AdventAI

CARELESS READING.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 23., June 4, 1889

The utter lack of thought and discrimination which many manifest in the reading of Gen. 2: 2, 3, is truly remarkable. In a single hasty reading of the passage this would not perhaps seem so strange; but it appears in the words even of some who claim to give the passage a close and critical examination, and who make such full use of it as to constitute it the basis of an argument.

It is well understood that Gen. 2: 2, 3, if it will sustain the interpretation claimed for it by observers of the seventh day, becomes a strong citadel for the Sabbath institution; for if the Sabbath was there instituted, and man was commanded to keep it in regularly recurring succession from that time on, the Sabbath is established upon a foundation from which it is impossible to move it. The first effort, therefore, of opposers of the Sabbath, generally, is to break down the testimony of Gen. 2: 2, 3.

A brother has sent us clippings from three numbers of the American Baptist, published in April last, containing three articles from one Rev. E. B. Hatch, on this subject. He rightly deems it necessary to dispose first of Gen. 2: 2, 3. Speaking of the position held by observers of the seventh day on this subject, he says, “Admit the premises, and it is hard to deny the conclusion.” Exactly; and so he undertakes to dispose of the premises. After quoting the texts referred to, he says:—

It will be observed that these words contain no precept or command. We have in them a simple historical statement, and that is all. The substance of the statement is this: God ended his work on the seventh creation day; on that day he rested, and in so doing he blessed and sanctified it. We have no proof here whatever of the establishment of a permanent Sabbatic institution. Nothing is said about a recurring weekly Sabbath. No Sabbath is here enjoined upon man, and the language authorizes no man to observe one. Many have made the mistake of conceding that God here establishes the Sabbath upon the seventh day of the week for the observance of man; but by no system of torture can a strict construction of the text be made to teach anything of the kind. We admit all it affirms, but deny the unwarrantable inferences people have drawn from it in order to support a theory. Let us take this text just as inspiration has given it to us, but add nothing to it.

Mr. Hatch may be thoroughly honest in all this. If so, we pity his mental organization; if not, his moral. If established facts could be overthrown by man’s ignorance, or the Lord’s positive statements be set aside by man’s denials, he would have made out, in the foregoing, a complete case. For if he had deliberately set about making every statement as opposite to the truth as it could be, he could not have succeeded better. One of his declarations should be changed so as to read as follows: “We deny all that the text affirms, and admit the unwarrantable inferences people have drawn from it to support a theory.”

These, we are aware, are grave charges; but their gravity only measures the magnitude of the offense. He asserts that God in resting on the seventh day blessed and sanctified it. This is a glaring perversion of the inspired record. That says that God rested on the seventh day, and, then, as an independent, separate, and subsequent act, God blessed and sanctified it “because that in it he had rested from all his work.”

“No Sabbath,” he says, “is here enjoined upon man, and the language authorizes no man to observe one.” We wonder what idea he has of the word “sanctify” as applied to the seventh day. We wonder what he would have thought of the record if it had been worded, “And God blessed the seventh day, and commanded man to keep it holy.”

And if he had read the passage a little more carefully, he would have seen that this is exactly what it does say; for the verb “to sanctify” means “to set apart to a holy or religious use;” and a day could not possibly be set apart to a religious use, as the text affirms that the seventh day was, except by giving a command to men to use it in this religious manner. The command itself is not of course here given; but its equivalent is here, namely, the record that such a command was given to Adam and Eve, and through them to their children and children’s children to the latest generation. “Let us take this text just as inspiration has given it to us.” “Admit the premises,” and every one must admit them, or deny the record, “and it is hard to deny the conclusion.”

It is unnecessary to follow the effort of this man any farther with reference to the seventh day. Starting out with so complete a perversion of the Scripture, the farther he goes the farther he is from the truth.

Contrary to former Baptist belief and teaching, he repudiates the idea of a change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. Shifting over upon Campbellite or Disciple ground, he would have the seventh-day Sabbath end with the Jewish economy, and declares that the first day of the week, under the title of “Lord’s day,” is a new institution, resting on a different basis, and observed for another reason.

We would like to see some sound basis pointed out, and some valid reason given. We are told it is to commemorate the resurrection of Christ. But of all people, Baptists do not need Sunday as such a memorial; for they have all the memorial that is necessary in the divinely appointed ordinance of baptism.

Mr. H. can very easily ignore the blessing and sanctification of the seventh day; but let us just for a moment imagine that a record could be found somewhere in the New Testament reading like this: “Wherefore the Lord blessed the first day and sanctified it.” What use would be made of this? and how much value would it have in the eyes of Sunday advocates?

Alas! how preconceived opinions and religious bias and bigotry will lead a man to ignore facts, call light darkness and darkness light, and stultify his reasoning powers in the defense of phantoms. Thank God for a Sabbatic institution which is sound and solid from base to final; and for a commandment which runs bright as the light and straight as the sunbeam from Eden to Eden.