IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 28, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 47.

Read the full edition

IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD.

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Continued.)
Perhaps we could not do better at this point than to present, side by side, the two views of the nature of man and the consequences which grow out of them. First, it is maintained by those with whom we differ, that man was in the beginning endowed with two natures; i. e., the physical, which was mortal, and the spiritual, which was immortal, or deathless. By the advocates of this view it is argued that the soul at the death of the individual enters the spirit world, where it will exist forever in the condition in which it was when it left the body; i. e., if it had accepted Christ here, it will be saved there. If it rejected Christ here, it will be numbered among the eternally damned there.
Over against this doctrine is the one advocated in this article. According to it, all men were made mortal in the beginning, body and soul.
If Adam and Eve had proved faithful, they and their posterity would finally have been made immortal, and this earth in the Edenic condition would have been their eternal home. When they transgressed, they were shut away from the tree of life, and as a consequence died in process of time. Being mortal, their death was complete, covering both soul and body. Once in their graves, they would have remained there forever had it not been for the atonement of Christ, which secured a resurrection from the dead for all men.
The object of this resurrection was to give the race a second chance of obtaining, individually, eternal life through faith in Christ. Between death and the resurrection, the soul is in an unconscious condition. At the resurrection the righteous are rewarded with an unending existence of unmixed felicity. The wicked, on the other hand, come forth from their graves to be punished according to their deserts, and are then destroyed utterly, as unworthy of a place in the universe of God.
As to the comparative merits of these two theories from the reasonable point of view, but little more needs to be said here. It will not be disputed that it was possible for the Creator to make man mortal or immortal as he might adjudge best. The only question to be settled by him, therefore, was one of expediency. Now take the facts as they exist, and look at the question from the orthodox point of view: The world has stood for 6000 years, and up to this time eight tenths of the human family have gone straight to hell at death, while only two tenths, say, have gone to heaven.
The condition of both these classes is fixed for all eternity. The righteous are destined to become more holy and more happy through each succeeding age, while the lost are to become more wicked and more wretched as the cycles of eternity pass. Tell me, reader, whether under these circumstances it would not have been better had this world never been created. Can there be any doubt upon this point so long as it is true that eight out of ten of the human family are doomed to unmitigated torment while God shall live? The next question which I propound is this: Did God know beforehand what would be the outcome of his creative act? If he did not, he is not omniscient. If he did, he deliberately performed an act which is destined to perpetuate sin throughout eternity, and doom the great majority of the human species to unending misery. This conclusion is inevitable since there is no probation after death, and since, if the soul is immortal, God himself can never put an end to its misery by striking it out of existence.
Now look at the subject for a moment from the other side of the question. If man was made mortal instead of immortal, then God can destroy him at will. Suppose now that between death and the resurrection, the spirit of man is unconscious. Grant once more that the resurrection has occurred, and that eight tenths of the human family have been adjudged worthy of a place in the lake of fire, while two tenths are redeemed through the blood of Christ; remembering that by the theory of this article, sinners are to be punished according to their deserts and then destroyed, and you have a basis upon which to rest your calculations in your effort to determine whether the creation of this world was a blunder.
Now admit, if you please, that the wicked will remain in the lake of fire a certain length of time; say a day, a month, a year, or if you must have it so, a hundred years, then what? Why, when that hundred years is ended, sin and sinners will disappear forever, and the universe will be freed from everything in the form of rebellion against the rule of the Most High. But what about the saved? As already premised, they have been made immortal, and are basking in the sunlight of the divine favor and blessing.
How long is this condition of things to continue? I answer, Without end. This gives you but an imperfect conception of the duration of their bliss. Should I say that it is to be eternal, that would not help the matter much, because eternity is inconceivable. Well, suppose they should live a million of years in the enjoyment of the most perfect felicity; that would be a great length of time, would it not? Now suppose that you multiply that million of years as many times as there are grains of sand on the seashore. This done, you are no nearer the limit of the glorious existence of the finally saved than you were at the end of the first million of years, for the reason that infinity cannot be numbered. Now suppose, at the end of a billion of ages the question were to be asked whether the creation of our world had proved to be a success. What think you would be the answer which would burst from the lips of the redeemed? Would it not be in the form of a mighty halleluiah of praise to the Creator for having brought our earth into being, thus securing the unending felicity of so many myriads of the sons of men? While even then it might remain a source of regret that any had been so foolish as to reject eternal life, the fact that they had done so would not be considered worthy of mention in comparison with the infinite advantages which the creation of this planet insured to the faithful.
Thus it is made to appear that in case man was created mortal, to be clothed with immortality only when he demonstrated that he could safely be intrusted with such a gift, it is possible to vindicate the wisdom of God in the creation of our planet. Thus it is made to appear, also, that if man was made immortal in the outset, and as a consequence eight tenths of the human family devoted to endless torment, it would have been better that this world had never been created at all. Therefore, as the existence of this world is a fact which cannot be denied, and as God never blunders, the only safe and reasonable conclusion which one can adopt, is that when man was created, he was made subject to death, with the prospect of receiving immortality should he develop a character worthy of a permanent existence in the universe.
The only serious objection against the plan of creation suggested above, is found in the fact that it consigns the majority of our race to final oblivion. Admit, if you please, that this objection is not wholly without force, you must yet conclude that it presents no difficulty worthy of mention as compared with that which confronts you when the other view is accepted. Assuredly it is more reasonable to suppose that God might strike men out of being at once than it is to suppose that he should hold them in excruciating agony throughout eternity; for the latter course would involve several absurdities. First, it would represent the Creator as inflicting an infinite punishment for the sin of a finite creature; secondly, it would perpetuate sin to all eternity; thirdly, it would make God appear to be so vindictive in his character that he would punish unremittingly forever and ever the sinner, when there was no prospect that the latter could be reformed, and where the example of his punishment, instead of producing a favorable effect upon the balance of the universe, would produce the opposite result by encouraging the impression that God was a heartless monster, inflicting torment endlessly for the sole purpose of gratifying the malignity of his own nature.
These propositions cannot be controverted. They have suggested themselves to the mind of every thoughtful man. In the conflict between Christianity and infidels, the latter plant their heaviest batteries right on this position. Assuming that modern orthodoxy represents correctly the Bible theory upon this subject, they first show the utter indefensibility of the doctrine of everlasting punishment in the lake of fire; and then they thunder their denunciations at a system of religion which would uphold such a monstrous tenet. All know the result. Infidelity holds the field to-day in the estimation of the popular mind. The orthodox clergy, while still clinging to the terrible dogma of an endless hell, dare not preach it in their pulpits. The reaction against this doctrine has been so great that it is with trembling that the minister of our day ventures to use the word “hell” in his discourse, lest he should run against the popular prejudice. The result of all this is that the religion of Jesus is brought into contempt by being made responsible for a doctrine which it nowhere inculcates.
(To be continued.)