THE THEORY OF “CHRISTIAN SCIENCE.”
By L. A. S.
As a theory, “Christian Science” could not command more than a passing notice in any journal which goes before intelligent readers. The truth of this statement we design to make apparent by quotations further on. Extended allusions to the subject, such as have already appeared in the REVIEW and in many other journals, are justified by the extent and rapidity of the development of this phenomenon of human belief, and not by virtue of the claims which it puts forth. That such a theory should ever have obtained the credence which it has, in an intelligent, thoughtful community, is a phenomenon difficult of explanation, unless it be classed among the peculiar delusions which are to characterize and make perilous the closing days of human history. It is but fair to suppose, however, that a prevailing ignorance as to the real nature and claims of this new “science” has contributed very largely to this result. Appearing in the disguise furnished by the title of “Christian,” it has fascinated the minds of people by its alleged cures of disease, without attracting at once particular attention to its anti-Christian theories. It has been judged, in the public mind, more by what it claimed to accomplish than by the nature of its teachings. We think it will be apparent, however, that this does not afford the best basis for a correct judgment. Wishing to set before our readers the authentic facts in this matter, we sent to the publishers for a copy of “Rudiments and Rules of Divine Science,” the author of which is Mrs. M. B. G. Eddy, well known as the leading apostle of Christian Science. It is a small pamphlet, containing a series of questions and answers arranged for beginning students. We give only a few quotations, but sufficient to show how much claim this new and wonderful healing power has on the credulity of any intelligent person:— What is the principle of Christian Science? It is God, the Supreme Being, Infinite and Immortal Mind, the Soul of man and the universe. It is our Father which is in heaven; Substance, Spirit, Life, Truth, and Love are the Deific Principles,—p. 7. By the individuality of God, do you mean that God has a finite form? No. I mean the Infinite and Divine Principle of all Being, the ever present I Am, filling all space, including all Mind, the One Father and Mother God. Life, Truth, and Love are the Trinity in Unity, and their universe is spiritual.—p. 10. All is Mind. According to the Scriptures and Christian Science, all is God, and there is naught beside Him. “God is Spirit.”—p. 11. On pages 12–15 the subject of man’s material and “spiritual” senses is considered. It appears that the two are in conflict:— The five material senses testify to the existence of matter. The spiritual senses afford no such evidence, but deny the testimony of the material senses. Which testimony is correct? . . . If, as the Scriptures declare, God is All in all, then all must be mind, since God is mind. Therefore in divine Science there is no material mortal man, for man is spiritual and eternal, he being made in the image or Spirit of God.—p. 12. Accepting the verdict of these material senses, we should believe man and the universe to be the football of chance, and sinking into oblivion,—p. 13. According to the evidence of the so-called physical senses, man is material, fallen, sick, depraved, mortal. Science and spiritual sense afford the only true evidence of the Being of God and man, the material evidence being wholly false.—p. 15. On pages 18, 19, we learn this in regard to disease:— Mortal ills are but errors of thought, diseases of mortal mind, and not of matter; for matter cannot feel, see, or report pain. There are no sickness, sin and death in the Divine Mind. What seems to be disease, vice, and mortality are illusions of the physical senses. These illusions are not real, but unreal. From page 20 it appears that the practice of Christian Science does not necessitate any previous knowledge of physiology:— The lecturer, teacher, or the healer, who is indeed a Christian Scientist, never introduces the subject of human anatomy; never depicts the muscular, vascular, or nervous operations of the human frame. He never thinks about the structure of the material body. He never lays his hands on the patient, nor manipulates the parts of the body supposed to be ailing. A paragraph on page 17 shows the miraculous potency of this system of healing:— The aroma of my thought, without any audible or even a mental argument, has sometimes healed inveterate diseases. Even Christ and the apostles never assumed to heal the sick by the mere “aroma” of their thoughts! The healing of the sick, however, is not the main purpose of Christian Science. Mrs. Eddy says:— Healing physical sickness is but the smallest part of Christian Science. . . . The emphatic purpose of Christian Science is the healing of sin.—p. 9. The last quotation throws light upon the real nature and purpose of this so-called science. Under the guise of a new science, it is nothing else than a new religion. It is such in theory at least, if not in effect. Thus far, its notoriety seems to have been achieved in the cure of the imaginary bodily ills rather than in the healing of sin; but this perhaps is not strange, for Mrs. Eddy states in immediate connection with the quotation last given, that “this task is a million times harder than the cure of disease; because, while mortals love to sin, they do not love to be sick.” As it is known to be frequently inadequate to the latter task, it could not be thought strange if it should accomplish little or nothing in an undertaking a million times as great. Perhaps it is expected that in the future, when the leaven of Christian Science shall have more thoroughly done its work, the minds and hearts of men will be prepared so that the accomplishment of its “emphatic purpose” can be brought within the range of possibility. Of course, in this new science of unrealities, sin is as unreal as everything else. Mrs. Eddy, in her Scripture “glossary,” defines it thus:— Sin; unreal. The only reality in sin is the awful fact that unrealities seem real to human belief. I hope that I am leading you to see that there can be no power (outside of your own belief) able to make you a sinner, and that you are conquering this lie. This “glossary” is harmonious throughout. A few of the definitions it contains are as follows:— Adam; error; nothingness.
Atonement; soul’s triumph over sense.
Death; an illusion.
Devil; a lie, neither a person nor a principle.
Dirt; illusion. Bathing or rubbing, to alter the secretions or remove unhealthy exhalations from the cuticle, receive a useful rebuke from Christian Science.
Eve; a finite belief in life.
Flesh; an error of personal belief.
Hell; error.
Man; the idea of principle not person.
New Jerusalem; Divine Science.
Resurrection; material belief yielding to spiritual understanding.
Spirits; hallucinations.
Trinity; God, Jesus, and Christian Science. All these and many others of like character were compiled for use in the study of the Scriptures, as a key for the opening of their “spiritual” or “secondary” sense. It is needless to comment on such a system of theology as is here set forth. All that can be done is to set before people the real character and claims of this spreading delusion; a belief in which, with such a knowledge before him, must be taken as evidence that the individual is beyond the reach of any principles of logic and reason which can be brought to bear upon him. One can easily imagine the utter uselessness of attempting to restore an individual to a rational form of Christian belief when there exists no common basis of faith in either science or revelation to serve as a starting-point for the effort. To conclude with a brief and comprehensive verdict on the entire subject, we borrow a phrase from the small boy’s celebrated composition on pins. “Pins,” the essay began, “have saved a great many people’s lives, by their not swallerin’ ’em.” The same is emphatically true of the doctrines of “Christian Science.” L. A. S.