BLACKSTONE ON REMEDIAL STATUTES

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 2, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 14.

Read the full edition

BLACKSTONE ON REMEDIAL STATUTES.

BY ELD. J. F. BALLENGER.
(Riverside, Mich.)
Blackstone, the great English jurist, in speaking of the change of laws, has the following:—
There are three points to be considered in the construction of remedial statutes: the old law, the mischief, and the remedy; that is, how the law stood at the making of the act; what the mischief was, for which the law did not provide; and what remedy Parliament hath provided to cure the mischief; and it is the business of the judges to so construe the act as to suppress the mischief and advance the remedy.—Book I., p. 60.
If the above is necessary in the construction of human law, is it not equally so when applied to the divine law? It is claimed by those who advocate the change of the “old law”—the decalogue—that Christ and his apostles constituted a divine parliament which remedied the defective statute—the fourth—by substituting the first-day Sabbath for the original, or seventh-day, Sabbath. But we would like very much to have them show, if they can, where either Christ or his apostles, in considering the ten-commandment law, ever showed where it had wrought any mischief, or pointed out a remedy for any mischief the law had made, or wherein the law did not provide for the formation or protection of a perfect character so long as it is perfectly obeyed.
The Saviour, when considering the law in Matt. 5:17–20, did not think that the original act had wrought any mischief, or needed any remedy, or that it did not provide for man’s happiness, both in this life and the life to come. On the other hand, he did show that whosoever violated the law in the least degree was unworthy a place in the kingdom of heaven, but that he who would strictly obey every jot and tittle of the original enactment, would be entitled to a great name in the kingdom of God; and so far from pointing out any defect or a remedy for any defect in the statute, he plainly declared that it was easier for heaven and earth to pass than for one jot or tittle of the law to fail. Certain it is that he did not intend by this strong illustration to convey to the multitudes who heard these words that the law or any part of it would pass away at the cross—about three and a half years from the time he spoke these words. It seems to us a most wicked perversion to so construe the Saviour’s words on that occasion, as those are obliged to do who abolish the law at the death of Christ.
When the young man came to the Saviour and asked him the most important question ever asked by mortals, would he have answered, saying, “If thou wilt enter into life, keep the commandments,” if he had thought that by obeying the original law or any part of it, it would have wrought any mischief in the life or character of the young man; nor could he have meant to convey that the blessing of eternal life could be secured by obedience to the ten commandments up to the time of his death, but after that the reverse? If so, his illustration in Luke 16:17, is calculated to mislead his hearers, for in these words he makes the existence of the law run parallel with the existence of heaven and earth, which could not be true if the law was to pass away inside of four years.
The apostle Paul, several years after the death of Christ, had occasion to consider the utility of the original law in conversion, and instead of pointing out any defect in it, he said, “The law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good,” and then asked, “Was then that which is good made death unto me,” or in other words, Was it the law that wrought the mischief in me? God forbid. He then proceeds to show that it was sin—the transgression of the law— that had wrought all the mischief. Rom. 7:12, 13. And in verse 14 he calls the law spiritual, in contrast with the transgressor, who is carnal. Then the remedy for all the mischief that has been wrought does not consist in abolishing the law that has been transgressed, but by a system of redemption through faith in the blood of Christ and repentance for the remission of sin. The law could form a good character, but it could not reform a bad one. Pardon can be extended to the transgressor on condition of repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ. Then the righteousness of the law can be fulfilled in us who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit. Rom. 8:4.
Therefore, when we consider the steps to be taken in the remedying of law, as laid down by Mr. Blackstone, we find that not one of them was ever taken or hinted at by Christ or his apostles when considering the original law of the Father; but on the contrary, they showed that no remedy was needed or possible, in that the law was holy, just, and good. But strange to say, the opponents of the law think that all the mischief lies in the fourth commandment—the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath. Let us therefore notice this commandment in particular, and see if Christ or his apostles, acting as judges, ever construed it so as to suppress the mischief—the seventh-day Sabbath—and advance the remedy—the first-day Sabbath. In Matt. 2:27 the Saviour states that “the Sabbath was made for man.” Being made for man could not mean, that the original act had wrought any mischief in him, or that it was in any way against him, and in Matt. 12:10, he recognizes the obligations of the Sabbath law by saying that “it is lawful to do well on the Sabbath days.” And to show us how we could best glorify God on that day, he set us the example of attending public services and reading the Scriptures on that day, Luke 4:16. Again, to prevent any desecration of the Sabbath commandment by a confused flight from Jerusalem, Jesus taught his disciples to pray that their flight be not on the Sabbath day. Matt. 24:20. Nor could the apostles or disciples of Christ have gathered from his teaching while with them, that after his death the law was to be construed so as to correct or remedy the mischief resulting from keeping the Sabbath which he, with the Father, had blessed in the beginning; for after his death we find them keeping the “Sabbath day according to the commandment” (Luke 23:56); the apostle Paul preaching to both Jews and Gentiles on the Sabbath (Acts 13:42), and reasoning out of the Scriptures three Sabbath days as his manner was, at Thessalonica; attending the prayer-meeting held at the river-side near Philippi on that day, and keeping seventy-eight Sabbaths at Corinth. Acts 17:4; 16:12, 13. No, friends, neither Christ nor his apostles ever thought there was any mischief wrought by keeping the fourth commandment of the Father’s law; but all the mischief arose in the making void the commandments, by the elders of the Catholic Church.