THE OLD COVENANT NOT THE TEN COMMANDMENTS.
By N. J. Bowers
Many who oppose the ancient Sabbath seek to excuse themselves from its obligations, by contending that the ten commandments comprise the old covenant, or that they are that covenant at least in part; and as the old covenant has long since passed away, the Sabbath, being a part, has passed away with it. The object of the present article is to show the falsity of this view. The ten commandments, it is true, are called the covenant (Ex. 34:28); but never “the old covenant” nor the “covenant made with the fathers,” and like expressions. These forms of speech abound in antinomian and anti-Sabbath literature, but never in the Bible. The decalogue is called the covenant because it contains the terms of agreement entered into by Israel when the covenant was made with them in Horeb. This is the secondary sense attached to the word by Mr. Webster; that is, it means “a writing containing the terms of agreement or contract between parties.” There was a contract or agreement entered into on the part of God and Israel recorded in Ex. 19:1–8. This is the primary definition of the word—agreement, contract, or stipulation. A covenant complete would comprehend both meanings; but the word applies to either element—to the contract simple, and to the terms of the contract; so the decalogue can properly be called the covenant. The following facts show that the old, or first, covenant was not the ten commandments in part or in whole:— 1. The ten commandments were in existence long before the covenant was made. 1 John 3:4; Rom. 4:15; 5:12–14; Gen. 4:7, 8; 6:5, 11–13; 13:13; 2 Pet. 2:7, 8. The covenant was made at Sinai, or Horeb, after the deliverance from Egypt. Deut. 5:2–4. Jer. 31:32. Heb. 8:9. The covenant, we see, was made (Ex. 19:1–8) some three months after the people left the land of bondage. The ten commandments were of binding obligation long before they ever went into that land. Especially was the Sabbath (which our opponents seek early and late to get rid of, and which is the sole occasion of the bitter war waged against the ten commandments in the stand they take on the covenant) known and observed by them before the making of the old covenant was entered upon. Read Ex. 16. Then it certainly did not owe its obligation to that covenant. 2. The people agreed to obey God’s voice and keep his covenant before they heard it. This voice proclaimed the ten commandments. Deut. 4:12, 13, 33, 36; 5:22; 9:9, 10. God’s covenant was these commandments. Deut. 4:13. Does580 not this, then, all seem natural, that the people should give so ready a consent to obey the voice and keep the covenant, on the supposition that they had a previous knowledge of the ten commandments? Would they reasonably have been so ready to obey had they been ignorant of what the Lord’s covenant was? 3. The made covenant was not the ten commandments, according to Ex. 24:7, 8. That covenant was concerning the words the Lord had spoken. Now the covenant made with the people, and the words concerning or relating to it, must be two things certainly. To illustrate: A conversation about Abraham Lincoln is certainly a thing distinct from him, though relating to or concerning him. A conversation in regard to the nature of an agreement between parties about the renting or the leasing of property, is assuredly a matter distinct from the property itself, though relating to or concerning it. The conversation between God and Israel, embodying the nature of a covenant or agreement, was most assuredly a thing wholly and decidedly distinct from the words concerning which the covenant was made. The words spoken were the ten commandments. These words were one and the principal thing. The covenant (the agreement on the part of God and that on the part of the people) was another thing and related to or concerned these words. A plain difference. 4. The old covenant was made with the people. Deut. 5:2–4; Jer. 31:32; Heb. 8:9. This implies co-operation. “With” shows that the people had something to do in the matter. This covenant, then, was not the ten commandments. The people did not help make them. They had nothing to do in this direction. They had no part nor lot in such work. The ten commandments did not depend for their existence on the will and action of the people, but the made covenant did. God is the sole author of the ten commandments; God and the people, of the made covenant. The people had nothing to do with the ten commandments but to obey them. Had the people refused to have the covenant made with them, there would have been none made. Does any one suppose that if the Lord had proposed to the people to assist in getting up the ten commandments, and they had refused, that there would have been none? Notwithstanding these plain facts, some may claim that Deut. 9:9 does teach that the commanded covenant was made with the people: “When I was gone up into the mount to receive the tables of stone, even the tables of the covenant which the Lord made with you,” etc. This language teaches not that the covenant on stone, the ten commandments, was made with the people, but that these tables contained that which was the basis or conditions of the covenant made. The words the Lord commanded Moses to write in Ex. 34:27 are those beginning with verse 10 and ending with verse 26. They relate to moral duties, attending the yearly feasts, offerings, etc. Moses did not write on the tables of stone in verse 28. The pronoun he relates to the Lord. See verses 1, 2 of this chapter, and Deut. 10:1–4. 