In the Michigan Christian Advocate of June 1, 1889, Mr. Wilbur F. Crafts makes a vigorous onslaught upon the counter-petitions against the Sunday-rest bill, circulated by S. D. Adventists. As a specimen of transparent sophistry, his effort is rarely equaled. He first gives the petition which is being circulated by Adventists, and then gives the Sunday petition as follows:—
“The original petition, which has called forth the above counter-petition, is as follows:—
“‘The undersigned, adult residents of the United States, twenty-one years of age or more, hereby earnestly petition your honorable body to pass a bill, forbidding, in the nation’s mail and military service and in interstate commerce, and in the District of Columbia and the Territories, all Sunday traffic and work, except works of religion and works of real necessity and mercy, and such private work by those who observe another day as will neither interfere with the general rest nor with public worship.’
“Certainly it would take more than an ordinary microscope to find in the petition just given, the conspiracies against American principles which the counter-petition first quoted leads its reader to expect.
“The counter-petition is not technically a falsehood, but it is certainly calculated to give the false impression (which, on the lips of those who circulate this counter-petition, becomes more than implication), that the petition which millions of us have been urging before the National Congress, includes a proposition to enforce ‘Sabbath observance’ as a ‘religious or ecclesiastical institution or rite,’ and also a proposition to weaken the present guarantees of our Constitution against a union of Church and State! Both of these implications are absurdly false. Our petition is headed: ‘For a Sunday-rest bill,’ and simply asks a law to protect the people in their right to the weekly day of rest, without requiring of any one a religious observance of the day, and without hindering those who observe another day from either worshiping on that day or working on the first day of the week—unless the work be of such a nature, shop-keeping for instance, as will interfere with the general rest.”
Again, he says: “Out of the millions who have petitioned for a national Sunday-rest law, only a few thousand have asked for the ‘Blair Sunday Rest Bill.’”
Thus Mr. Crafts would keep out of sight the connection between the Sunday petition, and the Blair Sunday-rest bill, in Congress, and then represent that our petition can have reference to nothing else but the Sunday petition, and that is a very innocent affair, requiring nothing to interfere with anybody or anything, hence our petition is a groundless scare, a deception and a fraud.
Let us analyze the wonderful representation a little. Only a few thousand, he says, have asked for the Blair bill. But if the petition claimed to have been signed by 14,000,000 people were not in favor of the Blair bill, and understood to be so, we would like to know why the papers containing these signatures were trundled into Congress by the wheelbarrow load, to bring to bear an overwhelming influence upon that body, while the Blair bill was pending. These were not asking for the Blair bill(?); oh, no! From what did the Blair bill and the Blair amendment spring? Of what movement were they a part? They sprung from the movement which called for the petition in question; they were a part of that movement; they constituted the channel in which the great petition was assuming tangible form, and leading to practical results. And now what matters the particular phraseology of the petition, when its fruits were appearing so plainly in Congress? And did our petition have any reference to the mere points stated in the Sunday petition?—Not at all, but to the movement which that petition was understood to support, and to the fruit which that movement was sure to bear if it should ever prove successful. Will Mr. Crafts deny that there was anything going on in Congress to which such a petition as we were circulating would apply? If not, then his article is simply an attempt to divert attention from the real issue, and mislead the minds of his readers in regard to our work.
We look not merely to the Sunday petition, but to the work in Congress, both present and prospective; and our petition is not worded so as to be confined specifically even to the Blair bill, but so as to cover the whole principle involved in the question. It will therefore be equally applicable to any bill which may be framed on the subject. Let the petitions be still vigorously circulated, that they may be ready when the question is re-opened in Congress, as beyond doubt it will be at the first opportunity after the opening of the next session.