ANOTHER ATTACK

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 5, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 10.

Read the full edition

ANOTHER ATTACK.

Seventh-day Adventism “Exposed” Again.

Moses, notwithstanding all his “mistakes,” still survives; and Seventh-day Adventism, despite its many “exposures,” never enjoyed a wider influence than it wields to-day.
It is the fortune of every cause which is designed to lead men to clearer light, greater knowledge, and better morals, to find itself antagonized from almost every quarter. The Devil does not take kindly to these regenerating influences. And if our cause was any exception to the rule, it might well cause serious misgivings as to its nature.
Bitter and unprincipled opposition is therefore not to be classed with the unexpected; the surprise pertains rather to those who engage in the work, and arises when we see men who might be supposed to possess sufficient refinement of organization to lead them to have some regard for dignity of deportment, and their own self-respect, descend in pursuance of their object, into the arena of personal vituperation.
A few days since, we received from one of our ministers in Wisconsin, a copy of a tract of 26 pages entitled, “Seventh-day Adventism: Some of its Errors and Delusions. By Rev. A. McLearn.” The tract toddles along in the usual runway of opposers of S. D. Adventists. It is a reduplication of the old tirades of the past forty years; a rehash of false charges and misrepresentations which have become so stale as to be past use without the aid of the smelling-bottle.
While so unprovoked an attack is a matter of some surprise in itself, there is a feature connected with it which is more to be regretted still; for the tract bears the imprint of the “American Sabbath Tract Society,” the Seventh-day Baptist publishing-house, at Alfred Center, N. Y., being issued and sold by them; and is furnished with an introduction by one of their ministers, “Rev. J. B. Clarke,” who has never, so far as we are aware, had any special association with the S. D. Adventist people, and who has consequently no occasion to lend his assistance to this work, other than his denominational connection. This virtually commits the S. D. Baptist denomination to this method of opposition and this form of attack. We have ever felt that we had occasion to respect and honor that people for their long defense of the sacred institution of the Sabbath; and we had hoped that they would never be betrayed into a course of action which would tend to embarrass such an attitude on our part. But if they are unable to avoid feelings of alienation and bitterness, of course they have a right to choose that way of expressing them which they may deem most creditable to themselves.
A bad break appears at the very outset between Mr. M. and his second. Thus Mr. C., in his “Introduction,” speaking of the work of S. D. Adventists, says:—
The sad examples on the one hand, of apostasy from all religious faith, and on the other of bigoted adherence to teachings that seem to make those who practice them censorious, unloving, and bitter toward all opponents, have been among the fruits that have come to our notice.
These, it seems, are all the fruits which Mr. C. has been able to discover. He finds just two classes of S. D. Adventists: one abandoning all religious faith; the other becoming censorious, unloving, and bitter. But when, on the next page, Mr. M. comes to enter upon his work, these are his opening words:—
In writing upon this subject, it should be distinctly understood that it is with no invidious spirit or disposition to injure any one. The Seventh-day Adventists, as a body, have been very kind to me; and there are many of them for whom I have the profoundest respect for their amiability and pure lives.
These are very different fruits—“kind” “amiable” and “pure in life.” Either the one who writes this is deceived in regard to this people, or the other does not know them; and if he writes about them without knowing them, it is a shame unto him. Prov. 18:13.
Were it not that the matter is of a serious nature, the picture set before us in this tract would be very amusing; for it is exceedingly ludicrous (or would be if it were not contemptible) to see a man, while slyly pawing around in the mire to work up a mud-ball for the objects of his dislike, call upon all to witness that he has n't any wrong spirit, and does not intend to injure any one, and exclaim, “What kind emotions I have! How loving I do feel!” and then when his missile is ready, rise up and hurl it with a venom which shows that he would gladly smirch the whole body beyond remedy, if possible.
We have fallen into the habit, when we meet with works of this kind, of inquiring first of all into the reasons which have called them forth. What great evils does Mr. M. discover, that have led him to be to the pains of writing a tract? We have looked through the twenty-six pages carefully, and are somewhat puzzled to explain the matter. He accuses us of holding certain unscriptural views, and being dishonest in the way we promulgate them. He finds fault with us for believing that in the death of Christ as the basis of the atonement, we have something more than merely the death of a human body; he charges us with being gross materialists because we deny that man is naturally immortal out of Christ; that in our books we dissemble our real views (which is certainly singular, since the books are written expressly to explain them); that we believe that “the door of mercy was shut in 1844;” that we follow Mrs. White as an inspired, infallible prophetess; and that when a person gives up S. D. Adventism, he gives up all religious faith. These are about the sum of our offending, as far as we are able to make it out.
To give up all faith is, of course, to give up the hope of eternal life; and this he sets forth as the general, if not the inevitable, issue out of S. D. Adventism. Yet he has written a book to have everybody give it up! At the same time he admits that a person may be an Adventist and yet be a Christian (p. 15). Now it would seem to us a much better way to let a man remain, yes, earnestly encourage him to remain, in a position in which he may be a Christian and be saved, rather than to try to crowd him into one in which he would almost inevitably be lost.
