HARD ARGUMENTS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 9, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 15.

Read the full edition

HARD ARGUMENTS.

A CORRESPONDENT of the Christian Statesman, writing from the Senate Chamber, Sacramento, Cal., Feb. 21, 1889, states some interesting points in connection with the efforts made during the past winter to revive the Sunday law of that State. The defeat of the law was so overwhelming, that it was denied even a second reading, by a vote of 22 to 13. Concerning the causes which contributed to this result, he gives quite an extended notice of the S. D. Adventists and their position, in which our readers will be interested. He speaks as follows:—
The best organized and most consistent opposition to this work is that of Seventh-day Adventists. They present their arguments in a way that commends them to the minds of many men. The following conversation illustrates the arguments they use:—
Ques.—“Why do you Adventists so strenuously oppose the passage of laws against allowing saloons, prize-fights, gambling-houses, etc., to be conducted on Sunday,—take the present bill for illustration?”
Ans.—“We don’t oppose closing them up on Sunday. Close them up every day in the week, and then they will be closed up on Sunday.”
Ques.—“But isn’t it a partial victory to get them closed up one day in the week?”
Ans.—“No; not any more than it would be to have a law against murder or stealing on Sunday. A law stopping them only on Sunday is a law tacitly admitting them to be all right on other days. It gives these places that ruin our children an appearance of respectability—an apparent sanction of the law—and it makes them worse than they were before. It is on the principle of high license—one of the Devil’s most delusive traps.”
Ques.—“But do not Christians have a right to be protected in their worship on Sunday?”
Ans.—“Most assuredly they have. We have no Sunday law in this State now, yet Christians are protected in their worship. It was only the other day, as you know, one man in San Francisco was sentenced to an imprisonment of fifty days, and another to an imprisonment of thirty days, for disturbing a meeting on Sunday. Laws should protect all in their religious observances, but compel none.”
Ques.—“But why do you oppose Sunday laws when Sabbatarians are exempted?”
Ans.—“Because a person has a right to refrain from resting just as much as he has a right to rest. We are opposed for the same reason we would be opposed to laws compelling everybody to worship Christ, except those who conscientiously worship some other deity. Laws cannot of right interfere with an individual’s rights, either positively or negatively. The infidel has a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, just as much as the Christian. Says our Constitution: ‘All men are created equal.’ I wouldn’t ask for an exemption clause. If the laws are right, it is wrong to exempt. There should never be an exemption made to a just law.”
These are the arguments that have to be met. The Adventists are just about as obstinate as the traditional Quaker; and their views on religious liberty are quite similar. An Adventist would go to jail and stay there indefinitely, before he would pay what he considers to be an unjust fine. These facts and arguments are partially responsible for the course just taken by the legislature of California.
While he states that these arguments are to be met, it is noticeable that he suggests no way in which to meet them. We wait with interest to hear their answer.