GATHERED THOUGHTS ON THE FIRST EPISTLE OF JOHN.
By August Kunz
To Accompany Sabbath-school Lesson for October 7. The “beloved disciple” aims in this epistle to confirm the Christian in his fellowship with the Saviour, into which he can come only by genuine repentance for sin, faith in the atoning sacrifice of Christ, and a strict obedience to his commandments. The things which John had recorded in the Gospel bearing his name, and which he had taught by word of mouth, are strengthened and brought home in this epistle, in order that the believer may come into the fullest possible enjoyment of the blessings and privileges that have been so richly provided for him in Christ. His heart is so full of everything divine and glorious which he has been permitted to see in Christ Jesus, that the current of his thoughts seems to leap even beyond his words. No date for the writing of this epistle is given. John simply narrates the truths of the Christian religion, with its consolations and reproofs, confidently and decidedly expecting that the children of God, enlightened by the Holy Spirit, will thereby gain the assurance that in Christ they have eternal life, purification, and victory, and withal, the full love of God. It is a remarkable fact that Paul’s utterances on justifying faith in Christ without the works of the law, and on our being crucified and risen with the Saviour, find no counterpart here at all; and yet John’s teachings fully coincide with those of Paul. Both teach that our entire salvation is the gift of God’s grace and mercy in Christ Jesus, and that it can be ours only by our believing in him and confessing him as our Saviour. Luther prefaces his comments on this epistle thus: “The first epistle of John is a candid, apostolic epistle, and ought really to follow immediately after his gospel. He meets those in his epistle who had boasted of their faith without works in the same breath in which he stimulates the faith of the believer, and in the style of his gospel. He teaches again and again, how works cannot be wanting where faith is. If, however, the works are absent, then is the faith not genuine, but deception and darkness. . . . Thus the epistle stands out against both divisions,—those who want a faith without works, and those who expect to be saved by their works. We are thus kept on the only sure middle way, that we must become free from sin and devoted to God, through faith; and when we thus have become children of light, we will abound in good works and love, without any compulsion whatever, simply for God’s sake.” Verse 1.—Christ is here called “the word of life.” As the pledged and truthful word of man bears the impress and reflection of his heart and soul within, so Christ, as the eternal Word, is the express image and reflection of God the Father. This relationship in its detail surpasses our finite understanding, by far, neither does the Scripture elucidate the same, but simply states the fact that the Word became flesh, in order by his death and resurrection to save all that believe and obey him. As we do not yet, by far, understand our own makeup, as to the exact relations between matter (our bodies) and spirit, or thought, and for all that, do not consider their acting in conjunction as an unreasonable thing, or impossible, it would be very inconsistent to reject these precious truths of God simply because we cannot understand them; it would be a most unreasonable thing to do; just as if a child should say to his parent, Father, I do not quite understand what you are doing, hence I do not think it is right. The fact that the Word became flesh proves the reality and oneness of the divinity and humanity of Christ, and refutes the teachings of Cerinthus and the Gnostics of John’s time, who taught that Christ came only in the semblance or appearance of a man. Verse 2.—Just as much as Christ’s incarnation is real, so also is the eternal life which he has won for us a reality; there is nothing impersonal or abstract about it. All nature teaches the same thing. As little as plant life is possible without plants, animal life without animals, or human life without real human beings, so we cannot have an eternal or godly life without having Christ and God; and if God wanted us to have eternal life, it was necessary for this life to come to us through his Son, as we had forfeited our claims, and none other was able to give it. Hence, forgiveness, justification, sanctification, eternal life, are not to be considered as a gift that can be separated from the living Christ, who is present with us and dwells in us through his word, but they can be found and maintained only in the living fellowship with him, as he, through the word, has taken his abode in us. Verse 3.—The verbal expression, “have seen and heard,” is in the perfect, which in the Greek expresses a condition, or state. Hence it is not something that was merely seen in the past, but something which still exists in the mind,—the recollection, before the eyes and ears of the inner man, so that physical and spiritual sight and hearing are evidently exercised thereby. This is accomplished through the Holy Spirit, who brings Christ, as the Word, or the glad tidings of salvation for man, into the heart. Thus the true proclamation of the word of Christ is a bringing of Christ, so that the Saviour, through the gospel, comes fully near to souls hearing the same. (Compare Rom. 10: 6–17; 1 John 2: 24, and other scriptures.) The word “fellowship” is used here in the sense of “partnership,” and means a great deal; for the hearers and doers of this message are to have an equal part, with the apostles, in Christ and the blessings of his salvation, and finally in his everlasting kingdom, so that they all are taken into partnership with God and with Christ. (Compare 2 Cor. 13: 13; Phil. 1: 11; 1 John 1: 6–8.) Thus true believers share by faith, through the Holy Spirit, the divine nature (2 Peter 1: 4), the life, love, light, righteousness, purity, and powers of God; hence they are enabled to have like aims and interests with God, so that they keep their thoughts directed upon the salvation of men, the coming kingdom, and the doing of the will of God on earth as it is done in heaven. Verse 4.