Speaking of those who give up, he says (p. 14): “Having nothing to fall back upon, and detecting the errors of Adventist theories, they turn away and discard Christianity altogether.” But why is it, we ask, that they have “nothing to fall back upon”? Cannot the other churches furnish them anything to fall back upon? If not, are we to blame for it? This is an unconscious acknowledgment that these persons consider Adventism the best there is; and that, if anything could hold them, that could. And this we say is the case. And this is why we have thousands in our ranks whom other churches failed entirely to move, but who now, rescued from infidelity or worldliness, are rejoicing in the blessed hope of the appearing of the Saviour, and of a glorious immortality through Christ their Lord. But there are some whom no religious influences seem sufficient to reach; or who, if they do commence the Christian life, cannot be kept in the way for any great length of time. Many turned away even from the Lord himself when he was here upon the earth. And when such cases occur now, we respectfully submit that Adventism is no more responsible for it than any other denomination; for if there was any other theory in which they could have more confidence, they would turn to that.
Following the last quotation, he says: “This class of apostates is astonishingly numerous.” But he has failed to tell us who these are, and in what part of the country they are to be found. We have not yet heard of them. And if it is so, then S. D. Adventism must be making converts at a pretty rapid rate; for each year, for several years past, has shown an increase, over all deaths and apostasies, of many hundred members.
He continues: “Adventists in Battle Creek have said to me repeatedly that if they give up the ‘visions,’ they give up all.” Then we would say, By all means hold on to the visions; for as they counsel to no evil, they cannot hurt you; and it will be better to believe them and cling to your hope, than to “give up all;” for that would be certain death. But Mr. M., knowing these circumstances, says, Give them up; and he writes a tract to help them along. Rather than have us believe in Mrs. White and the mortality of man out of Christ, he would have us give these up, even though we should all go to the Devil. This, then, he must consider the lesser of two evils; and this is one reason that has led us to inquire for the great evils that have called forth his attack upon us.
Mr. M. would of course be glad to see Seventh-day Adventism stop right here and now; and, per consequence, he would be glad if it never had been known. That is what the presence of his tract means, if it means anything more than a little petty spite against a few Adventist leaders. But Mr. M. is a Sabbath-keeper, professing still to love, and rejoice in, the new-found light concerning the Sabbath of the Lord. And who brought him this light and truth?—Seventh-day Adventists. And as the result of their work, there are in the land to-day 30,000 Sabbath-keepers, who in all probability would not have been occupying this position, had it not been for this work. But notwithstanding his professed love for the Sabbath, all this seems to count for nothing with him, in comparison with the horrible delusion that man has immortality alone through Christ, and that there is manifested through Mrs. White one of the gifts of the Spirit, which the apostle in Corinthians and Ephesians expressly declares were set in the Christian church. Better that there should be 30,000 less Sabbath-keepers in the world than there are to-day, than that any one should believe in Mrs. White! And so we become more and more puzzled over the secret of his onslaught upon this cause.
But perhaps we have the explanation in this: On page 15 he says:—
We do not claim that an Adventist cannot be a Christian, for there are, without doubt, many sincere but deluded Christians among them; but we do claim that, from the nature of their creed, a person may be a faithful, loyal, and consistent Seventh-day Adventist, and still be unregenerated, and therefore not a Christian.
Oh! Because Seventh-day Adventism is such a system that it is possible for a man to profess it and not be a Christian, therefore let us tear it down. But we wonder if no one ever professed the S. D. Baptist faith who was unregenerated and not a Christian; or the Methodist faith; or Presbyterian, or any other. But you say, in such case, the person was not a “loyal and consistent” S. D. Baptist, Methodist, etc. And, we reply, neither is any unregenerated person a “loyal and consistent” S. D. Adventist, no matter what his profession; for our “creed” is “the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus;” and if a person lives up to these principles, he is certainly a Christian.
But perhaps we find the secret of his effort in the closing paragraph, which reads:—
We only hope, for the sake of all who have not acquainted themselves with the nature of this unscriptural system, and for the honor of the Redeemer’s cause, that our dear brethren and sisters in Christ, especially of our Seventh-day Baptist churches, will pause and consider well the facts set forth in these pages, before they tamper with this subtle and soul-deceiving delusion.
So it appears that some Seventh-day Baptists may be getting interested, and it is to prevent their embracing these views, that the tract is written. Yet he has failed to show that the delusion is so very deadly, since a person holding it may be a “Christian,” “very kind,” and entitled to “profoundest respect,” for “amiability,” and “purity of life.” And he will find that it will not particularly help his cause nor injure ours, when those whom he addresses find that his charges are based on misrepresentation and perversion. An examination of his specific points we must leave to another week.