Not since William Morgan, the opposer of Freemasonry, so mysteriously disappeared from public view in 1826, has any event occurred so well calculated to bring into prominence the work and character of secret societies as the clearing up of the “Cronin mystery,” in Chicago. The evidence points conclusively to murder, done by prominent members of a secret organization, the Clan-na-Gael. It was not a murder for robbery or revenge, but for reasons growing out of the nature of the victim’s connection with this secret organization. Naturally, it does not tend to set the society in a favorable light before the public.
The Clan-na-Gael, otherwise known as the Irish Revolutionary Brotherhood and the United Brotherhood, may be taken as a typical representative of those secret societies which are secret in character as well as in name, not having suffered the loss in this respect which has been the case with other secret orders through long drifting on the sea of popularity. It is a powerful and wide-spread organization, whose object identifies it with the forces arrayed against Great Britain in its political conflict with Ireland. From a brief outline of Clan-na-Gael methods of dealing with offenders, given by the Chicago Inter Ocean, it appears that it tries and condemns such persons without their knowledge, any camp or lodge having the power under ordersp. 361 to form a committee for this purpose. The lodge of which the offender is a member then proceeds to take such action as may be considered necessary from the finding of this committee. In this manner it is probable that Dr. Cronin was “tried” and sentenced to removal, as a person whose presence was considered dangerous to the prosperity of the order.
In the odium which thus attaches to the Clan-na-Gael, it will be difficult for any secret order to escape some degree of participation, since it is the element of secrecy, alike in all, which screens the doings of the order from public observation and thereby makes easier to its members the way to crimes against life and property. We would not be understood as placing all secret societies upon a level with the Clan-na-Gael, but this element of their character, so far as it amounts to anything, has a natural tendency to bring them there. Secret societies there are, like the Freemasons, Odd-fellows, and other well-known orders, which, with barely enough left of their assumptions to secrecy to furnish them an excuse for existence, have ceased to be anything more formidable than an aggregation of individuals fond of petty power and parade; but even these supply conditions which in the hands of unscrupulous persons are capable of rendering them a menace to individual and public welfare.
A secret organization which is such both in name and in purpose has no known right to existence. Where the object is above suspicion, secrecy is unnecessary. Such a feature can only serve to identify an organization with those who “love darkness rather than light, because their deeds are evil,” and who repudiate the leadership of Him who said, “In secret have I said nothing.” L. A. S.