THE SAVIOUR'S INTERVIEWS WITH THE DISCIPLES AFTER HIS RESURRECTION

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 30, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE SAVIOUR'S INTERVIEWS WITH THE DISCIPLES AFTER HIS RESURRECTION.

Everything in the history of our divine Lord is of deep interest to those who love him. The records of his life on earth are very brief, and we could all wish they had been more extended, had such been the will of God. But brief as they are, they contain the most instructive information ever written, which we should study with closest attention. The period of the forty days from his resurrection to his ascension is one of striking interest.
How many interviews did the Saviour have with his disciples after he rose from the dead? We are not sure that we can answer this question; yet we would be glad to shed all the light upon it possible. Was he with them all the time till he ascended? Did he absent himself from them a large portion of the time, and only appear at brief intervals, and then only for a few moments or an hour or so at a time? He seems to have been with his disciples in his earlier ministry before his crucifixion almost constantly, except when he sent them out in small parties to preach and labor. They had their periods of public labor with him, and then of private communion; and they seemed to have generally accompanied him from place to place in his labors. Did he adopt a different course after his resurrection? And if so, why? We would we were sure we could answer the queries we have raised. But it is certainly proper to obtain all the information which the sacred records have left us concerning these questions. No one of the inspired writers alone seems to give clear and specific answers to them. But by consulting all who speak upon the subject, we can increase our fund of knowledge somewhat, and yet perhaps not obtain all we should like to know on the subject.
Paul, in his discourse in the Jewish synagogue, at Antioch in Pisidia, said: “But God raised him [Jesus] from the dead. And he was seen many days of them which come up with him from Galilee to Jerusalem, who are his witnesses unto the people.” Acts 13: 30, 31. Luke says: “To whom [the apostles] also he showed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God.” Acts 1: 3. Are we to understand that he was with them all the time, or each day more or less, these “many days” or these “forty days?” or that occasionally during this period intervening between the resurrection and the ascension he appeared to them for a space? The language may not be absolutely decisive that he appeared on each and every one of these days. Yet we should most naturally understand it so, in the absence of other evidence that he was with them much of this time.
But let us notice other references to the subject. Matthew records but two meetings between Christ and his disciples after his resurrection, though he does not intimate that others might not have occurred. He states that Mary Magdalene and the other Mary who went to see the sepulcher, as it began to dawn the first day of the week, found Jesus risen, and an angel told them to go and tell the disciples of the fact, and that he would go before them into Galilee. “And as they went to tell his disciples, behold, Jesus met them, saying, All hail. And they came and held him by the feet and worshiped him. Then said Jesus unto them, Be not afraid: go tell my brethren that they go into Galilee, and there shall they see me. . . . Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them. And when they saw him, they worshiped him: but some doubted,” etc. Matt. 28: 9, 10, 16, 17. This record gives no information concerning the length of time the Saviour remained with the disciples on this occasion. It might have been days, or but a short time.
Mark mentions four instances where Jesus was with his disciples before his ascension: 1. With Mary Magdalene, “He appeared first to Mary Magdalene.” Mark 16: 9; John 21: 14–17. This must have been a distinct meeting with her alone.
Luke mentions in his gospel but four meetings with his disciples: 1. With the two on the way to Emmaus (Luke 24: 13–33); 2. His appearing to Simon Peter (verse 34) as stated by the disciples to the other two upon their return to Jerusalem; 3. His appearing in their midst as they were talking together (verse 36); 4. At his ascension. Verse 50. Luke says nothing of the visit to Galilee and of the intervening forty days between these two meetings.
John mentions but four times when Jesus met with them: 1. With Mary Magdalene (John 21: 14–17); 2. With all the disciples at even, when he said, “Peace be unto you” (verse 19), when Thomas was not with them; 3. “After eight days” he met with the disciples again, when Thomas was with them (verse 26); 4. “At the sea of Tiberias” (in Galilee) he met with seven of the disciples (chap. 21: 1, 2); viz., Simon Peter, James and John, Thomas, Nathanael, and two others, on a fishing occasion.
Luke, in the first chapter of Acts, speaks of his final meeting with them at the time of his ascension. He here recognizes the length of time between his resurrection and ascension as forty days, and states where the latter event took place; i. e., from Mount Olivet, near Jerusalem. We have then clearly presented the fact that Jesus met at first with his disciples in Jerusalem; then that both he and they were in Galilee a greater or less time; and then of their return to Jerusalem, whence he ascended to heaven.
St. Paul adds interesting items to this list of interviews. “For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures; and that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the Scriptures: and that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve. After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once, of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep. After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles. And last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.” 1 Cor. 15: 3–8. The apostle doubtless here refers to the time when, on the road to Damascus, Christ said, “Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?” Acts 9: 4; 22: 7. So far as we know, these present all the recorded instances of Christ's presenting himself to his disciples subsequent to his resurrection, unless we include cases of heavenly vision. Let us now arrange these, as well as we can, in their order:—
1. “He appeared to Mary Magdalene.” Mark 16: 9; John 21: 14–17. This must have been a distinct meeting with her alone.
