THE LAW AND LIFE

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 6, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 32.

Read the full edition

THE LAW AND LIFE.

IN reference to a remark in the REVIEW of July 2, that when the Scriptures speak of a law being given which could not give life, they cannot refer to the moral law, inasmuch as that law was ordained to life, and if man never had broken it, would have given him life, a brother writes: “Did not the Creator give man life, and direct him to maintain that life in obedience to the law?”
We had never supposed the expression would be taken as teaching that the law took the place of the Creator, and gave man existence. God is the author of man’s being. He placed him upon probation, gave him a law, a rule of life, by which to regulate his conduct, and put him under the one condition: Obey, and live.
It is a common and a correct expression that man in the beginning had life and death set before him: the one he would secure by obedience; the other would be his portion by transgression. But in what sense is the word “life” to be taken in this expression?—Not in the sense of man’s original creation, his present physical existence; for God had given him that already. But it looked forward into the future, and had reference to a perpetuation of that life, a confirmation to a never-ending existence, or immortality. And if man never had sinned, and had reached this condition on this line—God’s original plan—what might be said to have given him this life?—Compliance with the condition, obedience, or the law which would have stood as a witness of his righteousness.
This our brother virtually admits, himself; for he adds: “Man failed to be obedient, and forfeited to the law the life that was given him.” Exactly; but how could he forfeit it to the law, if the law was not the arbiter of that life. What demands, and takes, the life of the transgressor?—The law. Then on the supposition that man never had transgressed, what would have given him life?—The law. Of course, after man sinned, the situation was all changed; for no law can give life to its transgressor. But the moral law was given before this change took place, when man might have gained eternal life by his obedience. Now the expression, “If there had been a law given which could have given life,” must apply to whatever law is referred to, at the time it was given. Therefore we say that it cannot refer to the moral law; for that was given before man had forfeited his life, and when it was designed to give life, and would have given him life, if he had always kept it. It must refer to some law which has come in subsequently, after man had forfeited his life by transgression, and needed to have it given back to him. But no law has been “given” (which must be understood in the sense “originated”) since the introduction of sin, except that involved in a remedial system.
But, says another, even if Adam had always been obedient, he would not even then have had life by the law, but by righteousness; and God gave him the righteousness when he created him. We must beg leave to differ. At the moment of Adam’s creation, he was neither righteous nor unrighteous, he had no character; in all this respect he was a blank. God made him innocent; he could not have made him otherwise. The Scriptures express it thus: “God hath made man upright;” that is, he was upright as he entered upon life. But righteousness is “right-doing,” and could not be manifested in Adam’s case till he had “done” something. Then if what he did was in accordance with law, so far he was righteous; and so long as he lived thus, so long he was righteous; and if he had always lived thus, he would always have been righteous; and in this case righteousness would have been by the law; and as righteousness and life go together, life would have been by the law also.