AdventAI

“HE CANNOT SIN.”

By Dudley Marvin Canright

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 37., September 15, 1885

This expression in 1 John 3:9 is taken by the perfectionists and “holiness” people to prove that a man who is born of God, or converted absolutely, cannot sin. Upon this and similar expressions are built their theories of living without sin. It would be an excellent thing if their practice only corresponded with their theory; but it does not; for the men who make the strongest claims on this point are the poorest Christians. They are generally high-headed, pompous, and full of self-praise.

In order to explain this text, it is not necessary to claim that it refers to the future life, that “being born of God” means being raised in the resurrection. It means no such thing; it means just what we call conversion. If we examine the Scriptures on the use of the word “cannot,” they will readily show that it is very often used in an accommodated sense, meaning “will not.” Thus Young’s Concordance, under the heading, “Helps to Bible Interpretation,” says: “Cannot in the Scripture idiom frequently means will not.” Then quite a large number of quotations are given to support it. Let us look at some of them. Laban said to Abraham’s servant, “We cannot speak unto thee bad or good.” Gen. 24:50. Did he mean that it was impossible to do it? Certainly not. Joseph’s brethren “could not speak peaceably unto him.” Gen. 37:4. Benjamin’s brethren said, “The lad cannot leave his father.” Gen. 44:22. And again: “We cannot go down.” Verse 26. In all these cases it is evident that this was merely a strong way of speaking to convey the idea of how very hard it would be for them to do such a thing. Again it is said: “The Egyptians could not drink of the water.” Ex. 7:21. And, “They are all dumb dogs, they cannot bark.” Isa. 56:10. Why could they not bark? The prophet goes on to say that they are all sleepy, lazy dogs. The Lord says of the wicked Jews, “Their ear is uncircumcised, and they cannot hearken.” Jer. 6:10. Could they not have hearkened if they had wished to? So we might give scores of instances just like these. For instance, see Mark 6:5; Luke 11:7; John 5:19, 30; 7:7; 8:43; Rom. 8:7, 8; 1 Cor. 2:14; 2 Cor. 13:8; 2 Tim. 2:13; Heb. 5:2; Rev. 2:2.

The fact is, it is the common way of speaking when we wish to express ourselves strongly. I say, “I cannot go to town to-day because my horse is lame.” Would any one understand me to mean that it was utterly impossible for me to go? No, and when John says that the converted man “cannot sin,” he means that sin is so distasteful to his feelings that he will not do it. But that very same John said in the same epistle, “If any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father.” D. M. CANRIGHT.