THE UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE IN THE UNITED STATES

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 17, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 41.

Read the full edition

THE UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE IN THE UNITED STATES.

It is one of the most significant facts with which we are acquainted, that the subject of the relations of the Church with the State is just at this time attracting such general attention, and is now being discussed in many of the leading religious papers in the United States. Upon our desk lay five religious papers, all of nearly the same date, each of which has a leading article upon this subject. But one of them takes a consistent position. The others, while disclaiming in smooth and honeyed words any desire to establish a State religion, lay down principles that will, if carried to their logical completion, as surely result in a national religion as two and two make four.
That these relations should be thus discussed in Europe, where many of the States are united to some form of Christianity, called the church, and where these relations are constantly being changed by wars, by public opinion, and other circumstances affecting the interests of these nations, is not surprising. But how does it happen that where the relations of the Church to the State were definitely and authoritatively settled, when the government was established more than 100 years ago, this subject should be again up for discussion through the length and breadth of our land? Were not the foundations rightly laid, when by the provision of the fundamental law, the Church was declared to be forever separate from the State? If the spectacle of a nation rising in 100 years to such a position of unexampled prosperity and national greatness, that the annals of history present nothing to be compared with it, affords a satisfactory answer to the above question, then we must conclude that the separation of the State from the Church in the United States of America, was a wise conception, which time has so fully justified, that any attempt to depart from it is little short of treason to the nation founded upon this understanding and exemplification of correct principles of government. Since this is undoubtedly true; since the United States Constitution settled the question, and settled it as the framers of that instrument supposed for all time for the people of the United States, what change has been wrought in the eternal principles of freedom of conscience from which this principle of the Constitution was drawn, or what change of sentiment has come over the thought and life of the people of the nation that will render it necessary to re-arrange the position of the Church and the State toward each other, or even to demand a further discussion of the subject? The answers to these questions are not difficult to find.
The principles of liberty upon which the Constitution rests, are the principles of truth, and are therefore immutable. Those who live here enjoy them; those in other countries have felt their influence, and have been benefited by them. The result has been to some countries toleration, to others, religious freedom. Under these favorable conditions, the churches of our land have prospered. Prevented by the Constitution from spending their energies in tearing each other down, the various churches of our land have devoted themselves to the better work of building themselves up. This they have accomplished in an eminent degree, if numbers and influence are a true criterion of prosperity.
But with this increase of numbers and prosperity there has also come into the popular churches of our land a spirit of pride, of popularity, and power, the latter not the power of God, but the power that ever accompanies popularity and pride,—the power of selfish desires working for personal and church aggrandizement, and the subjection of others to their wishes. They count with joy their increasing numbers, and proclaim that if once they were more firmly united, they could control the country. The reasons which have in the past prevented the formation of such a union, have largely passed away. The animosity which was once felt between rival churches, and which arose from intense religious convictions that certain things were true, and that those who held different opinions must therefore be in error, cannot exist where such intense convictions are not known; and the present time is remarkable for laxity upon such matters. Members of the various Protestant churches, if separated from those of their own particular church, have no scruples of joining any other Protestant body where their lot may be cast, thus saying by their actions that there is no vital difference between them. And as it was this well-known animosity of one church to another that contributed to the separation of the Church from the State, the passing away of this feeling, strange as it may appear, will inevitably lead, first, to a closer union of the various churches to each other, and secondly, to the union of these united churches to the State.
Not only is there a closer union of the Protestant churches with each other, but there is a growing feeling of friendship between the Protestants and the Catholics of this country. We do not mean personal friendship, but friendship for their doctrines, and a willingness on the part of Protestants to allow that the Catholic Church is a branch of the Christian church, and not what the fathers of the present Protestant churches declared her to be, “the scarlet lady,” and “Mystery, Babylon the great, the mother of harlots and abomination of the earth.” This friendship may be noticed in many acts of Protestants, in the general tone of the Protestant religious press, and particularly in the Religious Congress lately held in Chicago. There representative Protestantism and Catholicism embraced, and pointed out to their own satisfaction the lines of unity where they may work together.
