AdventAI

A VOICE FROM THE WORKINGMEN.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 28., July 9, 1889

One of the strongest points which the National Reformers attempt to make in behalf of a Sunday law, is that the workingmen may be secured in their right to a day of rest; and the plea over which they succeed in arousing the largest amount of sympathy, is that the workingmen themselves are groaning under their restrictions in this respect, and urgently implore them to press the matter forward to a successful issue. They would represent their work therefore as not only one of religion, but one of humanity and mercy as well.

When this plea is probed till we reach a basis of fact, it generally turns out that these so-called reformers have first to go to the workingmen, and labor long and earnestly with them, to bring them to even a nominal indorsement of their movement (and they do not always succeed in this); and then they go forth and represent that they are simply responding to a cry of humanity from the poor workingmen, and that Congress and the country should immediately come to their relief in the passage of a Sunday law. They have seemed to be oblivious to the fact that such a game might miscarry; for the workingmen are capable of speaking for themselves, and they might sometime choose to do so.

In the article which we present below, we have the sentiments of at least one organization of workingmen expressed in very unmistakable terms. It seems that J. P. Mills, Ohio State Secretary of the American Sabbath Union, and editor of the Herald of Reform (an organ of the National Reform party, published in Cleveland, O.), replied to an article from the Cleveland Secular Union, in the Cleveland Plaindealer of June 6. In the same paper of the following day was published the following answer by the Union to the article of Mr. Mills. The answer shows that the workingmen clearly understand the theological status of the Sunday institution; and while they desire a day of relaxation from business, and a day of recreation, they have no sympathy with the attempts which are made to throw over it a religious mantle, nor with the general line upon which the National Reformers are working. They say:—

“Sir: In the first place we would put you at ease regarding the authorship of our first communication. It was written by a member of the Secular Union, and sanctioned by the officers. If it contained ‘nothing new or meritorious,’ and needs ‘no answering before intelligent people,’ one might wonder why you answered it. Great art thou, O consistency. But we are glad you did, because when intelligent people understand the animus of your movement, you will not have their support.

“The contest is between the ministry and the rest of mankind. The movement is against so-called Sabbath desecration. The point we made was that the observance of Sunday as a Sabbath is an ecclesiastical institution without scriptural sanction, and that Sunday is no holier than any other day. We simply protested against the forging longer of God’s name to a theological contrivance. You know this, and that our claims cannot be answered; so, as a pretext, you profess great philanthropy and solicitude for the workingmen. The immorality of those engaged in this contest, either pro or con, has nothing to do with the question, and is brought in only as a subterfuge. We are not working against the Blair bill and Sunday movement for the reason that a large percentage of those in the ministry are immoral persons, but because its triumph means the violation of the rights of the citizens, and the worst kind of despotism—theological—and religious persecution.

“Evading the real issue, because you cannot answer us, you attempt to place us in a false light by imputing that we do not desire cessation from labor; that we are in favor of seven days’ work in the week. This blind will not work. We are as desirous as you of a day of rest, but we protest against your dictating, with the aid of civil legislation in what manner we shall rest. You are trying to compel people to rest (?) in church by making it unlawful to do anything Sunday but attend church. That may be your idea of rest, and we are perfectly willing for you to spend your Sundays that way; but we claim the same right of deciding for ourselves how we shall rest. To those who toil in shops and factories, and drudge away the hours in misty offices, recreation is rest. They are rested, invigorated, and refreshed by walking and riding, by innocent games, by trips into the country among the flowers and brooks and birds, where the air is pure and the sky blue. Sunday is the only day the working people have for these pleasures; but you and your confraternity, by pretended sympathy and spurious offers of aid, would rob these same workingfolk of these sources of enjoyment and rest. All this under the guise of friendship. For shame! That is what the Blair bill means, and more. It means that these locomotive engineers, who have children they ‘desire to educate in everything that will make them good men and women,’ will find all places of education, such as museums, art rooms, historical rooms, libraries, etc., closed and barred against their educational desires on that day. It means that you can preach from your pulpits on Sundays for big salaries, but the little newsboys competing with you by trying to earn a few pennies from the sale of papers, may be locked up in jail.

“If you are so desirous of helping the workingmen and women, why do you not try to lessen their week-day hours of labor; why do you not open to them the museums and libraries and music rooms the only day they have for such things?—Because it would draw from your congregations and lessen your salaries. You fear honest competition, and hope, by means of that iniquitous measure concocted by the gentleman from New Hampshire, to put under ban everything but church-going, so that your empty pews will be filled and your revenues increased.

“You will fail, sir. A religion that cannot stand on its merits, but must needs be crowded upon people by law, carries in its bosom the seeds of its own destruction. Let the working people, whose co-operation you boast of, once understand that the Blair bill forbids that ‘any person engage in any play, game, or amusement, or recreation’ on Sunday, and then see how they will stand on the question. We do not think they will be willing to exchange, nor submit to be forced into exchanging, their recreation for the questionable rest of listening to sermons presenting matters more ‘stale’ even than the argument of our former article.

“CLEVELAND SECULAR UNION.

“Cleveland, O., June 7, 1889.”