RIGHT AND WRONG

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 21, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 46.

Read the full edition

RIGHT AND WRONG.

A WRITER in the Canadian Baptist, giving his reasons for observing Sunday instead of the Sabbath, lays down the following as his first proposition:—
“The moral law promulgated from Mount Sinai (Ex. 20: 8, 9) enjoins upon us the sanctification of one-seventh part of our weekly lifetime to divine service. Observe in this passage and in others where the command is repeated, how carefully the particular day is not specified. The substantial meaning of this injunction, is that at the completion of every six days’ secular work, one entire day of holy rest should be observed.”
The law certainly demands one-seventh part of our time to be devoted to divine service; because it demands that the seventh day be so devoted, and the seventh day is one seventh of all the time there is. But the writer really holds that the law demanded only one indefinite seventh of the time, without reference to any particular seventh, or definite day, a claim for which there is no proof. He declares that “the particular day is not specified!” As well might a boy claim that his father, who told him to do a piece of work on Saturday, did not specify the particular day when the work was to be done! To the people who stood at the base of the burning mountain, and listened to the words of the law, the term “the seventh day,” meant the last day of the week, and nothing else, as truly as the word “Saturday” has that meaning to us. The Jewish people had no other than numerical names for the days of the week. The day was specified just as clearly as it was possible for it to be done in the language in which it was spoken and written.
Again: the “substantial meaning” of the fourth commandment is simply that, “at the completion of every six days’ secular work, one entire day of holy rest should be observed.”
If this statement about the Sabbath is true now, it was also true when the law was proclaimed. Hence, according to the writer’s position, if one of the children of Israel had refused to observe the last day of the week, and had chosen instead the day that is now observed by the Christian world as the Sabbath, he would have complied with the “substantial meaning” of the fourth commandment. Can any one believe this to be true? Imagine a man arraigned for Sabbath-breaking before the wise Solomon, trying to excuse himself on the ground that he had kept another day, and had, therefore, fulfilled the “substantial meaning” of the Sabbath commandment! He could certainly do it with as much show of reason as men can do so now.
But the criticisms we have made upon the author’s position as stated above, are almost unnecessary; for the writer himself, in the very next sentence, gives himself away in the following words:—
“There are very good reasons which I have neither time nor space to give now, for believing that the Jewish Sabbath—I mean the particular day of the week—was not the Edenic and patriarchal Sabbath, but the day following.”
So the Sabbath, which he is pleased to call the Jewish Sabbath, the only Sabbath that can claim any divine authority for its observance, is a “particular day of the week,” after all! But how could it be a “particular day of the week” unless it was specified? which he before declared was not done!
The writer devotes the portion of his article which we have not quoted in attempting to prove that the seventh day of the week cannot be kept at the same absolute time all over the earth, acknowledges that Sunday-keeping is open to the same objection, and then asks the following strange question: “Who is to keep the wrong day, if the seventh day be the right one?” He answers this question by declaring that every one should keep Sunday! We cannot understand why he asks such a curiously-worded question, nor can we see any reason or logic in his answer. If we were going to answer the question, we would first transpose it, to make it a little clearer. Then it would read thus: “If the seventh day be the right one (to keep), who is to keep the wrong day?” We should unhesitatingly reply, “Those who want to do wrong.” There is no other way to answer the question.
We will, with a slight change, ask the question once more, and by so doing get at both sides of the subject, “If the seventh day be the right one (to keep), who is to keep the right day?” Again we answer, “Those who want to do right.” The question cannot be answered any other way. We would ask our friend of the Canadian Baptist to ponder these questions and the answers, and to decide not to do wrong by keeping the wrong day, but to do right by keeping the right day.
M. E. K.