BY FRANK W. HOWE.
(Battle Creek College.)
In the report of the hearing on the Sunday-rest bill, Dr. Sunderland, of Washington, D. C., is “very glad to communicate” some interesting information on what might be called the origin, distinctions, transmutations, and present status of the week. In a few words he concisely states a history which deserves the dignity (but lacks the accuracy) of a scientific treatise. We quote from the point where his speech begins to have significance:—
We find upon examination of the Scriptures that there are three distinct weekly periods pointed out and legislated for. One is the creation week, another is the Jewish week, and the third is the Christian week.
Another learned doctor, who is the author of a work on “The Lord’s Day Our Sabbath,” which is advertised as containing all the newest and freshest arguments, distinguishes still another variety, the “human week.” But Dr. S. himself branches out in a generous way as his subject advances. After nine questions and interruptions, he continues thus:—
We find in the Scriptures, and it is a fundamental distinction of the weekly period, that it consists of six secular days, followed by a seventh—a sacred day, or day of rest. That was the case with the creation week, and the order is not changed anywhere under any dispensation—the paradisiacal, the patriarchal, the Jewish, or the Christian. A week consists of six secular days, followed by a seventh, a sacred day. So far as the records of the Bible show, there is no notice anywhere of the change from the creation week to the Jewish week, or the change from the Jewish week to the Christian week.
It is difficult to conceive why the Doctor is so emphatic in re-iterating these statements, unless it be on the principle of those would-be Roman emperors who, when defeated, committed suicide to keep from being killed. He is particular to state that the order of the days has not been changed anywhere under any dispensation; and that in the Bible there is no evidence of the change from the creation week to the Jewish week, or from that to the Christian week. What is the necessary and logical conclusion?—That there never was and never could be any change, except in name. Further in the discussion, in answer to a question of the chairman, he is careful to leave the impression that he considers the days of creation to be literal days; which adds strength, if it were needed, to his statement that the Bible records no change from the “creation week” to the “Jewish week.” And as if forever to settle any possible misunderstanding of his language concerning any change in the order of the days in passing from the “Jewish week” to the “Christian week,” he says, “The Christian Sabbath is the seventh day of the Christian week, and comes directly under the fourth commandment of the decalogue: ‘Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work, but the seventh is the Sabbath of the Lord; in that thou shalt do no work; thou shalt rest.’” Query: Did he quote that command from a Catholic catechism? Why do doctors of divinity invariably omit the last three-quarters of the fourth commandment? Perhaps we shall see.
I ought to state further how this division of weeks arises. In every case—in the creation week, in the Jewish week, and in the Christian week—they are reckoned from, and founded upon, some great providential event. The creation week is founded upon, and reckoned from, the creation of this world. The Jewish week, which was designed for a particular and special nation, is founded upon, and reckoned from, the falling of the manna.
That sounds so euphonious that we must stop right here and admire it. That species known as the “creation week” exists because God created this earth in six days and rested the seventh. The species known as the “Jewish week” exists because the manna fell six days and refrained from falling on the seventh. Therefore the manna is responsible for that old Jewish Sabbath whose advocates cause us so much inconvenience! That is certainly a novel idea, but it is worth investigating. Let us refer, for a change, from the Doctor’s assertions to the Scriptures themselves on this latter point. Let us inquire whether the week at that time was determined by the continuance of the manna during six days and its cessation on the seventh, or whether this regularity in its fall and cessation was determined by the week.