—If believers grasp and practice the facts stated in verses 1–3, so that through the word they have fulness of grace, and share eternal life and the powers of a coming Saviour, their joy will indeed be full, notwithstanding all the conflicts and sufferings of this earth life. John 15: 11. This entire epistle aims to give the reader a deeper experience in the things of Christ, and in the life eternal which we have in him. To the believer it is the normal standard of the life and the fulness of the love of Christ. Verses 5, 6.—These and the following verses, up to chapter 2, verse 25, are primarily in refutation of certain false teachings that were in John’s time gaining a foothold with some, who claimed to have communion with God and the knowledge of Christ, but who at the same time committed open sins, and declared, moreover, that a truly enlightened Christian life could well be maintained, even though sin was indulged in. This entire section must therefore be read with this fact in mind, lest the true child of God may not draw that instruction and help from it which he otherwise would. God is light,—pure, glorious, and good,—or love itself. 1 John 4: 8–16. This truth neither nature nor reason can set forth any longer in its entirety as clearly as before the fall of man. Both announce to us indeed that there is a God, and even show forth his omnipotence and wisdom; but torn and rent as nature is, by so many elements of evil, it no longer lets the love of God shine through as clearly as it otherwise might. The sufferings, death, and resurrection of Christ, alone, reveal to us fully that God is light, love, and life. The fact that God is light, and that in him is no darkness at all, is also proof conclusive that sin and its cause did not originate with God, nor were created by him, nor could be through him (compare Rom. 5: 12; Genesis 3); but furthermore, that every one who lives and walks with God must be separate from sin and darkness. Whoever they be that make assertions, or do contrary to this, “lie, and do not the truth.” (Compare 1 John 2: 4, 6, 11; 3: 6.) These texts strike against a continued state or condition of life in known sin, rather than merely against any one rash act of sin that is at once repented of, and for which cleansing and pardon is found in Christ, who can also keep us from sinning in that way again. Chapter 2: 1. “Truth,” in the Scriptures, signifies not only correct doctrine, or a mere agreement of reports with facts, but also a state or condition of purity, in which we walk according to what God has marked out for us. (Compare John 1: 14 with Rom. 1: 18.) To “do” the truth, means, then, to be and abide in the proper Christian condition, to follow Christ properly. To “lie” is not only to tell falsehoods, intentionally and knowingly; but those who are involved in strong error and sin, being bound thereby, and who commend the same as truth to others, are called “liars.” Verse 7.—Here the condition of every true child of God is set forth as one who does not walk in the darkness of known sins, but who walks by virtue of the blood of Christ, through confidence in, and obedience to, him. This is not necessarily restricted to a walk in perfect holiness, as it will be in heaven; nor even to the last and highest degree of cleansing and purity which some have reached and maintained in this life. We walk in the light when we strive earnestly and perseveringly every day toward this goal, and make good progress from day to day, toward it. The wavering and undecided, however, find no encouragement whatever here. On the other hand, Christians who are in the light of the salvation through Christ, and faithfully follow the heavenly guide, in confidence and obedience, will also have fellowship one with another; they will be partakers of the heavenly gifts and callings in Christ Jesus, and will share with each other their spiritual experiences, answers to prayer, instructions, admonitions, comfort, encouragement, etc., etc. But where Christians still continue in selfishness, legality, the admiration of men, vainglory, self-will, frivolity, jesting, the fetters of sense, slothfulness, neglecting to search for the Biblical truths of salvation,—there true Christian fellowship cannot prosper, and prayer and social meetings have no charm for such. But the very first fruits of walking in the light, as pointed out to us here, is fellowship one with another. Hence brotherly love and fellowship come even before a deeper work of grace in the heart may be fully under way. “The blood of Jesus Christ . . . cleanseth us from all sin.” The verb being in the present tense, implies a constant cleansing every day,—yea, every moment,—and cannot be either past or future. But a continual