2. He met with the other holy women on their return from the sepulcher. Matt. 28: 9, 10.
3. With Simon Peter. Luke 24: 34; 1 Cor. 15: 5.
4. With Cephas and the other disciple on the way to Emmaus. Luke 24: 13–33; Mark 16: 12. We cannot be positively certain which of these two meetings was first in order of time.
5. With all of the apostles except Thomas, at about the close of the day of the resurrection. Mark 16: 14; Luke 24: 36; John 21: 19; 1 Cor. 15: 5.
6. With Thomas and the other apostles “after eight days,” when Thomas was reproved for his unbelief. John 21: 26.
7. With seven disciples at the sea of Tiberias, when a miraculous draught of fishes was made. John 21: 1–21. This is said to be “the third time that Jesus showed himself to his disciples after he was risen from the dead.” Verse 14. We must understand by this, perhaps, his showing himself to the larger portion of them, as we see is true of the two preceding occasions.
8. He showed himself to “above five hundred brethren at once.” 1 Cor. 15: 6. Perhaps this occurred in Galilee. We cannot be certain, however, where or when, as the record makes no other mention of it.
9. “After that he was seen of James.” 1 Cor. 15: 7. This meeting seems not to have been mentioned elsewhere.
10. A meeting of the eleven apostles at a mountain in Galilee, where Jesus had appointed to meet with them. Matt. 28: 16, 17; 1 Cor. 15: 7. It is possible this may have been the same meeting which John mentions, where Thomas was present and was reproved for his unbelief, as Matthew says, “Some doubted.” Yet it seems, from the language of John, that the meeting with Thomas occurred at Jerusalem; for he speaks of “the doors being shut,” and all the disciples being “within,” using the same language as he did concerning his first meeting with the apostles, when he said, “Peace be unto you.” They were then in their hired room at Jerusalem, and closed their doors “for fear of the Jews.” We think therefore this must have been another meeting in Galilee.
11. A meeting upon their return to Jerusalem from Galilee, ten days before the Pentecost, when Jesus was with his disciples imparting encouragement and instruction, and promising them the gift of the Holy Spirit, at which time he led them out as far as Bethany upon the mount of Olives, and then ascended in their sight. Acts 1: 3–12; Luke 24: 50; Mark 16: 19.
12. His meeting with Paul on the road to Damascus. Acts 9: 4; 22: 7.
Here we have twelve distinct instances mentioned in the record, where Christ was seen after his resurrection, by one or more of his disciples, and at one time as many as five hundred of them saw him at once. Can we be sure these instances were all that actually occurred? We see no reason for drawing such a conclusion. None of the evangelists claim to have mentioned all the instances, Matthew giving only two of them, Mark four, Luke four, John four, and Paul six. And in these cases they do not mention always the same occasions. Their object seems to have been to give merely enough to establish the fact of our Lord's resurrection beyond question, rather than to extend the number of meetings as far as possible. Why, then, should we conclude that there were actually but these recorded interviews? For our part we think the probabilities are, that they saw him many other times than those mentioned.
Paul's statement (Acts 13: 31) that Christ was seen of them “many days,” and Luke's assurance that he was “seen of them forty days” naturally intimate that he was with them much more. Yet we cannot reasonably conclude that he was with them all the time for forty days. For Matthew states that he made an appointment at Jerusalem to meet them at a certain mountain in Galilee. While John informs us that the meeting at the lake of Tiberias, which must have occurred after Thomas was reproved (i. e., eight days after the resurrection, with time added to make the journey from Jerusalem to Galilee) was his third meeting with the disciples. Very likely he was with them in a private manner considerably in Galilee, giving them such instruction as they needed. How gladly would we know how this time was spent, and what was said to them, or whether he permitted them to talk with him freely! But the Lord has seen fit to give us but a brief insight into this most interesting period. How precious must have been these interviews and experiences to the poor disappointed disciples who had seen their blessed Lord crucified! What courage came into their hearts! As said the two disciples, “Did not our hearts burn within us while he talked with us by the way?” What a precious experience indeed when he opened “their understanding, that they might understand the Scriptures,” and when he breathed upon them the Holy Spirit. Now the mysteries they could not understand before, cleared away like the fog on a summer's morning; and they could comprehend the great scheme of human salvation. Our Saviour's great work was now clear before them. Their hearts were full of courage and bright hope. With the blessed assurance that he would pour upon them the Spirit, and ever give it to them as a Comforter, they could now labor with faith and courage. They lived with a consciousness of their Saviour's companionship through that Spirit's influence, wherever they might be. He would not leave them comfortless, and even in prisons, suffering unjust punishment, or facing death, was he not ever present?
Yes, that forty days was a most blessed experience, preparing them for their future work, as soon as the Spirit should be poured out in its fullness. We never before realized it meant so much, or that Jesus was with them so constantly. How foolish, in view of the facts, appear the claims of Sunday advocates who pretend that every meeting of Christ with his disciples occurred on the first day of the week? There is not a hint in the record that he met on that day, except upon the first day after his resurrection. He doubtless met with them “many days” during the interval of forty days before ascending. We may well thank God that we can have precious experiences of Christ's presence through his Spirit as the time draws near for his return. Thank God that we are near the second great outpouring of his Spirit in the “latter rain;” and that soon we shall meet that blessed Saviour, to spend an eternity in his loving presence. May the Lord hasten the day. G. I. B.