As a sign of this feeling of unity that is becoming so marked in our day, we would call attention to the now very common habit indulged in by the religious press, of speaking of the various bodies of Christians of this country as the church. They declare that the church has power in this country; that the voice of the church should be heard; that the church can have whatever she is pleased to ask for; thus establishing in reality an American church, meaning Christianity in a general sense, as professed and practiced by these religious bodies.
And what is to hinder these churches in the progress of any work that they may unitedly agree upon? And if they should thus agree, and so obtain civil enactments from the law-making and executive power of the nation to carry out their purposes, would not this be a practical union of the Church with the State, just as much as though they were one church in name, and had entered into a formal compact, as has been done in other countries? A tacit union, or agreement, is often as strong as one that is openly and fully expressed. The churches of this country are forming such a compact, both with each other and with the government. They do not desire violently to trample the Constitution beneath their feet, but they propose to evade its meaning by declaring, as many now do, that the clause in the Constitution forbidding “an establishment of religion,” means any one sect of the Christian religion, and not the Christian religion as a whole. The Supreme Court has helped them in this direction, by declaring that this is a Christian nation, thus paving the way for churchly assumptions of special rights and powers of churches as a whole, to be continued in a further contest as to which individual church has the best historical and actual claim to be called the Christian church.
When it comes to this, the lesser lights of Protestantism must pale before the greater light of the Church of Rome. From a Bible standpoint, the Church of Rome is not the church of Christ. She is there foretold under the expressive titles of the “beast,” the woman on a “scarlet-colored beast,” “Mystery, Babylon the great, the mother of harlots,” the “mystery of iniquity;” and other titles of a similar nature, all showing her anti-Christian character. She has departed from every principle of Christianity, as laid down by Christ and his apostles. But while this is true of Rome from the position of truth and Scripture, historically she is the Christian church, and it will be perfectly useless for the Protestants to deny it. So that the very moment the Protestant churches acknowledge that she is not apostate, as they now seem inclined to do, they will, by that act, and by the very facts of her history, her priority to them, her continuance, her unity, and her power, be compelled to acknowledge her as the church, and thus the church established here would in reality be the Church of Rome. Rome would be the great luminary, and the other churches, whose members Rome once denominated heretics, but which she now calls separated brethren, would be the lesser lights, the satellites which will revolve around her, and all together will form, if not one church, one body, whose purposes and aims will be largely identical, and whose united influence will mold the life of the nation, as they shall determine. This fusion is rapidly taking place, and Rome, whose scheming Jesuits in disguise fill many high places in the so-called Protestant churches, knows it, and is preparing to gain all the advantages that long ages of ecclesiastical diplomacy have taught her how to secure.
This work now going on before our eyes, is in direct fulfilment of the prophecy of Revelation 13, which predicts the formation of something so near like the “beast” (Rome), that it is called an “image of the beast,” and whose object is to compel men to worship the beast itself. The sanctification of Sunday, which is now being so sedulously sought by all these organizations, which led to the passage of the World’s Fair Sunday-closing act, and which persistently seeks to give vigor and force to existing State and municipal laws for the same purpose, is the first united effort in which these churches have been engaged. While the greater part of this work is being done by Protestants, Sunday as a day of worship is entirely and peculiarly Catholic, and has no foundation in Scripture; so every effort made for the exaltation of that day is an act of worship and reverence to Rome; and judging by a series of articles lately appearing in the Catholic Mirror, to which reference has been made in the REVIEW, Rome is determined that Protestants shall know what power they are recognizing and worshiping, when men voluntarily, or because of legal enactments, rest upon that day.
When this unholy coalition now taking place has become solidified, and no voice is raised in objection to this badge of servility to Rome but by those whom God has called to proclaim the last warning message (see Rev. 14:9–12), then we may expect the storm to burst upon us in all its fury. Rev. 12:17. But he who has given into our hands the work of warning, will surely hold these forces of evil in check until the work of grace is done, and the servants of God are sealed in their foreheads. Revelation 7.
Let those who are now engaged in this work, thank God for the light they have received, and for the privileges of labor thus granted to them; and let those to whose attention these rapid fulfilments of prophecy have been more recently called, not neglect to receive and act upon the light given. Victory will surely come to those who hold up the banner of truth. A prophet’s vision has not only seen before the coming conflict, but has seen and foretold the certain victory. “And I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire: and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, and over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass, having the harps of God. And they sing the song of Moses the servant of God, and the song of the Lamb.” Rev. 15:2, 3.
Let us rejoice that the confederacy of evil now so rapidly forming, is preparing the way for a glorious victory, which shall be the crowning event of all the ages. M. E. K.