cleansing with regard to past sin brings the power of the blood to view, which causes these sins to remain forgiven, and we are kept clean and pure. (Compare Rom. 6: 1–14.) The words are therefore not confined to mean the justification, conversion, or “regeneration” of the believer, but show how the forgiveness of, and justification from, sin, as experienced at conversion, continues. At conversion the soul is “washed, . . . sanctified, . . . justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God.” 1 Cor. 6: 11. The believer is made over into the image of Christ by the Holy Spirit, and has thus in Christ, but by no means in himself without Christ, forgiveness and purification. Yet in and of himself the Christian is guilty, impure, and prone to sin; for, as verse 8 clearly states, we have still sin; that is, we are still in a house of flesh; sin or the power to sin is still there, although we need not and must not yield to its promptings or inclinations. Only as a member in Christ, the head,—as a branch on the vine, but never in himself,—is the believer without guilt, or kept pure. Of himself, without the forgiving and cleansing power of the blood and Spirit of Christ, every Christian is guilty, unclean, incapable to do that which is spiritually good. (Compare John. 15: 6; Rom. 8: 1.) Forgiveness, too, is only effective as long as we walk and abide in Christ. (Compare Matt. 18: 23–35.) Out of Christ we are ever under sin, and both sin and Satan have power to control us. The hand or the foot, without connection with the body through which the life and health-diffusing blood flows, must decay and perish; but connected with the body, as long as its blood is healthy and pure, they, too, will be preserved, healthy, pure, and strong. Thus the Christian’s innocence and purity are utterly and altogether dependent on Christ, the saving head. As long as we continue to walk in the light, so long does the blood of Christ cleanse and preserve us from all sin. Verse 8.—We must distinguish between “having sin,” and “doing sin,” or “sinning.” (Compare chapter 2: 1, 3, 4, 6; 3: 6–9.) Every believer on earth has sin dwelling in his members, but walking in the light enables him to keep the body under. Unavoidable defects of nature, and mistakes committed by good intentions, are not to be classed under this head, either; nor are thoughts and suggestions which the evil one may put into our minds, to tempt us, to be considered sin. Paraphrased, verses 7 and 8 read thus: Whoever says, I have no need of the blood of Jesus to keep me clean and pure; for I have no longer a sinful nature, inasmuch as the blood of Christ makes me free from its guilt and power, and keeps me clean! But such ones can only deceive themselves most fatally with any assertions like that, and they are without the truth which alone makes free. Verse 9.—The sinful nature which man has as long as he is in the flesh and without Christ, ever makes sinning easy, at any time he chooses to indulge in sin, or does not watch in earnest prayer, to keep from it. There is a sinning from weakness, and there is a wilful sinning from the love of it. The former the believer may fall into, but will at once seek forgiveness for it, and ask for God’s cleansing and keeping power, so as to sin no more. Wilful sins are those of the apostate and reprobate, as a rule, who are “fallen from grace,” and let the old man rule again; or of the unconverted, who have never known the blessedness of sins forgiven and a pure heart through Christ. We must, as believers, whenever we fall into any sin, not only confess the same before God and ask his pardon for it, but we must also pray that he may cleanse us from the root of that sin, and seek to find out why it was stronger than we. For if the internal wound of sin remains as a constitutional evil, we may heal the outward, local sore, but will for all that in time fall into the same old trouble again, in spite even of the very best and stoutest resolutions. These sins of weakness come like boils, from impure blood; or, plainly stated, because we do not hearken to the voice of Jesus, and walk, led by his hand. And only when we can have faith and confidence, after having committed sins of weakness, and when the Lord has now brought us into the proper position of faith, and healed us internally, so that we will not commit that sin again,—only then can we really rejoice in his forgiveness. Hence in our relation to God, the confidence that the blood of Christ has power to purify us from all sin is indispensably necessary for a joyous assurance of the forgiveness of our sins, and the continuance of God’s grace to usward. Verse 10.—Paraphrased, this verse reads: If after a committed sin, or in a state of bondage to sin, about which God’s Spirit reproves us through the conscience, we stand out against the word and the Spirit of God, and say, “We have not sinned,” or “That was no sin,”—we thereby make God who reproves us, a liar, and the word which is quickened by the Spirit of God, does not bear rule in us. But if a Christian should suppose that now he has reached a degree of holiness that leaves him so pure that sin could no longer proceed out of his heart, or even that it is his duty now evermore to believe that he is wholly clean, even though he should notice the opposite in himself, his soul is in imminent danger. John evidently takes the position that all sanctified Christians, himself along with the rest, may come where they will have sins to confess.