ANOTHER ATTACK

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 12, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 11.

Read the full edition

ANOTHER ATTACK.

Second Paper.

We spoke last week on some of the general principles involved in the little tract by A. McLearn, entitled, “Seventh-day Adventism: Some of its Errors and Delusions.” The notice of the work would not be complete, unless some answer was made to a few, at least, of its specific misrepresentations and perversions. The “Rev. J. B. Clarke,” who writes a page and four lines of introduction, closes that introduction with these words:—
May all who read these words earnestly seek the Holy Spirit as the guide into all truth, and “obey God rather than men,” and trust in Christ as “the way, the truth, and the life,” rather than in any so-called prophetess.
This language conveys the impression, as it was doubtless designed to do, that the whole body of Seventh-day Adventists, over twenty-five thousand in number, have taken a “so-called prophetess,” meaning Mrs. White, as “the way, the truth, and the life,” instead of Jesus Christ. But Mr. C. knows that the views of S. D. Adventists in reference to the relation of Jesus Christ and his work to the law of God, and his position as the only Saviour of men, are precisely like his own. He knows that no people exalt, or can exalt, Jesus Christ and his saving grace, more highly than this people. Why, then, does he represent that we discard Christ, and take in his stead a “so-called prophetess”? To those who know the facts in the case, such a charge will prove its own antidote; and it would hardly seem possible that a stranger would give it any credit. But it makes us ashamed of human nature to read such groundless and bare-faced perversions.
Mr. M. accuses us of dissembling in the case of the death of Christ. He says:—
Now, in this case the teachers of Adventism dissemble. They are sharp enough to see that a dogma so palpably erroneous as the absolute mortality of Christ would be met by popular derision; hence they resort to the use of phrases calculated to conceal their real meaning, and give the impression that they stand with orthodox Christians on this subject. They claim that Christ is now divine. In some way he became so after his resurrection, but in what manner or by what process they do not pretend to tell.—p. 9.
The false impression conveyed by this language cannot perhaps be made more plainly to appear, than by comparing it with a simple statement of the views we hold and have ever held on this point. We have no peculiar phrases to resort to, but let the Scriptures tell us what we are to believe. They teach us that the divine Son of God had glory with the Father before the world was (John 17 : 15); that this being took upon him “the seed of Abraham” (Heb. 2 : 16); that is, became a “partaker of flesh and blood” (verse 14), was “manifest in the flesh” (1 Tim. 3 : 16), “was made flesh and dwelt among us” (John 1 : 14), and was thus “made a little lower than the angels, for the suffering of death.” Heb. 2 : 9. And this being was just as much the divine Son of God, while here in our estate, as he was before. And as such he died. He laid down his life. And to guard against every quibble, it is said that he poured out his “soul” unto death (Isa. 53 : 12), and when he was raised from the dead, it is said that his “soul” was not left in hell (hades, the grave), neither his flesh did see corruption.” Acts 2 : 31. Mr. M. may believe, if he chooses, that the Son of God did not die; that only the body ceased to live, but the real being continued right on; and that, consequently, we have only the sacrifice of a human body to depend upon; but we prefer to take the Bible as it reads, and believe that Christ gave himself for our sins, and that we therefore have a divine sacrifice as the basis of our hope. If we are asked to explain how the divine Son of God could pass through these changes, we simply answer in the words of the apostle, “Great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh.” And we do not pretend to be able either to comprehend or explain it.
Again, we are misrepresented in regard to a change of heart. He says:—
They speak of the work of the Holy Spirit in the hearts of men, etc., just as other people do, but when you come to question them about a change of heart, you will be astonished to find that with them the new birth is a thing impossible in the present life. The new birth with an Adventist means the first resurrection. This is made necessary by the dogma that man has no spirit to regenerate.
Mr. M. was, or professed to be, once a Seventh-day Adventist himself in good standing. When he undertakes to tell what S. D. Adventists believe, he is therefore stating, of course, what he believed while he was one. But did he ever believe any such stuff as this? If so, had S. D. Adventists known it, they would have been tempted promptly to disfellowship him. But if he could be an S. D. Adventist and not hold such views, they are no inseparable part of S. D. Adventist belief. We believe, as much as any people, in a change of heart by the operation of the Holy Spirit. This is conversion. This change is represented as being “born again” (John 3 : 3), because it leads to a new and spiritual life. Any change that introduces a new life may be compared to a birth. This is why the resurrection is also called a new birth (Luke 20 : 36) because, just as our natural birth introduces us to this state of life, and the change of heart by the Holy Spirit gives us a new spiritual life, so that introduces us to a new state of being, in which we have literal eternal life in the kingdom of God. We do not believe that “the breath of life,” sometimes called “spirit,” is a mere “puff of air.” Man might force air into the lungs of a dead body, and it would accomplish nothing; but God imparts the principle of life; and he made the air breathed into Adam’s nostrils the medium through which it was conferred upon him; and hence we have as one of the definitions of the Hebrew ruah, and Greek pneuma, “the principle of life, residing in the breath, breathed by God into man’s nostrils.” But this is not a separate entity, capable of a conscious existence before it is put into the body, and after it leaves it. God did not thrust an immortal being through Adam’s nose, into his lifeless body.
