AdventAI

W. A. C

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 27., July 2, 1889

THE GREEK CHURCH.—NO. 2.

As before suggested, the idea that the authority of a bishop should be commensurate to the size and importance of the city in which he officiated, quite early prevailed. Constantine the Great divided the Roman empire into four large divisions called prefects, each ruled by an officer called a prefecture. Each prefect was divided into dioceses, thirteen in all; and each diocese, into provinces, one hundred and sixteen altogether. Those officers who were placed over the provinces, were responsible to the rulers of the dioceses, those to the prefectures, and these to the emperor. The Church caught the idea, and very soon adopted the same plan in its government. The bishop in the principal city of a prefect was made to correspond in authority in the Church, to that of the prefecture in the government. He was given the title of patriarch. The bishop of the principal city of a diocese corresponded to the political head of the diocese, and was called exarch. And the bishop of the principal city of a province corresponded to the ruler of the province, and was styled metropolitan. Those officiating in the smaller places in his district, were called suffragans. As in the State, so in the Church: the suffragans were amenable to the metropolitans, the metropolitans to the exarchs, the exarchs to the patriarchs; but to whom the patriarchs were responsible, was the question. There were the patriarchs of Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem. These all eagerly craved the predominancy, and aspired to that position in the Church which in the State was held by the emperor, and which in truth belonged alone to Christ: “Neither be ye called masters; for one is your Master, even Christ.” Matt. 23: 10. But adopting this form of government, the patriarchs of Alexandria, Jerusalem, and Antioch were very naturally regarded as prelates of the second order, and the controversy over the supremacy narrowed down to the bishops of the two cities which had each enjoyed for a time the honor of being the seat of government in the empire—Constantinople in the East, and Rome in the West. Between the bishops of these two cities the controversy became a warm and determined struggle.

Various theological questions arose during the third, fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh centuries, such as that of the trinity—whether in the Godhead there were three persons in one, or one in three; the nature of Christ—whether he had one or two natures, a human and a divine; the Holy Ghost—whether it proceeded from the Father and the Son, or from the Father alone, and various other such questions. These excited a vast amount of contention; councils were called, and temporary decisions made, those in the East often favoring one view, and those in the West another. Of the contentions of the fifth and sixth centuries, Mosheim very fittingly remarks: “The sacred and venerable simplicity of the primitive times, which required no more than a true faith in the word of God, and a sincere obedience to his holy laws, appeared little better than rusticity and ignorance to the subtile doctors of this quibbling age. . . The greatest part of them reasoned and disputed concerning the truths of the gospel, as the blind would argue about light and colors, and imagined that they had acquitted themselves nobly when they had thrown out a heap of crude and indigested notions, and overwhelmed their adversaries with a torrent of words.”

A controversy involving a matter of more importance than these abstruse and sophistical questions, however, arose in the eighth century, concerning the worship of images, a practice which had become so prevalent among the churches throughout the Roman empire, both east and west. The opposition to this idolatrous and superstitious practice, however, did not originate with the bishops, but was begun by the emperor. Leo III., the Isaurian, coming to the throne and being a professor of Christianity, and becoming convinced of the enormity of this evil, issued an edict in 726, ordering all images to be removed from the churches in the empire. These sentiments and measures were also adopted and carried out by his son Constantine, and his grandson Leo IV., who succeeded him on the throne. A council composed of Eastern bishops assembled in Constantinople in 754, and declared in favor of the opinion embraced by the emperors, and solemnly condemned the worship and use of images. Although these measures did not have the desired effect of wholly extirpating the idolatrous practice from the churches, it did much toward accomplishing this end among those in the East. While there was no little contention over the matter among the prelates of the East, the greatest opposition came from the West. The Roman pontiff, Gregory II., vehemently opposed the edict against images, demanding the emperor to revoke it. Upon being refused, this audacious pope declared him unworthy of the name and privileges of a Christian, and excluded him from the communion of the church. The emperor, Leo III., manifested his resentment by a general mandate ordering all images to be publicly burned, and inflicting a variety of severe punishments upon such as persisted in this idolatrous worship. These rigorous measures divided the church into two violent factions,—the iconoclasts, or destroyers of images, and the iconolaters, or image worshipers. Pope Gregory III. defended this odious superstition of image-worship with even greater zeal, if possible, than his predecessor. Concerning this Mosheim says, “It was their extravagant attachment to image-worship that chiefly occasioned the separation of the Italian provinces from the Grecian empire.”

But none of these theological controversies served to alienate the two aspiring bishops, the pope of Rome and the patriarch of Constantinople, and divide the church as did the insatiable cravings of these prelates for ecclesiastical supremacy. Of the seventh century Mosheim says, “The disputes about pre-eminence that had so long subsisted between the bishops of Rome and Constantinople, proceeded in this century to such violent lengths as laid the foundation of that deplorable schism which afterward separated the Greek and Latin churches.” To enlarge their temporal domains and increase their ecclesiastical authority was their highest ambition. The above-named historian continues: “The Roman pontiffs used all sorts of methods to maintain and enlarge the authority and pre-eminence which they had acquired by a grant from the most odious tyrant that ever disgraced the annals of history.” As he elsewhere says, “Those means were deemed the most lawful that tended best to the accomplishment of their purposes.” He thus concludes: “We shall, therefore, only observe that in this century were sown the seeds of those fatal discords which rent asunder the bonds of Christian communion between the Greek and Latin churches: indeed, these seeds had already taken root in the minds of the Greeks, to whom the Roman power became insupportable, and the pretentions of the sovereign pontiff odious.”

W. A. C