MRS. BATEHAM AND THE CONSTITUTION

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 26, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 13.

Read the full edition

MRS. BATEHAM AND THE CONSTITUTION.

BY W. A. COLCORD.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
Those who are laboring so persistently to reform the Government of the United States, change its Constitution, and enact a national Sabbath law, are endeavoring to remodel matters, upon the principle that “the revealed will of God is of supreme authority in civil affairs.” In other words, they wish to make this Government an exact type of the government of God. That God’s government is a good one we have no desire to question. And that it would be very desirable that all our presidents, senators, representatives, and officials everywhere should be godlike men, and as pure as the angels, cannot be denied. But that they are not, and are not likely to be, will be about as readily conceded as it will be that all have sinned and come short of the glory of God. We should naturally expect, however, that the prime movers in this so-called reform would embody in their proposed changes at least the main characteristics of that form of government which they are seeking to introduce.
Prominent in the divine government is the fact that God is no respecter of persons. Acts 10:34, 35. Upon this declaration running all through his revealed will, is founded the doctrine of his justice and the very conception of the perfection of his government. But how largely this divine attribute is possessed by our would-be National Reformers, and how prominent a feature it would be in the proposed administration of the revealed will of God in civil affairs, may be judged from a provision proposed by one of its prominent advocates, Mrs. J. C. Bateham. This lady is the superintendent of the Sabbath-observance department of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, and was the second person who spoke in the hearing of the Senate committee, Dec. 13, 1888, on the Sunday-rest bill. In the previous deliberations of the W. C. T. U. upon this subject, the infringement which this bill would naturally make upon the rights of seventh-day observers had evidently been considered, and hence, Mrs. Bateham, in her speech, suggested the following addition to the bill:—
Section VII. Any person that has habitually and conscientiously refrained from all labor on Saturday, believing that to be the Sabbath, shall, on proof thereof, be exempt from the penalties of this law, provided he has not on Sunday interfered with the rights of others to a day for rest and worship.
This would have been quite magnanimous, had it not been for the discrimination and partiality shown in the last clause. In that lies the dead-fly of this ointment poured out for Sabbatarians. Sabbath-keepers shall be exempt from the penalties of the Sunday law, provided they have not interfered with the rights of Sunday-keepers on Sunday. Now we wish to ask if the Sunday-keeper has any rights on Sunday that the Sabbath-keeper has not on Saturday, and if the Sabbath-keeper is any more likely to disturb the Sunday-keeper in his rest and worship than the Sunday-keeper is to disturb the Sabbath-keeper in his rest and worship; and if an intentional disturbance on the part of one would not be as much a breach of the public peace as on the part of the other; and if a person should not be held as culpable for the one as for the other? Why restrict seventh-day observers from interfering with the rights of Sunday-keepers, and not restrict Sunday-keepers from interfering with the rights of seventh-day observers? Is it because one citizen of the United States has rights which another has not, or that one’s rights are more sacred than another’s; or has not the seventh-day citizen any rights? Why should a man, the echoes of whose ax in the distant woods might chance to be heard by some worshiping assembly on Sunday, be fined and imprisoned any more than the blacksmith who should beat on his anvil on Saturday a discordant chime to the devotions of a seventh-day assembly? For our laws to be so framed as to convict one and not the other, would be for them to respect persons. And such is the style of laws that even the gentler sex of a Christian association would dictate in their most lenient exemption clauses.
Equality before the law is the very nomenclature of equity. That is what is symbolized by the balance suspended from the hand of the Goddess of Justice reared above our courts throughout the land. That is the only pivot upon which a just administration of law can be suspended. And that was the thought which permeated the founders of this Government when they declared it to be a self-evident truth that all men are created equal.
The fourteenth amendment to the Constitution of the United States says:—
No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law, nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
What is right in this respect for the States, is right for the United States. The principle is the same. Every citizen should be entitled to the same liberty and freedom and to the same protection granted to every other citizen. But Mrs. Bateham would protect a Sunday-keeper in his rest and worship, and not a Sabbath-keeper in his rest and worship. This certainly is denying equal protection to citizens. This is placing men upon an inequality before the law. This is preferring one before another, and showing partiality,—things which “the revealed will of God” condemns: “I charge thee before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, and the elect angels, that thou observe these things without preferring one before another, doing nothing by partiality.” 1 Tim. 5:21.
We leave it to the judgment of candid, thinking men and women, if the exemption clause proposed by Mrs. Bateham who stands as a representative of a large, professedly Christian body, numbering nearly 200,000, is not contrary to the spirit of both the word of God and the Constitution of the United States. For our part, we are not quite ready yet to give our voice and vote for the National Reform party and its correlative forces to take the reins of government, nor accord to them the ability to properly administer a theocracy. We believe that the Constitution of the United States as it now stands, possesses more of those features of equality and justice which characterize the Divine government, than it will after these National Reformers and biased daughters of Eve have meddled with it. Until these parties become more like God, we think they would better let God administer his own law, and allow civil laws to control simply civil affairs. And when they do become so good as that, they will not want a Sunday law, for Sunday is not the Sabbath.