Prohibition Advances

4%

Review and Herald Publishing Association · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Feb 22, 1917

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 94, No. 8.

Read the full edition

Prohibition Advances

THE advocates of the legalized liquor traffic continue to lose ground in both the United States and England.

United States

On January 8 the Supreme Court of the United States handed down a decision that the Webb-Kenyon law is Constitutional. This law was passed near the close of the Presidential term of William H. Taft, and had as its purpose the stopping of the shipment of liquor from wet States into dry States under the protection of interstate laws. President Taft vetoed the bill as unconstitutional. Congress immediately passed the law over the Presidential veto, and now the Supreme Court has ruled that the law is Constitutional.
On January 9 the Senate of the United States, by a vote of fifty-five to thirty-two, passed a bill to make the District of Columbia dry. And on January 11 the same body passed by a substantial majority a bill excluding liquor advertising from mails in dry territory. These two bills must pass the House before they become law; but it is generally conceded that they will pass, if they come up to a vote.
A new phrase in the prohibition campaign is now showing itself in the United States. The Prohibitionist latest slogan is “bone dry.” Concerning this phrase the Washington Star of February 5, says:—
“This is the latest prohibition cry; and it is very expressive. States have gone, or are going, ‘bone dry.’ No halfway enactments, or halfway or half-hearted executions of enactments, but the real thing. When ‘dry’ is ordered, ‘bone dry’ it is, or will be.”
“Reports of the past few days have shown great and significant gains for the cause. They cover a wide sweep. Oregon has gone ‘bone dry.’ Tennessee will go ‘bone dry’ March 1. The governor has signed the bill, and will enforce the law. Alaska will be ‘bone dry’ by act of Congress. The Senate bill passed the House without a roll call. Indiana will be ‘bone dry’ in April of next year. The bill passed both houses of the legislature by large majorities.”
“Oregon, Indiana, and Tennessee are solid and progressive States, inhabited by people who are alert and up to date. Alaska is a rich territory, just ‘coming out of the woods,’ and Congress is showing a disposition to help her in every way in her development. . . .”
“Well, whether one believes in prohibition or not, all should welcome this ‘bone dry’ aspect of the contest. Let it be understood what is in the balance, and what a victory will mean. If prohibition on a nation-wide scale is to be tried, let it be tried in the open, so to say, and for all it is worth. The way to prohibit is to prohibit.”
And with the Constitutionality of the Webb-Kenyon law assured, it should now be easy for a State desiring to be “bone dry” actually to be so.

England

Public opinion in England is rapidly drifting toward prohibition. “A whirlwind of sobriety, in theory if not in fact, has swept over Britain, and almost every newspaper, in both its editorial and advertising columns, is advocating ‘prohibition for the period of the war’ or the immediate state purchase of the liquor trade. Shortage of food seems to have influenced the situation, and many journals of prominence have published spirited protests against the conversion of badly needed grain into intoxicants.”
The London Spectator, in reviewing the English situation, prints the following paragraph at the head of its columns:—
“The shortage of food remains the question of the hour. ‘We are a beleaguered city.’ Yet we continue to turn foodstuffs into intoxicants. Does such a state of things satisfy the nation? It certainly does not satisfy us.”
It then proceeds to outline its policy. We quote only a short extract:—
“The liquor problem has developed with extraordinary rapidity in the last three weeks, and is now, we believe, ripe for solution. If it is solved now, the nation will greatly benefit, both in war and in peace. If, owing to want of courage and consistency in our leading politicians, it is not solved, the prosecution of the war must be seriously delayed, and we may be placed in a position of danger from which our statesmen could and ought to have preserved us. Moreover, we shall be forced to face the future bowed down with a heritage of trouble from the past.”
“The Spectator policy provides, we believe, the best method of solving the problem. It is a winning policy and a just policy. It can be stated, like most things that are worth anything, in a very few words:—
“(1) Prohibition for the war; (2) the elimination of private profit from the manufacture and sale of intoxicants after the war.”
“The instrument for obtaining what we desire is, in both cases, state purchase on just terms.”
The London Times clearly states its belief that prohibition is inevitable:—
“The liquor traffic is one of those domestic concerns which have been profoundly affected by the war; and, like others, it will be still further affected as the pressure increases. Those who are interested in it will do well to recognize the signs and be prepared to accept the inevitable. It touches the conduct of the war in two respects: one is the food supply, and the other the efficiency of our war industries. Both are of such supreme importance that no regard for sectional interests can be allowed to stand in the way of any measures which may be called for to strengthen the national effort.”
While the Times favors state purchase and not prohibition, some papers declare themselves openly for prohibition, and state their opinion that the people are ready for this step. The London Daily News is among these:—
“What we have not, and to our national shame seem incapable of acquiring, is the resolution to decree that the prohibition of the consumption of alcohol for the period of the war shall be absolute and universal. There have been times when such a step would have provoked a storm of opposition. Today we believe it would be greeted with whole-hearted approval by the solid mass of the population.”
It is surely a subject worthy of earnest effort that out of the present world calamity some blessing should come to the people, and that not merely for the time of the war, but for the subsequent time of peace toward which all hopes turn. If the nations of the world can free themselves from the throttle grasp which alcohol has upon their manhood, they possibly can cope with the stupendous debts which the present war is fastening upon them. Otherwise the struggle would seem hopeless.
L. L. C.