INNOCENT WOMEN SHAMEFULLY TREATED

5%

Review and Herald Publishing Association · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Aug 9, 1917

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 94, No. 32.

Read the full edition

INNOCENT WOMEN SHAMEFULLY TREATED

It must be remembered that the Puritans differed from men of our own day only in training and environment. They were naturally no more hard-hearted than are those who read these words, nor than he who writes them. But the theocratic theory of government and the mistaken sense of duty made them cruel in their acts, even though kind at heart.
According to the Puritan understanding of the Scriptures, they were under solemn obligation to repress heresy and to punish by civil pains and penalties departures from the paths of right and rectitude. As they viewed it, the peculiar doctrines of the Quakers were not only evil spiritually, but socially most mischievous, and civilly dangerous and even destructive. Their charter bound them to be governed by only such “orders, laws, ordinances, instructions, and directions aforesaid, not being repugnant to the laws and statutes of our realm of England;” and further enjoined them, “for their special defense and safety, to encounter, expulse, repel, and resist by force of arms, as well by sea as by land, and by all fitting ways and means whatsoever, all such person and persons as shall at any time hereafter attempt or enterprise the destruction, invasion, detriment, or annoyance to the said plantation or inhabitants; and to take and surprise by all ways and means whatsoever, all and every such person and persons,” etc.
Letters from their friends in England had apprised them of the coming to America of two Quaker women, mentioned in our last article, namely, Ann Austin and Mary Fisher, and they felt that fidelity to the truth of the Scriptures and loyalty to their liege lord, the king of England, united in demanding that they deal promptly and sternly with these unwelcome visitors; and this they did.
In the imagination of the Puritans these defenseless and really inoffensive women were, as Mr. Hallowell puts it, “two desperate and warlike amazons.” “To be sure,” he continues, “the Quaker books they brought with them gave the lie to the letters from England, but what need to read them? One of the dreadful women had said ‘thee’ to the deputy governor, and her arrest prior to this declaration of war was thus amply justified.” — The Quaker Invasion of New England, pp. 39, 40.
John Endicott, the governor, wrote from Salem saying that had he been at home he would have had these women whipped, but as Hallowell remarks, “an ordeal far more terrible than scourging awaited them. By official order these two defenseless women were literally stripped of their clothing, and their bodies were examined for witch marks in a manner too indecent to be named.”
A president of the Massachusetts Historical Society said some years since that the advent of the Quakers in that State began in “comedy,” but it was rather tragedy.
“A few days after the enforced departure of Ann Austin and Mary Fisher, another vessel anchored in the harbor with nine Quakers aboard. They were immediately arrested and were imprisoned for about eleven weeks, when they were sent away in the ship that brought them, the master of the ship having been compelled by an arbitrary imprisonment to give security to take them to England at his own charge.
. . . During their confinement, Governor Endicott bullied them with threats of hanging. ‘Take heed,’ he said to them, ‘ye break not our ecclesiastical laws, for then ye are sure to stretch by a halter.’ . . .
“The next act in this tragedy of errors was performed while these nine Quakers were still in gaol, but before any others had arrived, and before any of the residents had avowed the Quaker name and faith. On the fourteenth day of October, 1656, the General Court enacted the first of a series of disgraceful laws, aimed exclusively at the Quakers. It begins, ‘Whereas there is a cursed sect of heretics lately risen up in the world, which are commonly called Quakers.’ . . .
“This formal declaration of war against the Quakers was proclaimed in the streets of Boston by beat of drum. Nicholas Upsall . . . was proprietor of the Red Lyon Inn, and hearing the act read before his own door, said ‘that he did look at it as a sad forerunner of some heavy judgment to fall on the country.’”—Id., pp. 42-48.
“They summoned Upsall before the court the next morning,” says Hallowell, “where he, ‘in much tenderness and love,’ warned them ‘to take heed lest ye should be found fighters against God.’ He was fined twenty pounds, Endicott saying, ‘I will not bate him one groat, [a former English silver coin worth about eight cents].’ He was then banished, with orders to depart in thirty days, four of which he spent in gaol; and before leaving, he was fined three pounds more for not going to church.”
“On the fourteenth of October, 1657, a second law was enacted. . . . It provided for the forfeiture of one hundred pounds by any one who knowingly brought a Quaker into the jurisdiction, and imposed a fine of forty shillings for every hour’s entertainment of a Quaker by any resident. It further ordered that any Quaker man presuming to come into the jurisdiction after having once suffered what the law requireth, ‘shall for the first offense have one of his ears cut off, . . . and for the second offense shall have his other ear cut off, . . . and every woman Quaker that hath suffered the law here, that shall presume to come into this jurisdiction, shall be severely whipped. . . . and so also for her coming again she shall be alike used as aforesaid; and for every Quaker, he or she, that shall a third time herein again offend, they shall have their tongues bored through with a hot iron. . . . And it is further ordered that all and every Quaker arising from amongst ourselves shall be dealt with and suffer the like punishment as the law provides against foreign Quakers.’”
“On the nineteenth of May, 1658, for a third time the General Court issued its decree against the Friends, forbidding under severe penalties, the holding of meetings or attendance at meetings. . . .
“On the nineteenth of October, 1658, the court enacted the fourth law, in which they incorporated Endicott’s threat, ‘Take heed ye break not our ecclesiastical laws, for then ye are sure to stretch by the halter.’ . . . It is followed by an order banishing both visiting and resident Quakers upon pain of death if they return. . . .
“On May 11, 1659, by a special order, the county treasurers were authorized to sell Daniel and Provided Southwicks, son and daughter, to Lawrence Southwicke, to any of the English nation at Virginia or Barbados, to satisfy the fines imposed upon them ‘for siding with the Quakers and absenting themselves from the public ordinances.’ . . .
“Innocent women were stripped to the waist, and thus exposed to public gaze, were beaten with stripes until the blood ran down their bare backs and bosoms; the ears of men were cut off, and the bodies of men were beaten to a jelly, for attending Quaker meetings and for testifying against ‘your bloody and cruel laws.’ . . .
“Edmund Batter hunted in vain for a shipmaster mean enough to sail freighted with human victims for a Virginia market. One captain, being approached, ‘to try Batter, said that they would spoil all the vessel’s company,’ whereupon he replied, with a testimony to the inoffensive character of the Quakers, rarely extorted from Puritan lips. He said to the ship captain, ‘Oh, you need not fear that, for they’re poor harmless creatures, and will not hurt anybody.’ ‘Will they not so?’ said the ship master, ‘and will ye offer to make slaves of so harmless creatures?’ Whittier has immortalized this scene by rendering the captain’s answer in the following lines:
“Pile my ship with bars of silver,— pack with coins of Spanish gold, From keel piece up to deck plank, the roomage of her hold, By the living God who made me! — I would sooner in your bay Sink ship and crew and cargo than bear this child away!” — Id., pp. 48-53.
How the death penalty was later invoked and actually inflicted must be told at another time.
C. P. BOLLMAN.