges that “Cardinal Gibbons is inconsistent;” and says:— “As every one is aware, this is a critical hour in the Sabbath controversy. This will sufficiently account for the activity of the cardinal, and for the prominence given to his utterances by the Associated Press. It is the purpose of Cardinal Gibbons, of course, to get a favorable consideration for the ‘Sunday’ of his church by the American public, and if possible, get it introduced into this country as a substitute for what hitherto has been known as the American Sabbath.”
The Statesman still further criticises the cardinal because “he very curiously turns to the papal church, instead of to the living and unchangeable word of God, for instruction as to how the day should be sanctified.” But in this matter it must be confessed that the cardinal is consistent; for the papal church is the highest authority there is, either for the “Sunday” or the “American Sabbath;” for they are the same, and have their origin in the Catholic Church, which is admitted by all Catholic authorities. These both—the Catholic Church and the American Sabbath Unionists—know it, and have acknowledged in their public writings that there is no Bible authority for Sunday. The Christian Statesman further adds:— “His argument in this respect, however, is the same as the doctors of his church employ in all Catholic countries to enforce the observance of their saints’ days.”
Of course it is. And why not? They rest upon the same foundation; namely, the authority of the Catholic Church, and no other, for there is no other; and it would be more consistent for the Statesman to acknowledge the parentage of their “American Sabbath,” than to cry out against the only authority that can be produced for Sunday sacredness, call the day what you may. The American Sabbath Unionists once made a proposition to the Catholic Church through this same cardinal, for aid in securing a Sunday law; and he responded by saying:— “I am most happy to add my name to the millions of others who are laudably contending against the violation of the Christian Sabbath by unnecessary labor, and who are endeavoring to promote its decent and proper observance by judicious legislation.”
The courtship has been going on, and a union formed; but now differences arise. The one being possessed of the Puritan spirit, desires that Sunday observance shall be enforced with Puritanical severity, and calls for the preservation of the American Sabbath; while the other calls for the Catholic Sunday, and pleads conformity to the practices of the Catholic Church. But says the Christian Statesman:— “The rest day will be either a holy day or a holiday. You cannot make a hybrid out of it.”
But whether it came out of this contest as a holiday or a hybrid, it is not a holy day, and never will be, for it is surely a usurper—a supplanter of the Sabbath of the great God, and in all this we see but a fulfillment of the words so lately sent to us: “Prophecies are being fulfilled, and stormy times are before us. Old controversies which have apparently been hushed for a long time will be revived, and new controversies will spring up; the new and old will commingle, and this will take place right early.” At every turn of the wheel the situation becomes more complicated. One party cries out, “Great is the American Sabbath,” and are very jealous that it shall take the precedence; while the other would make prominent the Sunday of the Catholic Church. And this difference itself will but serve to hasten on the crisis. But thanks be to God, in the midst of all this, the true Sabbath shines out with a luster undimmed by time and untarnished by the smoke and dust arising from all these controversies, either old or new.