ILLOGICAL

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 3, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 35.

Read the full edition

ILLOGICAL

REV. J. M. FOSTER, of Cincinnati, Ohio, in the Christian Statesman of April 18, 1889, says:—
Man has an inalienable right to the seventh part of time for rest. The Government as the institution of human rights should secure this right. That would prohibit all common labor on the Sabbath.
Not exactly. The conclusion is by no means a logical deduction from the premises laid down. That man has a right not only to a part of his time but to all of it, to use as he sees fit, is undoubtedly true. This being the case, he of course has a right to a seventh part of it, or any other part of it, for rest. (Most men usually take about a third of it—eight hours sleep a day—for this purpose.) The Government should and does secure this right. But it does not follow that all common labor is prohibited on the Sabbath therefore.
Reasoning conversely, men have an inalienable right to work six-sevenths of their time. Should the Government secure this right, there would be no resting except on the Sabbath,—no vacations, no holidays, simply work! Will Mr. Foster accept of his logic, or tell us where our reasoning is defective and not at the same time demolish his own?
Mr. Foster evidently has a very erroneous idea of what it is for the Government to “secure” to men their rights, or at least uses the term in a grossly perverted sense. To him it appears to have the meaning of enforcing on men their rights. Herein lies the germ of all the monstrous evils growing out of the National Reform idea of government. By hook or crook they manage to form a plausible argument which involves compulsory religious legislation. But all should remember that the argument is faulty at its very foundation.
Mr. Foster’s logic would lead to many other erroneous conclusions. Man has an inalienable right to attend church. The Government should secure to him his inalienable rights. If it should do this, it would prohibit any one from remaining away from church!
Man has an inalienable right to pray. The Government should secure to man his inalienable rights. That would prohibit men from being prayerless!
These conclusions are unavoidable if Mr. Foster’s reasoning in the above quotation is correct. But if his reasoning is incorrect and illogical, so is also the whole system of National Reformism; for that is founded on the very theory involved in his reasoning. Their idea of securing to men their rights is destructive of those rights.
W. A. C.