IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 31, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 43.

Read the full edition

IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD.

Rational and Scriptural Arguments

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Continued.)
GENUINE science and philosophy go hand in hand. What the first condemns the latter must surrender. For thousands of years the discussion over the nature of the soul has been going on. When science was in its infancy, it was believed by some that its teachings harmonized with the doctrine that the soul is naturally immortal. Now that science is more fully developed, it must be admitted that, with each recurring year, its teachings are undermining more and more fully the faith of scholars in the dogma that there is any part of the natural man which survives the grave. When such scientists as Huxley, Tyndall, and Draper, unhesitatingly express their conviction that science assuredly inculcates the doctrine that all there is of man expires in death, it is idle for smaller lights to argue that the teachings of science are unmistakably on the side of a future life. The simple fact is, that if the Bible were to be taken out of the controversy, the battle would quickly be decided in favor of those who hold that science recognizes no hereafter for the race.
Many good men have an inkling of this fact, and are greatly alarmed. Let them dispel their fears, however; for on this point the triumph of science will prove to be the triumph of the Scriptures also. The God of nature and the God of the Bible are one and the same. When, therefore, we read in the latter that the dead “know not anything” (Eccl. 9: 5), and that when man “returneth to his earth; . . . his thoughts perish” (Ps. 146: 3, 4), why should it be esteemed a marvel that the same sentiment should be found written upon the tablets of the brain, and confirmed by the science of biology, or life?
It is not the Bible which is in conflict with science upon this point. Take it as it reads, and its testimony is clear and explicit on the state of man in death, and agrees perfectly with the conclusion reached by many of the greatest scholars of the age on this subject. The whole trouble springs out of the fact that when the Bible says emphatically, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die” (Ezek. 18: 4), modern theologians deny the proposition flatly, declaring that the soul of the sinner cannot possibly die, since it was made immortal. Having shown that the faith of men in a future endless life of the soul is not sufficiently strong and well defined to be regarded as intuitional, it is enough to say, in concluding upon this point, that its existence can be accounted for satisfactorily without having recourse to anything of an intuitional character.
After the fall, the fundamental principles of the gospel were outlined to our first parents. Among other things, the doctrines of the resurrection and future life through Christ were communicated to Adam and Eve. These great truths were transmitted by them to their posterity. In process of time, these tenets, like nearly everything which is handed down by tradition, were perverted, until at length a variety of theories sprang up on this subject; and some, through ignorance, and others through a desire that it should be so, taught the future existence of all souls throughout the eternal age. It is, therefore, to distorted and unreliable tradition, and not to either right reason, or the Scriptures, that modern theologians are indebted for the tenet that in the matter of an endless life man is equal to the Deity.
Another line of argument which is thought to favor the natural immortality of the soul, is founded upon certain supposed analogies of nature. Among them is the familiar one of the butterfly. It is well known that the caterpillar surrounds himself with a cocoon for a number of weeks, and then emerges from that condition transmuted into a butterfly. Strangely enough, grave doctors of divinity see in this natural phenomenon a striking proof that the human family are destined to pass into another state of being, where they will live forever. Unfortunately, they do not tell us just when and where we, like the caterpillar, will go into the cocoon state, or just how or when we shall be able to crack the chrysalis, and expand our gold-bespangled wings for the first flight in our experience. Perhaps they do not consider these trifling details worthy of notice; but really, if the analogy is of any value whatever, it certainly should hold good in the particulars just mentioned.
But all these things aside, let us get at the gist of the matter at once. In what way does the transmutation of a caterpillar into a butterfly, elucidate or prove the deathless nature of the human soul? When the caterpillar is changed into the butterfly, has he passed from a mortal into an immortal state? If so, the illustration is apropos to the case in hand; if not, then it has no force whatever in this discussion. Every school-boy knows that the butterfly is a fragile and short-lived creature. It flits before us for a few days, a thing of beauty and grace, then dies and is seen no more. To reason that in its brief career, terminating in utter extinction, can be found a demonstration of the fact that all men are destined to live forever, is too puerile to be worthy the abilities of the learned clergymen who use it so largely in their argumentations on the soul question. Indeed, the same butterfly which is so often used by these gentlemen to prove the immortality of the soul, is more frequently employed by them to illustrate the ephemeral nature of the beautiful and graceful in this life. In such a use of the delicate creature under discussion, they are fully justified; for if its life teaches anything, it is that the most exquisitely ornamented in nature must die, and therefore that things less favored in this direction assuredly will share the same fate, man not excepted.
Another similitude of nature, in which some have fancied that they have discovered a prophecy of the future life, is the rising and setting of the planets. Late in the evening, Jupiter or Saturn or Mars disappears in the west, regretted by some one who loves to look upon the shining orbs of the sky. Twenty-four hours elapse, and lo! the favorite planet reappears, burning as brightly as ever before in the diadem of the night. “There,” says the more than gratified beholder, “there, is a promise of the life to come. The soul may enter the shadows of death for a time, and be obscured as was that planet; but, like the latter, it will reappear at last, shining more brilliantly than ever before.” Such, I say, have been the reflections of many a one who was groping for testimony that would favor an existence beyond the grave. His ambition for a future life was both natural and commendable, and his failure to find proof of it in the direction where it was sought, is to be pitied rather than censured. His idea was a poetic one, but when you have said that, you can say nothing more in its favor. It proves literally nothing either for or against the doctrine of a hereafter.
The earth revolves upon its axis from west to east. The spectator loses sight of a planet at one time, and discovers it at another time, simply because the revolving earth on which he stands, bears him rapidly forward, until his favorite planet disappears at one time and reappears at another time. Practically speaking, Jupiter or Saturn or Mars, as the case may be, neither rises nor sets at all. Furthermore, they were shining just as brightly in the sky when not seen as they were when seen. It was not because the planets were dimmed that they were invisible, but simply because something had come between the beholder and them. There is therefore no analogy between them and the soul in death. So far as observation can go, when man enters the tomb, the spark of his intellect is utterly extinguished, whereas the planet, as heretofore suggested, has undergone no change whatever.
(To be continued.)