THE IOWA STATE SUNDAY CONVENTION

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 3, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 48.

Read the full edition

THE IOWA STATE SUNDAY CONVENTION.

The second annual meeting of the Iowa Sabbath Association was held in Des Moines, according to appointment, Nov. 12, 13. The topics for discussion included nearly all the different phases of the question of Sunday rest, and so far as the original program was carried out, the papers and addresses bore evidence of much care in their preparation. To the interested spectator, however, there were several noticeable features worthy of special mention:—
1. Manifest indifference and lack of enthusiasm. Although the association has been in active operation for over two years, and its members are found in every part of the State; and although on the program were such names as Mr. Victor Lawson, of the Chicago News, Rev. Chas. A. Blanchard, President of the National Sabbath Union, Rev. M. A. Gault, Mrs. J. Ellen Foster, Gov. Larrabee, Hon. John Malin, President Gates, of Grinnell College, and others equally prominent, and although the announcement of the meeting was given the widest circulation by all the leading papers of the State, yet there were not over twenty-five in attendance from outside the city, and by actual count less than forty attended the opening session, and not more than double this number were present the first evening. The second day’s attendance was somewhat better. On a par with the attendance was the evident lack of enthusiasm of those who were present. The papers read for the most part elicited little or no comment, and even the most active appeared much less ardent than these “Sabbath-reform” gentlemen usually are. Perhaps this was due, in part at least, to the peculiar combination of circumstances that presented itself, not anticipated.
2. Lack of unity as to the moral obligation of the Sabbath. While one speaker argued in the strongest terms the holy and divine character of the Sabbath, and quoted the fourth commandment in support of the same, another, President Gates, declared that it was superstition and heathenism for him to regard any one day more holy than another, only as he put it to a different use. Another paper read, took the position that a man must certainly be insane to think for a moment that the law of God in toto is any less binding on this generation than it was on the Israelites, while by another speaker it was declared that if we are to be guided in all particulars by the “law of Moses,” then surely the seventh-day advocates have, as the boys say, “got us.”
3. Perhaps the most striking feature of the entire convention was the evident desire for a change of tactics as to what should constitute the basis of the Sunday-rest legislation. This was not clearly brought to the surface till the committee on resolutions, of which Mr. Gault was chairman, brought in its report. All went well till the following resolution was read:—
Resolved, That while we recognize the value of arguments for the Sabbath from expediency and physical health, still we urge that the State, in order to reach the citizen’s conscience, must recognize God’s authority behind the law.
No sooner was this read than the entire aspect of the association changed. New life entered into it. A half dozen were on their feet at once, and one rarely hears more vehement protestations than came from these delegates in the discussion of this resolution. The presiding officer said that he was strongly opposed to placing this work on any such basis. Said he, “The reason there are not more present here to-day, is because the people have an idea that we are a set of cranks, and want to legislate them into religion.” Rev. J. K. Fowler declared: “It is time we had done arguing for Sabbath legislation before Congress and other civil bodies on the plea of its supposed divine institution and scriptural authority. It is utterly untenable according to the spirit of our charters of Government.” “No man,” said another speaker, “has a right to coerce my religious convictions by the arm of the civil law. I would not submit to it. I would die first.” Dr. Frisbie, of the First Congregational Church of Des Moines, declared in the most positive manner that he was opposed to anything whatsoever that savored of religious legislation, but thought that if such a law was enacted, it should be on such a broad basis that all could stand on it. Although counter-arguments to this position were adduced, yet with but little effect; and after nearly two hours’ running discussion of this kind, they adjourned to take up the further consideration of the resolution; but when the resolutions were called for in the next meeting, in some mysterious manner this one was dropped, and in its place was another, with the objectionable feature expunged, and it passed without comment.
It seemed to be the idea of the majority of the convention that the Sunday-rest law should be placed on the same basis as any other National holiday, stripping it entirely of its religious character, so far as its enforcement was concerned. In other words, the law should be so framed that a man could have the privilege of resting on Sunday if he cared to, but should not be compelled to observe that day as a religious duty. This law, then, would be in the interests of those in the employ of corporate and other bodies demanding seven days’ work, where now for a man to refuse to comply with the demand, means a sacrifice of his position.
There were a number of other interesting features of the convention, that space will not permit me to mention. The Sunday newspapers and Sunday running of trains received the hardest blows. President Blanchard stated that he “would rather swear for half an hour than to buy a Sunday newspaper for a minute.” Rev. M. A. Gault, in the opening part of his address, spoke of Puritanism, and wished there might be a shower of it all over Iowa; for there was need of it. The following was one of the resolutions adopted:—
Resolved, That in the preservation of the Sabbath as a civil institution, we do not oppress the consciences of those who observe the seventh day.
In personal conversation with several members of the convention, they appeared to be actuated by a different spirit from that manifested by most of those engaged in this movement. They certainly could see the lameness of the position heretofore held, of basing the enforcement of the civil law on moral obligation; and whether the change of tactics was because of their desire to infringe on the rights of no one, or whether it was to avoid a vulnerable point, is left for others to judge.
After the address of President Gates, in which he denounced so severely any attempt to coerce the religious convictions of any man by civil law, and urged that if such a law were passed, the moral phase of the question should be left out entirely, Mr. Gault privately upbraided him by saying that he reminded him of an experience he once had when he was in Kansas. Just before giving an address, the temperance people came to him, and begged that he say nothing about Mr. St. John, as he was in disrepute there, and was not their recognized leader. “So,” said Mr. Gault, “we have Jesus for our leader, but in this work you want to leave him out entirely, as though he were in disrepute.” The answer that President Gates gave him was, “I do not so consider it.” W. E. CORNELL.