A DISAPPOINTING TEXT

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 7, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 19.

Read the full edition

A DISAPPOINTING TEXT.

THE advocates of Sunday make a great deal of John 20:26: “And after eight days again his disciples were within and Thomas with them; then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.”
Here, it is said, the fact is specially noted that after Christ met with his disciples on the Sunday of his resurrection, he met with them the next Sunday, evidently with the design of conferring honor upon that day, and showing it to be the Christian Sabbath.
When we suggest that the expression “after eight days” naturally means more than a week, the reply is, Oh, no; for the expression “after three days” (Matt. 27:63) means “on the third day” (Matt. 16:21); and hence the expression “after eight days,” by parity of reasoning, would mean “on the eighth day;” and on the eighth day, reckoned from one Sunday, would be on the next Sunday.
If this is so, the same parity of reasoning may be applied to other expressions; and let us see where it will lead us? For instance, “after two days” would mean “on the next day,” and “after one day” would be “on the same day;” which, being a reductio ad absurdum, spoils the argument. We cannot therefore admit that the statements respecting the three days establish a rule for all other numbers.
As to the expression “after three days,” we are able to find but one occasion where our Lord made use of it; and that is Mark 8:31, the instance in Matt. 27:63 being simply a repetition of his words by his enemies. His ordinary manner was to speak of the day of his resurrection as “the third day.” See Matt. 16:21; 17:23; 20:19; 26:61; Mark 9:31; 10:34; Luke 9:22; 18:33; 24:7; John 2:19.
From all these instances, speaking of the same event, we know that Mark 8:31 must be interpreted in the same manner, and mean “on the third day.” But we have no such collateral texts to guide us in the interpretation of the expression “after eight days,” in John 20:26. If we had some ten other texts referring to the same event, and stating that it occurred, or was to occur, “on the eighth day,” then we might rest assured that the expression “after eight days,” in the one instance of its use, meant “on the eighth day.” But, as already noticed, we have no such texts.
We have, however, some texts speaking of a number higher than three, and a comment thereon, which must be taken as having some bearing on the case before us. Thus in Matt. 17:1 and Mark 9:2, we have the expression “after six days.” But Luke (9:28), speaking of the same event, translates the “after six days” of Matthew and Mark into the expression, “about an eight days after.”
This is the only light we have in the New Testament on numbers higher than three; and it shows that although “after three days” is used in the sense of “on the third day,” that fact does not establish any rule for any other number, and no just argument can be built upon it to sustain such a conclusion.
Again, we find an instance where the expression given to denote a week, is “after seven days.” 1 Chron. 9:25, 32, compared with 2 Kings 11:5. From all these facts the conclusion is inevitable that above the number “three,” such expressions as “after” four, five, six, seven, or eight days, etc., are to be taken in their literal, and not in any idiomatic, sense. In which case, “after eight days,” would mean more than eight days or a later point than “the eighth day.”
But, finally, even if we admit that the expression means “on the eighth day,” the text is bound still to disappoint our Sunday friends, so far as it relates to the point they have in view; for it contains no proof that the eighth day from the meeting in question was Sunday. Let us look at the circumstances. The time is to be reckoned from a certain meeting of Christ with his disciples. And what meeting was that?—It was the one in which Jesus appeared after the two disciples had returned from Emmaus. Luke 24:33–35. Compare Mark 16:12–14 and John 20:24, 25. But the day was “far spent” when Jesus and the two disciples were at Emmaus (Luke 24:29); and going back to Jerusalem after that, seven and a half miles, on foot, those two disciples could not possibly have reached the city before that first day had ended and the second day had begun, which was ushered in by the setting of the sun. It was not till after this that Jesus appeared in their midst. Thus the interview recorded in Mark 16:14 and John 20:19, must have taken place after the close of the day of the resurrection, on the second day of the week, not on the first. And it is from this meeting that the time “after eight days” is to be reckoned; and reckoned from this point, the next meeting could not by any possibility be located sooner than at the beginning of the second day of the next week, allowing that the expression means, “on the eighth day.”
To this it will doubtless be said that John declares that it was on “the first day of the week,” when they came together; and so it was when they came together; but it was not necessarily that day when all the events took place; for some of them would occupy time which would easily carry them over into the second day. Thus they came together for their evening meal (Mark 16:14), and shut the doors for fear of the Jews. Some time would elapse in the preparation and the partaking of the meal, and it appears that they lingered around the table till the two disciples got back from Emmaus, which, as we have seen, must have been after sunset, and consequently after the second day had begun. Then finally Christ himself appeared in their midst. And from this meeting the eight days are to be reckoned. So the next meeting must have been, in any event, as late as the second day of the next week. It could not have been on Sunday.