AdventAI

AUTHORITY FOR SUNDAY, OLD AND NEW.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 49., December 12, 1893

When we look at the evidences, so-called, that are adduced from the Scriptures for the support of that venerable heathen institution, so early ingrafted upon the Christian church,—the Sunday Sabbath, we are often led to wonder that men, who upon other subjects appear to be able to reason with considerable clearness, upon this topic are so blinded by custom and sophistry that they cannot see the plainest proofs against their position; and on the other hand they think they see evidences of apostolic Sunday-keeping in passages where nothing but their extreme desire to have it so would ever lead them to rest upon such flimsy supports. In order that we may show what we mean by this, we would examine some of the reasons that were used by the early church to justify their departure from the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and their adoption of Sunday in its place. When we say “early church” in this connection, we do not mean apostolic church. We mean the church in the days of Constantine and Eusebius. But first we will refer to Justin Martyr, whose “Apology” was directed to the Roman emperor Antoninus Pius. In this apology the first reason given for Sunday-keeping is “that on this day of the week the world and light were created.”—Chamber’s Encyclopedia, Vol. XII., p. 859.

The reason now so generally given, that Christp. 781 rose from the dead that day, is referred to as a secondary reason. So the same fact used by God himself when he gave the Sabbath law as the reason why men should work on the first day, is used by this early father as proof that they should rest! This shows the difference between the mind of God and the mind of a man.

But it was to the Scriptures used by these early fathers that we wished especially to refer. We quote again from the same book and page as before: “There now began to be discovered in the Old Testament, foreshadowings of the new Sunday Sabbath; and Eusebius, bishop of Cæsarea, the friend and biographer of Constantine, was able to descry, in Ps. 46: 5 and 59: 16, prophetic allusions to the morning assemblies of Christians on Sundays for worship; and in Ps. 22: 29, a prefiguration of the weekly celebration of the Lord’s Supper on that day.” We will now quote Ps. 46: 5. Remember that this was one of the texts that was used in the early church to countenance and sustain their observance of Sunday, for which at this time they began to feel the need of some Scriptural evidence: “God is in the midst of her; she shall not be moved: God shall help her, and that right early.” If the reader should ask in surprise what this has to do with the keeping of Sunday, he will ask a question that we cannot answer; but we can refer him to Eusebius, bishop of Cæsarea and friend of Constantine. He was just as confident that this was a prophecy of Sunday-keeping as modern theologians are that John 20: 19, 26 is a proof that Sunday was actually kept. And he certainly has just as good a reason for his opinion as the later theologian has. Did not the Christians in Eusebius’s time have a habit of meeting early every Sunday morning? and does not the text referring to the church say, “God shall help her, and that right early”? What could be clearer than that this meant early Sunday morning! That is the way the bishop reasoned; that was the evidence he rested upon to sustain their observance of Sunday.

The other text which he used is equally clear: “But I will sing of thy power; yea, I will sing aloud of thy mercy in the morning: for thou hast been my defense and refuge in the day of my trouble.” Ps. 59: 16. This text was thought by the learned bishop to corroborate the other. The earliest observance of Sunday was an early morning meeting, commenced by singing a hymn to Christ. After this meeting, which could have occupied but a short time, they resumed their usual occupations. But since they did meet in the morning and sing, the bishop regarded it as a fulfilment of the text above quoted. Then they were also in the habit of celebrating the Lord’s Supper at these meetings, and this they believed was predicted in Ps. 22: 29, which reads thus: “All they that be fat upon earth shall eat and worship,” etc.

Upon such texts as these the fabric of Sunday-keeping was first sustained. The minister who would quote them now for that purpose, would be set down by thinking people as a lunatic; but we are not afraid to affirm that as far as any real evidence is concerned, they are as good texts to prove the observance of Sunday by as there are in the Bible. And this bishop, the friend and flatterer of the heathen emperor Constantine, who was the author of the first Sunday law,—this bishop declared, “All things whatsoever that it was duty to do on the Sabbath, these we have transferred to the Lord’s day.”—“History of the Sabbath,” p. 360. And this usurped authority over the law of God was sustained by such interpretations of Scripture as we have noticed!

The Scriptures now used for the same purpose are no clearer than those used at that time; and the reasoning of Eusebius on the psalms and that of modern theologians on texts usually referred to now to sustain Sunday-keeping, have a very striking similarity, in that imagination clothes these Scripture texts with a meaning entirely outside of that which the natural and reasonable construction of the language would warrant.

The true Sabbath needs not to be supported by any such doubtful disputations. To sustain it, we do not have to depend upon ambiguous scriptures, or infer things where some one else can just as reasonably infer something else. The sanctification of the Sabbath at creation, its solemn rendition by God himself at Sinai, its position of eminence in the bosom of the great moral code, the honor rendered to it by Christ and his apostles,—all speak one plain, unmistakable language as to its origin, holiness, position, and perpetuity. It is still the “Sabbath of the Lord,” with the uniform testimony of the Scriptures for its support. We can truly say that the command, “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy,” is binding to this day, and that in no possible way can it be used to enforce any other day than the day specified in the commandment. M. E. K.