Ex. 16:26: “Six days ye shall gather it; but on the seventh day, which is the Sabbath, in it there shall be none.” Here the week is definitely pointed out, “six secular days, followed by a seventh.” Now was the seventh day the Sabbath because the manna did not fall, or did the manna cease because it was the Sabbath day—the end of the week? The Doctor’s professional associates are fond of quoting, “Man was not made for the Sabbath, but the Sabbath was made for man.” It would seem to suit the Doctor himself better to have it read, “Manna was not made for the Sabbath, but the Sabbath was made for the manna.” That reading would assist him vastly in giving plausibility to his assertion that the “Jewish week [of course including the so-called Jewish Sabbath] was designed for a particular and special nation;” for it would be an easy transition from the manna to the manna-eaters. But let us look farther. “And the Lord said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws? See, for that the Lord hath given you the Sabbath, therefore he giveth you on the sixth day the bread of two days; abide ye every man in his place, let no man go out of his place on the seventh day.” Verses 28, 29. Here is a plain declaration that the manna fell as it did because the Lord had given them the Sabbath; which of course marked the termination of the week. Instead of being determined by the providential gift of the manna, it was founded upon the commandments and laws of God. Before the manna fell, God declared its purpose to Moses in the fourth verse of the same chapter:—“Then said the Lord unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law or no.” Observe that this object in thus sending the manna is most definitely expressed—that he might prove them, whether they would walk in his law. The Doctor must admit that if this law was not already in existence, it was certainly given soon after. We find it in that fourth commandment, the first quarter of which he has quoted as a warrant for the obligation of the “Christian Sabbath.” That commandment is the only formal, written law for what is called the “Jewish Sabbath”; and the part which he very conveniently did not quote, identifies it with the Sabbath of the creation week: “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.” In Gen. 2:3, the last expression is explained in these words: “And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it.” To sanctify is to set apart, to dedicate to a holy use. (See Webster.) For whose use?—“The Sabbath was made for man.” Dr. Sunderland knows that this sublime declaration was made concerning the Sabbath which the Jews observed. It was made before the time when the most ardent advocates of Sunday will presume to claim that the first day was substituted for the seventh by divine appointment. So we see that the “Jewish week” was not “designed for a particular and special nation;” it was not “founded upon, and reckoned from, the falling of the manna,” and it is not distinguishable from the “creation week”; and by his use of the fourth commandment the Doctor himself virtually identifies the “Christian Sabbath” with this “Jewish” and “creation” Sabbath,—if his argument were consistent; but the quality of consistency is not a necessary characteristic of such efforts. Let us proceed:—
The Christian week is founded upon, and reckoned from, the greatest providential event of all—the resurrection of Jesus Christ. In the twentieth chapter of John’s Gospel we will find that there on a certain day it was found that he arose. On the evening of the same day he met with his disciples. Eight days afterward he met with them again. That is the record of the first Christian week.
Indeed! it began on a “certain day” and ended on another certain day eight days after the first; so there were eight days in this “first Christian week.” Dr. Herrick Johnson, the speaker who preceded Dr. S., was cautious enough to say, “Seven days after there was another meeting. . .” Neither of the learned gentlemen have quoted the text correctly. It is in John 20:26, and states that it was “after eight days” that this second appearance occurred. So if that is the “record of the first Christian week,” it contained at least nine days! Now, will the Doctor be pleased to explain this discrepancy when he has been so particular to declare that it is a fundamental distinction of the weekly period; that it consists of six secular days followed by a seventh—the Sabbath; and that this order has not been changed anywhere under any dispensation! It would be very gratifying if this apparent contradiction could be reconciled. If he could have brought in his eight-day week seven days earlier, it might seem to relieve the subject of embarrassment; but then there would have been six secular days followed by two Sabbaths, which appears to contradict the Doctor’s “fundamental distinction” again. The only alternative to this, however, is to have the first Christian week consist of a Sabbath followed by six secular days, which would be equally objectionable on the score of consistency. But perhaps the Doctor can give us a little light, for a little later, in answer to a question of the chairman, he declares that Sunday “is the seventh day of the Christian week.” Then Monday must be the first day of that week; and as the preceding Saturday was also a seventh day, the day which intervenes must have been dropped out; otherwise there would have been two first days. First-day advocates are so fond of the “lost time theory,” whenever the claims of the definite seventh day are pointed out, that the Doctor would doubtless admit its operation right at this point, and grant that this particular day was the identical one that was lost! Peradventure this explains why no man knows exactly when Christ was resurrected!
Indeed, the Doctor particularly designates this as an “intercalary day,” and maintains “that the phrase ‘the first day of the week,’ which we find in our English version, ought never to have been there,” and that the original Greek indicates that it ought to have been translated “one of the Sabbaths.” This Greek expression has given a vast amount of perplexity to some theologians; yet the New Version still renders it simply “the first day of the week.” The same word occurs in Luke 18:12, in the parable of the self-righteous Pharisee and the publican, where in enumerating his virtues, he says, “I fast twice in the week.” Did Dr. Sunderland ever experience the hardship of fasting twice in one Sabbath?
It would indeed have been better for this theory if the doings of this day, if not the day itself, had been dropped from the inspired record. For instead of showing that this was a religious meeting, and that the disciples had assembled to honor Christ’s resurrection, and expected his presence with them, the Gospels prove that they were assembled in their own common home for fear of the Jews, that they were frightened when he appeared, and that he upbraided them because they did not believe that he had risen! Mark 16:14.