Another argument by which Mr. M. tries to prove the continued conscious existence of a disembodied spirit after death, is Rom. 8 : 10. Thus he says:—
The word of God declares that man has a spirit, and that that spirit is quickened or made alive by the Spirit of the Lord, while the body remains dead. Rom. 8 : 10. But Seventh-day Adventists teach that man’s spirit is simply air, and therefore there is nothing to be quickened. Here is a palpable contradiction between the teaching of Adventism and the Bible.—p. 14.
The text referred to reads: “And if Christ be in you, the body is dead because of sin, but the spirit is life because of righteousness.” It is sufficient to remark that this text applies wholly to the present state. If Christ be in you here, the body, the old man of sin, the carnal nature, is dead, but the spirit, the new nature given by Christ, lives and makes us “new creatures” in him. It has no reference whatever to the future state and disembodied spirits.
Mr. M. says that our treatment of other denominations “is neither honest, fair, nor Christian,” because we are willing to co-operate with them in any good work, and at the same time hold that they are “Babylon.” All there is to this Babylon matter is this: We call no one Babylon. The Bible uses that term in a prophecy which we can apply nowhere else but to the divided and confused Christendom, especially Protestant Christendom, of to-day. And it is not a term of reproach; for prophecy never indulges in such; but a term used to describe a state or condition which every one knows to exist; for the word means “mixture, confusion;” and no one can believe that it was ever contemplated that there should be so many creeds and sects in the professed church of Christ. But in these bodies the great mass of true Christians are yet to be found. And not until their divisions are healed, can the term which the prophecy, on this account, applies to them, be avoided.
We come now to the central point of the whole effort; namely, the failures and inconsistencies of Mrs. White. And foremost among these we find the hackneyed charge of the shut door and no salvation for sinners since 1844. As a specimen of Mr. M.’s ability to handle this subject, and his accuracy as to historical facts, we present the following:—
That they believe this, the following facts will show: “Wm. Miller taught, and all Adventists of his time believed and taught, that as Jesus left the outer sanctuary in 1844, the door of mercy was shut forever against the ungodly world.” They considered that the work of the Aaronic priesthood exactly represented the work of Christ. For they teach that there is a tabernacle in heaven, the exact counterpart of the one that Moses built, etc.
The facts in the case are that Wm. Miller never knew anything about the view of the sanctuary held by S. D. Adventists, and never indorsed such a view. He based no ideas which he had in regard to the close of the work for the world, on the change of administration in the heavenly sanctuary. After the passing of the time in 1844, Adventists could not, for a time, have done anything for the world, if they had wished to ever so much; for nobody would listen to them. And it would be very natural for them to think that the work for the world was ended, as they were looking for the Lord daily and hourly. But it was this very subject of the sanctuary, which Mr. M. represents as responsible for the shut-door view, which corrected it. That light led out the people known as S. D. Adventists, and the more fully it was developed, the more clearly it was seen that still another message was to be given to the world, and other souls to be reached by it. These are the facts. Compare them again with the statements quoted above.
But Mr. M. argues that our view of the sanctuary, involving the position that we have been in the antitypical work of atonement, since 1844, holds us to the view that Christ then left the mediatorial seat, as no one could bring an offering on the day of atonement in the type.
The trouble with this objection is that there is no truth in it. The penitent could receive pardon on the day of atonement. The high priest went into the most holy place with the blood of an offering for the whole people, and was a mediator for the people till all the sins were figuratively blotted out. And even if a man had not brought an offering before in the year, he could come to the sanctuary on the day of atonement, afflict his soul, and thus secure an interest in the offering which the high priest was ministering in the most holy place. So in the antitype, Christ is mediator for all who will receive him till his entire work as priest is done. We had hoped to finish our remarks on this subject with this number. But this article is already sufficiently lengthy, and we defer the remaining points till a future time.