5. The old covenant was made with the Jewish people. It was theirs in a special sense. The ten commandments are not Jewish. They are not theirs in any special sense, but they, embodying moral principles, are for all nations. Rom. 3:19; 1 Tim. 1:9–11. 6. The first, or old, covenant was based upon promises. Heb. 8:7, 8; Eph. 2:12. Thus the real nature of a covenant is shown. It is synonymous with contract, which Mr. Webster says is a “mutual promise.” The old covenant promised something. Ex. 19:5, 6. The ten commandments are not established upon promises, but upon the authority of God. A covenant comprehends a promise or promises; therefore there can be no covenant without them. The ten commandments are, in the very nature of the case, not promises, but moral obligations. In obeying them we do not keep so many promises, but discharge certain duties. True, there are promises belonging to them to incite to obedience, but the commandments themselves are not promises. 7. The old covenant was not faultless nor perfect. Its sacrifices could not and did not take away sin. It pointed to perfection, but was not perfection itself. It led the people on and prepared them for better things. It was an instructor with limited powers, teaching the people in its range. It did not impart the full knowledge which the instructor beyond and in after time, the new covenant, did. The ten commandments are perfection. Perfect they are in their brief fullness and in their comprehensive sweep. They are perfect in their power to convert the soul. Ps. 19:7. They are “holy, just, and good;” “spiritual;” and to the apostle they were a “delight.” Rom. 7:12, 14, 22. They convince us of sin and will judge us at last. James 2:9–12. 9. Under the new covenant the law is written in the mind. Jer. 31:33; Heb. 8:10. Thus the ten commandments are nearer the believer under the gospel than they were under the old dispensation. Now, they are in the heart; then, they were on tables of stone. 2 Cor. 3:3. The law is the basis of both covenants. It sustains to them the relation of the foundation to the house built on it; remove the house, and the foundation remains for another structure to be erected thereon. The foundation of the old covenant remained when that covenant vanished in the light and glory of the new; and it, with pillars and domes of beauty, rests on that same solid base. 10. Jesus took away the first, or old, covenant that he might establish the second, or new. Heb. 10:9. This covenant was not the ten commandments. They are not taken away, but are themselves established by the gospel, according to Rom. 3:31; Matt. 5:17–20; so they are not the same. 11. The old covenant was made with the people. The decalogue covenant was commanded to them. Deut. 5:3; 4:13. 12. The apostle Paul makes a plain distinction between the covenants and the law. Rom. 9:4. To briefly recapitulate: (1) The word covenant has two meanings; viz., (a) a contract or agreement with mutual promises; (b) the conditions upon which the contract is based. The covenant made, answers to the first definition; the covenant commanded, to the second. (2) The ten commandments were in existence long years before the covenant was made. Notably was the observance of the Sabbath enjoined and engaged in by the people before they came to Sinai, where the old covenant was made. (3) The people agreeing to obey the Lord’s voice and keep his covenant, or ten commandments, before they had heard him utter them, would show that they had a knowledge of these precepts. Their prompt and ready promise evinces this. (4) The covenant made with the people, and the “words” or ten commandments concerning which the covenant was made, serves to plainly mark them different. (5) The old covenant was made with the people; that is, they co-operated with God in making it. This shows that the covenant was not the ten commandments, as they did not depend upon any human assent or help for their existence. (6) The old covenant was Jewish, was theirs especially. The ten commandments do not belong especially to the Jews, but are the precepts of morality, binding on all alike. (7) The old covenant was established upon promises. The ten commandments are not promises, but moral requirements. (8) The old covenant was not a perfect system, relatively. The ten commandments are complete in their perfection, and perfect in their completeness. (9) The ten commandments are in the new covenant, and so they are not the old covenant. This covenant was not merged into the new, but having waxed old, vanished away. The law is in the heart of the real Christian under the new covenant, and he delights to keep it. Rom. 7:22, 25. (10) Jesus took away the first covenant that he might establish the second or the new. This is not the ten commandments, as they were not taken away but established. Rom. 3:31. (11) The old covenant was made with Israel. The ten commandments were proclaimed to them. (12) The apostle states that to Israel pertained the covenants and the giving of the law. Both covenants, the old and the new, were made with the Jews. The covenants were one thing, the law another. The distinction is preserved here by the apostle between the covenants and the ten commandments. They are not the same.